Unlawful Object Under Contract Law

Published: 7 min read

Meaning of Unlawful Object

Under Indian contract law, the object of an agreement refers to the purpose or objective for which the parties enter into the agreement.

An unlawful object is a purpose that falls within the categories of unlawfulness specified under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.

The object of an agreement must be lawful for the agreement to be enforceable. Even if the parties freely consent to an arrangement, the agreement cannot ordinarily be enforced when its purpose is unlawful.

Example: A agrees to pay B ₹50,000 to bribe a public official to secure a government contract. The purpose of the agreement is unlawful, so the agreement is void under Section 23.

Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872

Section 23 provides that the consideration or object of an agreement is lawful unless it falls within one or more of the specified categories of unlawfulness.

The object or consideration is unlawful if:

  1. It is forbidden by law.
  2. It would defeat the provisions of any law if permitted.
  3. It is fraudulent.
  4. It involves or implies injury to the person or property of another.
  5. The court regards it as immoral.
  6. The court regards it as opposed to public policy.

An agreement whose object is unlawful is void under Section 23.

Grounds of Unlawful Object

1. Object Forbidden by Law

An object is unlawful when the purpose of the agreement involves something expressly prohibited by applicable law.

Example: A agrees to pay B to sell prohibited substances in violation of the applicable law.

The agreement is void because its object is forbidden by law.

2. Object That Defeats the Provisions of Law

An agreement may be unlawful even if it does not expressly require the commission of an illegal act. If its purpose would defeat the provisions of an applicable law, Section 23 may apply.

Example: A and B enter into an arrangement designed to circumvent a statutory restriction on the transfer of property.

If the arrangement defeats the purpose of the relevant law, the agreement may be void.

3. Fraudulent Object

An object is unlawful when the agreement is intended to facilitate fraud or deception.

Example: A agrees to pay B to prepare false documents to deceive a bank into approving a loan.

The agreement is void because its purpose is fraudulent.

4. Object Involving Injury to a Person or Property

An agreement is unlawful when its object involves or implies injury to another person’s body or property.

Example: A promises to pay B to damage C’s vehicle.

The object is unlawful because the agreement is intended to cause injury to another person’s property.

Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.

Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.

Join WhatsApp Channel

5. Object Regarded as Immoral by the Court

Section 23 also covers objects that the court regards as immoral within the meaning of the provision.

Whether an agreement falls into this category depends on the applicable legal principles and the circumstances of the transaction.

Example: An agreement whose purpose involves an arrangement treated by law as immoral may be unenforceable under Section 23.

Not every socially controversial or personal arrangement automatically falls within this category.

6. Object Opposed to Public Policy

An object is unlawful if it is opposed to public policy.

Public policy protects the public interest, the administration of justice and the proper functioning of legal institutions. Courts apply this ground carefully because an excessively broad interpretation could create uncertainty in contractual dealings.

Example: A agrees to pay B for improperly influencing a judicial officer to secure a favourable decision.

Such an agreement undermines the administration of justice and is opposed to public policy.

Difference Between Unlawful Object and Unlawful Consideration

Although Section 23 deals with both concepts, they focus on different aspects of an agreement.

BasisUnlawful ObjectUnlawful Consideration
MeaningThe purpose of the agreement is unlawfulThe promised act, abstinence or exchange is unlawful
FocusWhat the parties intend to achieveWhat is given, done or promised in exchange
ExampleEntering into an agreement to evade a statutory prohibitionPaying someone to commit an unlawful act
Relevant provisionSection 23Section 23
Legal effectAgreement is voidAgreement is void

In practice, the object and consideration may both be unlawful in the same transaction. For example, an agreement to pay a person to commit fraud may involve both an unlawful purpose and unlawful consideration.

Difference Between Unlawful Object and Void Agreement

An unlawful object is one ground on which an agreement becomes void under Section 23.

However, not every void agreement necessarily has an unlawful object. Some agreements are void for other reasons, such as uncertainty under Section 29 or wagering under Section 30.

BasisUnlawful ObjectVoid Agreement
MeaningThe purpose of the agreement is unlawful under Section 23An agreement that is not enforceable by law
Relevant provisionSection 23Section 2(g), read with applicable provisions
ScopeA particular ground of invalidityA broader legal category
ExampleAn agreement to bribe an officialAn uncertain agreement under Section 29

1. The Agreement Is Void

An agreement with an unlawful object under Section 23 is void and cannot ordinarily be enforced by either party as a valid contractual obligation.

2. Contractual Remedies May Be Unavailable

A party generally cannot seek enforcement of an agreement whose object is unlawful.

Whether a party may recover money or property already transferred requires separate analysis under the applicable law and the circumstances of the transaction.

3. Partly Unlawful Agreements

Section 24 deals with agreements in which a single consideration or object is partly unlawful. Where the unlawful part cannot be separated from the lawful part, the agreement is void.

Example: A agrees to undertake a lawful service for B in return for a single payment, but the agreement also requires A to perform an inseparable unlawful act as part of the same arrangement. Section 24 may render the agreement void.

The outcome depends on the structure of the agreement and whether the lawful and unlawful parts are legally separable.

Important Case Laws

Gherulal Parakh v. Mahadeodas Maiya (1959)

The Supreme Court examined wagering agreements and the relationship between void agreements and public policy.

Principle: An agreement being void does not automatically mean that it is illegal in every sense. Its legal consequences depend on the relevant statutory provisions and applicable principles.

This case is useful for distinguishing an agreement that is merely void from one that is unlawful on a separate legal ground.

Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly (1986)

The Supreme Court considered an unconscionable contractual term imposed in circumstances involving unequal bargaining power.

Principle: Certain unfair and unconscionable contractual terms may be opposed to public policy and unenforceable in the relevant circumstances.

The case illustrates the role of public policy in evaluating contractual arrangements, although it does not concern every category of unlawful object under Section 23.

Key Points for Exams

  • The object of an agreement means its purpose or objective.
  • Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, governs the lawfulness of an agreement’s object and consideration.
  • Section 23 identifies six grounds of unlawfulness.
  • An agreement with an unlawful object is void.
  • Section 24 deals with certain agreements involving partly unlawful consideration or objects.
  • Unlawful object is different from unlawful consideration, although both may arise in the same transaction.
  • Not every void agreement has an unlawful object.
  • Gherulal Parakh v. Mahadeodas Maiya (1959) is relevant to wagering agreements and public policy.
  • Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly (1986) is relevant to unconscionable terms and public policy.

Conclusion

Unlawful object is an important principle under Indian contract law because parties cannot use contractual arrangements to achieve purposes forbidden by law or contrary to the standards recognised under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.

The provision identifies several grounds of unlawfulness, including illegality, fraud, injury, immorality and opposition to public policy. Where the object is unlawful, the agreement is void and generally cannot be enforced.

The central principle is that contractual freedom does not extend to agreements intended to achieve unlawful purposes.