Meaning of Undue Influence
Undue influence occurs when one party uses their position of power or authority over another person to obtain an unfair advantage in a contractual transaction.
- Meaning of Undue Influence
- Section 16 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
- Essentials of Undue Influence
- Presumption of Undue Influence: Section 16(3)
- Important Case Laws on Undue Influence
- Effect of Undue Influence on a Contract
- Undue Influence vs Coercion
- Undue Influence vs Fraud
- Undue Influence and Free Consent
- How Can Undue Influence Be Proved?
- Key Points for Exams
- Quick Revision
- Conclusion
Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, undue influence is governed by Sections 16 and 19A. Section 16 defines undue influence, while Section 19A deals with the power of a court to set aside a contract induced by undue influence.
Undue influence affects the freedom of consent. Although a person may formally agree to a contract, their consent may not be genuinely free if another person improperly dominates their will and uses that position to secure an unfair advantage.
Example
An elderly person depends entirely on a caregiver for daily assistance and financial decisions. The caregiver uses this position of influence to persuade the elderly person to transfer valuable property without a fair explanation or independent advice.
Depending on the circumstances, the transaction may be challenged on the ground of undue influence.
Section 16 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
Section 16 provides that a contract is induced by undue influence where:
- The relationship between the parties is such that one party is in a position to dominate the will of the other; and
- That party uses the position to obtain an unfair advantage over the other.
The provision also identifies circumstances in which a person may be considered to be in a position to dominate another’s will.
Essentials of Undue Influence
1. One Party Must Be in a Position to Dominate the Will of the Other
The first requirement is that one party must occupy a position that enables them to exercise influence over the other party’s decision-making.
Section 16 recognises circumstances where this may arise, including situations where a person:
- holds real or apparent authority over another;
- stands in a fiduciary relationship with another; or
- contracts with a person whose mental capacity is temporarily or permanently affected by age, illness or mental or bodily distress.
A fiduciary relationship is one involving a special duty of trust and confidence, such as certain relationships between trustees and beneficiaries.
Example: A trustee uses their position of control over a beneficiary’s financial affairs to persuade the beneficiary to enter into a transaction that unfairly benefits the trustee.
2. The Dominating Position Must Be Used
The existence of a relationship of trust, authority or dependence does not automatically establish undue influence.
The dominating position must actually be used to obtain an unfair advantage.
Example: A parent advises an adult child about a financial transaction. The existence of the parent-child relationship alone does not establish undue influence. The circumstances must show that the legal requirements of Section 16 are satisfied.
3. An Unfair Advantage Must Be Obtained
The party exercising influence must use that position to obtain an unfair advantage.
The court considers the circumstances of the transaction, including its terms, the relationship between the parties and the manner in which consent was obtained.
An unequal bargain is not automatically the result of undue influence. The statutory requirements must be established.
4. The Consent Must Be Induced by Undue Influence
There must be a connection between the use of the dominating position and the agreement.
If the person entered into the transaction independently and without undue influence, the existence of a close or dependent relationship alone will not invalidate the contract.
Presumption of Undue Influence: Section 16(3)
Section 16(3) provides an important rule concerning the burden of proof.
Where a person who is in a position to dominate another’s will enters into a transaction with that person, and the transaction appears on its face or on the evidence to be unconscionable, the burden of proving that the contract was not induced by undue influence may shift to the party in the dominating position.
This rule does not mean that every transaction between persons in a relationship of trust is automatically presumed to be invalid.
The statutory conditions must be satisfied.
Example
A person who depends on a financial adviser for managing their assets transfers almost all their property to the adviser on highly disadvantageous terms.
If the adviser was in a position to dominate the person’s will and the transaction appears unconscionable, Section 16(3) may shift the burden of proof to the adviser to show that undue influence did not induce the transaction.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp ChannelImportant Case Laws on Undue Influence
Raghunath Prasad v. Sarju Prasad (1924)
This is a leading Indian case on undue influence.
The Privy Council explained the importance of examining the relationship between the parties, whether one party was in a position to dominate the other’s will, and whether that position was used to obtain an unfair advantage.
Principle: The court must examine the statutory requirements of undue influence rather than assume that an unfavourable transaction is automatically invalid.
Subhas Chandra Das Mushib v. Ganga Prosad Das Mushib (1967)
The Supreme Court considered the requirements for establishing undue influence.
The Court emphasised that the mere existence of a relationship between the parties does not automatically establish undue influence.
Principle: The party alleging undue influence must establish the relevant circumstances showing domination of the will and its improper use, subject to the burden-shifting rule in Section 16(3).
Effect of Undue Influence on a Contract
Section 19A: Power to Set Aside a Contract
Section 19A provides that when consent to an agreement is caused by undue influence, the contract is voidable at the option of the party whose consent was so caused.
The court may set the contract aside:
- absolutely; or
- on such terms and conditions as it considers just, where the party seeking relief has received a benefit under the contract.
This allows the court to consider the circumstances and ensure that the relief granted is fair.
Example
A person transfers property to another under undue influence and receives a benefit under the transaction.
A court may set aside the transaction and impose appropriate conditions concerning restoration of the benefit, depending on the facts and the law.
Undue Influence vs Coercion
| Basis | Undue Influence | Coercion |
|---|---|---|
| Provision | Section 16 | Section 15 |
| Nature | Improper use of a position to dominate another’s will | Conduct involving acts forbidden by criminal law or unlawful detention of property |
| Relationship | A position to dominate another’s will is essential | A special relationship is not required |
| Unfair advantage | Must be obtained through the use of the dominating position | Not a separate express requirement in the same form |
| Legal consequence | Contract may be set aside under Section 19A | Contract is generally voidable under Section 19 |
Example
Undue influence: A person in a position of trust uses that position to obtain an unfair property transfer.
Coercion: A threatens unlawful harm unless another person signs a contract.
Undue Influence vs Fraud
| Basis | Undue Influence | Fraud |
|---|---|---|
| Provision | Section 16 | Section 17 |
| Main feature | Dominating position used to obtain unfair advantage | Intentional deception or other conduct covered by Section 17 |
| Special relationship | Relevant to establishing domination, though the statutory test governs | Not necessary |
| Consent | Obtained through improper influence | Obtained through fraudulent conduct |
| Legal consequence | Section 19A | Section 19, subject to statutory qualifications |
Undue Influence and Free Consent
Section 14 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, states that consent is free when it is not caused by coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation or mistake, subject to the Act’s provisions.
Undue influence therefore affects an essential requirement of a valid contract.
The relevant provisions work together as follows:
Section 14: Defines free consent.
Section 16: Defines undue influence.
Section 19A: Provides relief where a contract is induced by undue influence.
How Can Undue Influence Be Proved?
The court examines the circumstances of the transaction rather than relying on the relationship alone.
Relevant considerations may include:
- the nature of the relationship between the parties;
- the extent of authority, trust or dependence;
- the terms of the transaction;
- whether the transaction appears unconscionable;
- whether the person received independent advice; and
- whether the dominating position was used to obtain an unfair advantage.
Independent advice may be relevant evidence, but it does not automatically determine the outcome.
Key Points for Exams
- Undue influence is governed by Sections 16 and 19A of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
- One party must be in a position to dominate the will of the other.
- That position must be used to obtain an unfair advantage.
- A relationship of trust or authority alone does not automatically establish undue influence.
- Section 16(3) provides for a shift in the burden of proof when its statutory conditions are met.
- A contract induced by undue influence is generally voidable, not automatically void.
- Section 19A allows a court to set aside the contract on appropriate terms.
- Raghunath Prasad v. Sarju Prasad (1924) is a leading case.
- Subhas Chandra Das Mushib v. Ganga Prosad Das Mushib (1967) clarifies that a relationship alone is insufficient.
- Undue influence differs from coercion because it centres on domination of the will and the improper use of that position.
Quick Revision
Section 16 → Definition of undue influence
↓
Position to dominate another’s will
↓
Use of that position to obtain unfair advantage
↓
Consent caused by undue influence
↓
Section 19A → Court may set aside the contract
Conclusion
Undue influence protects parties whose consent is obtained through the improper use of authority, trust or another position of dominance. Under Sections 16 and 19A of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the law examines whether one party was in a position to dominate the other’s will and used that position to obtain an unfair advantage.
The existence of a close relationship or an unfavourable transaction alone is not sufficient. The statutory requirements must be established, and where the conditions of Section 16(3) are satisfied, the burden of proof may shift to the party in the dominating position.
The central principle is that a contract may be set aside when a party uses a position of dominance to obtain an unfair advantage and thereby induces the other party’s consent.