Contracts may be classified according to the nature of the promises made by the parties. On this basis, contracts are commonly classified as unilateral contracts and bilateral contracts.
- Unilateral Contract
- Characteristics of a Unilateral Contract
- Classic Example: Reward
- Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)
- Knowledge of the Offer
- Bilateral Contract
- Statutory Connection
- Characteristics of Bilateral Contracts
- Example of a Bilateral Contract
- Unilateral vs Bilateral Contracts
- Difference Through an Example
- Unilateral Contract and Reward Offers
- Bilateral Contracts and Reciprocal Promises
- Types of Reciprocal Promises
- Important Cases
- Unilateral Contract vs Unilateral Promise
- Can a Unilateral Contract Become Bilateral?
- Key Points for Examination
- Conclusion
The distinction primarily concerns whether acceptance takes place through performance of an act or through a reciprocal promise.
In simple terms:
Unilateral Contract → Promise in return for an act
Bilateral Contract → Promise in return for a promise
Unilateral Contract
A unilateral contract is a contract in which one party makes a promise in return for the performance of a specified act by another person.
The offer invites acceptance through performance, rather than merely through a promise to perform.
The person making the offer promises to do something if the other person performs the specified condition.
Example
A announces:
“I will pay ₹10,000 to anyone who finds and returns my lost dog.”
B finds the dog and returns it.
B has accepted the offer by performing the required act. A is then bound to perform the promise, subject to the applicable legal requirements.
Characteristics of a Unilateral Contract
Acceptance Through Performance
The most important feature is that acceptance generally occurs through performance of the specified act.
The offeree does not ordinarily need to make a separate promise to perform.
Offer to the Public
A unilateral offer may be made to a particular person or to the public generally.
A reward advertisement is a common example of an offer made to the public.
Obligation After Performance
The offeror’s obligation arises when the required act is performed in accordance with the terms of the offer.
No Need for Prior Promise
The person accepting the offer generally accepts it by doing what the offer requires.
Example
A offers ₹50,000 to B if B successfully climbs a particular mountain.
B does not necessarily have to first promise:
“I will climb the mountain.”
If B performs the required act in accordance with the offer, the requirements for acceptance through performance may be satisfied.
Classic Example: Reward
Suppose A announces:
“₹20,000 will be paid to anyone who finds my missing laptop and returns it.”
B finds the laptop and returns it.
B’s performance of the specified act constitutes acceptance of the offer, provided B acted with the necessary knowledge of the offer and the other requirements of contract formation are satisfied.
Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)
Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. is the classic case used to explain unilateral contracts.
The company advertised that it would pay £100 to a person who used its smoke ball according to the prescribed directions and nevertheless contracted influenza. Mrs Carlill used the product as directed but still contracted influenza.
The court treated the advertisement as a sufficiently definite offer capable of acceptance through performance.
The case illustrates the principle that an offer may be made to the public and accepted by performing the conditions specified in the offer.
Knowledge of the Offer
Knowledge of the offer is important.
A person generally cannot accept an offer of which they were unaware.
Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)
In this case, a reward had been announced for information leading to the recovery of a missing boy. The person who provided the information had acted without knowledge of the reward when he performed the relevant act.
The case is commonly cited for the principle that knowledge of an offer is necessary for acceptance.
This principle is particularly important when studying unilateral offers.
Bilateral Contract
A bilateral contract is a contract in which both parties exchange promises.
One party’s promise is given in return for the promise of the other party.
This is sometimes described as a promise for a promise.
Example
A agrees to sell his car to B for ₹6 lakh.
- A promises to deliver the car.
- B promises to pay ₹6 lakh.
Both parties undertake obligations.
This is a bilateral contract.
Statutory Connection
The Indian Contract Act, 1872 does not expressly provide a separate statutory definition of “unilateral contract” and “bilateral contract.”
However, the concept of bilateral contracts is closely connected with reciprocal promises.
Section 2(f) provides that promises which form the consideration or part of the consideration for each other are called reciprocal promises.
Thus, a bilateral contract commonly consists of reciprocal promises.
Example
A promises to deliver 100 bags of rice to B.
B promises to pay ₹2 lakh for the goods.
A’s promise and B’s promise constitute reciprocal promises.
Characteristics of Bilateral Contracts
Mutual Promises
Both parties make promises to one another.
Acceptance Through Promise
Acceptance ordinarily takes the form of agreeing to undertake the reciprocal obligation.
Obligations on Both Sides
Both parties generally have contractual obligations.
Common in Commercial Transactions
Most ordinary commercial agreements are bilateral.
Examples include:
- Sale agreements;
- Employment contracts;
- Lease agreements;
- Service contracts;
- Construction contracts; and
- Supply agreements.
Example of a Bilateral Contract
A agrees to design a website for B for ₹80,000.
B promises to pay ₹80,000, and A promises to complete the website according to the agreed terms.
Both parties have undertaken promises.
Therefore, it is a bilateral contract.
Unilateral vs Bilateral Contracts
| Basis | Unilateral Contract | Bilateral Contract |
|---|---|---|
| Basic nature | Promise in return for an act | Promise in return for a promise |
| Acceptance | Generally through performance | Generally through a reciprocal promise |
| Obligations at formation | The offeror’s promise is conditional upon the specified act | Both parties undertake reciprocal obligations |
| Offeree’s role | Performs the required act | Makes a promise to perform |
| Common example | Reward offer | Agreement for sale of goods |
| Section 2(f) | Not necessarily based on reciprocal promises | Closely connected with reciprocal promises |
Difference Through an Example
Unilateral
A says:
“I will pay ₹10,000 if you find my lost phone.”
B finds and returns the phone.
A’s promise → B’s performance
Bilateral
A says:
“I will sell you my phone for ₹10,000.”
B says:
“I agree to buy it for ₹10,000.”
A’s promise → B’s promise
This is the simplest way to distinguish the two.
Unilateral Contract and Reward Offers
Reward offers are one of the most common examples of unilateral contracts.
Examples include:
- Reward for finding lost property;
- Reward for providing information;
- Reward for completing a specified task;
- Public offers promising payment upon achievement of a specified result.
The essential point is that the person claiming the reward must generally perform the condition specified in the offer.
Example
A announces:
“₹25,000 will be paid to anyone who provides information leading to the recovery of my stolen vehicle.”
B, knowing of the offer, provides the required information.
If the conditions of the offer are fulfilled, B may claim the promised reward.
Bilateral Contracts and Reciprocal Promises
Section 2(f) is particularly important for bilateral contracts.
Where two promises constitute consideration for each other, they are called reciprocal promises.
Example
A promises to manufacture 1,000 units of a product for B.
B promises to pay ₹5 lakh.
There are two corresponding promises:
- A’s promise to manufacture and supply;
- B’s promise to pay.
The promises form the consideration for each other.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp ChannelTypes of Reciprocal Promises
The Indian Contract Act also contains provisions dealing with the performance of reciprocal promises.
Sections 51 to 54 deal with important situations involving reciprocal promises.
Section 51 — Simultaneous Performance
Where reciprocal promises are to be performed simultaneously, one party need not perform unless the other party is ready and willing to perform the reciprocal promise.
Example
A agrees to deliver goods to B in exchange for immediate payment.
If both performances are intended to occur simultaneously, the parties must generally be ready and willing to perform their respective obligations.
Section 52 — Order of Performance
Where the contract specifies the order in which reciprocal promises are to be performed, they must be performed in that order.
If the contract does not specify the order, the nature of the transaction determines the order.
Section 53 — Prevention of Performance
If one party prevents the other from performing a reciprocal promise, the contract may become voidable at the option of the party prevented from performing, who may also be entitled to compensation.
Section 54 — Default in First Promise
Where one promise must be performed first and the party responsible for that promise fails to perform it, that party cannot ordinarily demand performance of the reciprocal promise and may have to compensate the other party.
Important Cases
Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)
The case is the classic authority for a unilateral offer capable of acceptance through performance.
It demonstrates that an offer may be made to the public and accepted by performing the conditions specified in the offer.
Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)
The case establishes the importance of knowledge of an offer for acceptance.
It is particularly relevant to reward-based unilateral offers.
Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)
The Supreme Court considered the communication of acceptance in contracts involving instantaneous communication.
The case is important for understanding the formation of contracts and communication of acceptance.
Hind Construction Co. Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra (1979)
The Supreme Court considered contractual obligations and the interpretation of contractual terms in the context of reciprocal obligations.
The case is useful when studying the performance and interpretation of contractual promises.
Unilateral Contract vs Unilateral Promise
A unilateral promise should not automatically be treated as a unilateral contract.
A promise becomes part of an enforceable contract only when the requirements of contract formation are satisfied.
Therefore:
Unilateral offer + required performance + legal requirements = enforceable unilateral contract
Can a Unilateral Contract Become Bilateral?
The terminology can sometimes be confusing because a contract may develop through different stages.
For example, A makes a reward offer requiring B to perform a specified act. Before the act is completed, B may not have undertaken a reciprocal promise merely by knowing of the offer. Once B performs the required condition, the contractual obligation arises according to the terms of the offer.
Therefore, the key distinction should remain focused on how the offer is accepted.
Key Points for Examination
- A unilateral contract generally involves a promise in return for performance of an act.
- A bilateral contract involves a promise in return for another promise.
- Unilateral offers are commonly accepted through performance.
- Reward offers are classic examples of unilateral contracts.
- Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. is the leading case illustrating unilateral offers.
- Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt establishes the importance of knowledge of the offer.
- Bilateral contracts commonly involve reciprocal promises.
- Section 2(f) defines reciprocal promises.
- Sections 51–54 deal with performance of reciprocal promises.
- The Indian Contract Act does not separately define the expressions “unilateral contract” and “bilateral contract.”
- Most ordinary commercial agreements, such as sale and service contracts, are bilateral.
- A unilateral contract should not be confused with a mere unilateral promise that has not become legally enforceable.
Conclusion
Unilateral and bilateral contracts are distinguished primarily by the manner in which the offer is accepted and the nature of the obligations undertaken by the parties.
In a unilateral contract, the offer is generally accepted by performing the specified act. A reward offer is the classic example.
In a bilateral contract, both parties make promises to each other, creating reciprocal obligations. Most ordinary commercial agreements fall into this category.
The easiest way to remember the distinction is:
Unilateral Contract = Promise for an Act
Bilateral Contract = Promise for a Promise