An offer, or proposal, is the foundation of a contract. Under Section 2(a) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a proposal is made when one person signifies to another their willingness to do or abstain from doing something, with a view to obtaining the assent of that person.
- Specific Offer
- General Offer
- Specific Offer vs General Offer
- Express Offer
- Implied Offer
- Express Offer vs Implied Offer
- Standing or Continuing Offer
- Cross Offer
- Counter-Offer
- Conditional Offer
- Open Offer
- Offer Made by Words and Conduct
- Offer vs Invitation to Offer
- Important Distinctions
- Revocation of Different Types of Offers
- Important Cases at a Glance
- Key Points for Examination
- Conclusion
Offers can be classified in different ways based on how they are made, to whom they are made, their duration and the manner in which they may be accepted.
The major types of offers are:
- Specific Offer
- General Offer
- Express Offer
- Implied Offer
- Standing or Continuing Offer
- Cross Offer
- Counter-Offer
- Conditional Offer
- Open Offer
Specific Offer
A specific offer is an offer made to a particular person or a specific group of persons.
Only the person or persons to whom the offer is made can ordinarily accept it.
Example
A offers to sell his car to B for ₹6 lakh.
The offer is specifically made to B. Therefore, B can accept it.
C cannot ordinarily accept A’s offer because the offer was not made to C.
Case Law
Boulton v. Jones (1857)
An offer was made to a particular person, but another person attempted to accept it. The case illustrates the principle that a specific offer can generally be accepted only by the person to whom it is made.
General Offer
A general offer is an offer made to the public at large or to an unspecified class of persons.
Anyone who has knowledge of the offer and fulfils its conditions may ordinarily accept it.
Example
A announces:
“₹20,000 will be paid to anyone who finds and returns my lost dog.”
The offer is made to the public generally.
A person who knows about the offer and performs the required act may claim the reward, subject to the terms of the offer.
Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)
This is the leading case on general offers.
The company advertised a reward to anyone who used its smoke ball according to specified directions and nevertheless contracted influenza. Mrs Carlill fulfilled the conditions.
The court treated the advertisement as a valid offer to the public capable of acceptance through performance.
The case establishes that a general offer can create a contractual obligation when its conditions are fulfilled.
Specific Offer vs General Offer
| Specific Offer | General Offer |
|---|---|
| Made to a particular person or group | Made to the public or an unspecified class |
| Only the intended offeree can ordinarily accept | Anyone who fulfils the conditions may accept |
| Example: A offers a car to B | Example: Reward offered to anyone who finds lost property |
| Acceptance is limited to the identified offeree | Acceptance may occur through performance by a qualifying person |
Express Offer
An express offer is an offer made through words, either orally or in writing.
Section 9 recognises express promises where the proposal or acceptance is made in words.
Example
A writes to B:
“I will sell my laptop to you for ₹40,000.”
This is an express offer because A’s willingness is communicated through written words.
An oral statement can also constitute an express offer.
Example
A tells B:
“I will sell you my motorcycle for ₹80,000.”
This is an oral express offer.
Implied Offer
An implied offer is an offer inferred from the conduct of the parties or the circumstances rather than directly expressed in words.
Section 9 recognises promises that are made otherwise than in words as implied.
Example
A bus operating a regular route and carrying passengers for a prescribed fare may be understood, from its conduct and circumstances, to make an implied offer to carry passengers on payment of the applicable fare.
A passenger who boards the bus and pays the fare accepts the service on the applicable terms.
Express Offer vs Implied Offer
| Express Offer | Implied Offer |
|---|---|
| Made through words | Inferred from conduct or circumstances |
| May be oral or written | Arises from acts or surrounding circumstances |
| Terms are directly communicated | Terms are inferred |
| Example: written offer to sell a car | Example: public transport service |
Standing or Continuing Offer
A standing offer, also called a continuing offer, is an offer that remains open for acceptance over a period of time.
It is commonly used in supply contracts and tenders.
Example
A submits a tender to supply 1,000 units of stationery to a company at specified prices for one year.
The tender may constitute a standing offer. Individual orders placed in accordance with the terms may constitute separate acceptances, depending upon the contractual arrangement.
Important Point
A standing offer does not necessarily result in one single contract for the entire quantity merely because the offer is made.
Individual orders and their acceptance may create separate contractual obligations.
Case Law
Great Northern Railway Co. v. Witham (1873)
The case is a classic authority on standing offers.
An offer to supply goods at specified prices over a period was treated as a continuing offer, with individual orders operating as acceptances.
The case is commonly used to explain the nature of standing or continuing offers.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp ChannelCross Offer
A cross offer occurs when two parties independently make identical or substantially similar offers to each other without knowing about the other person’s offer.
The two offers cross each other but do not constitute acceptance.
Example
A posts a letter to B offering to sell his car for ₹5 lakh.
At the same time, without knowing about A’s letter, B posts a letter offering to buy A’s car for ₹5 lakh.
These are cross offers.
There is no acceptance because neither party has accepted the other’s offer.
Case Law
Tinn v. Hoffman & Co. (1873)
The case is a classic authority on cross offers.
The court held that identical offers made independently by the parties do not amount to acceptance of each other.
Important Principle
Cross offer ≠ acceptance.
A contract requires acceptance of an offer, not merely the existence of matching offers.
Counter-Offer
A counter-offer arises when the person receiving an offer responds by proposing different or modified terms instead of accepting the original offer absolutely.
A counter-offer generally terminates or rejects the original offer, subject to the circumstances.
Example
A offers to sell his car to B for ₹6 lakh.
B replies:
“I will buy it for ₹5.5 lakh.”
B has not accepted A’s offer.
B has made a counter-offer.
Hyde v. Wrench (1840)
A offered to sell property for £1,000. The other party offered £950 instead. When the original offeror later attempted to accept the £950 offer, the court treated the original offer as having been terminated by the counter-offer.
The case establishes the classic principle that a counter-offer is not an acceptance of the original offer.
Conditional Offer
A conditional offer is an offer that is subject to the fulfilment of specified conditions.
The offeror indicates that the contractual obligation will arise only if the stated conditions are satisfied.
Example
A offers to sell his land to B for ₹20 lakh subject to obtaining the required approval from the relevant authority.
The offer is conditional upon the specified event.
Acceptance of a Conditional Offer
The offeree must accept the offer in accordance with its conditions.
If the offeree attempts to accept while changing or rejecting the conditions, there may be no valid acceptance.
Open Offer
An open offer is an offer that remains available for acceptance by the intended person or persons until it is revoked, rejected, expires or otherwise comes to an end according to law.
An open offer should not automatically be confused with a general offer.
The terms “open offer” can also have a specialised meaning in securities regulation, particularly under takeover regulations. That regulatory meaning is different from the general Contract Law classification.
Offer Made by Words and Conduct
Offers can also be classified according to the manner in which they are communicated.
Offer by Words
The offer is expressly communicated.
Example:
“I will sell my phone for ₹20,000.”
Offer by Conduct
The offer is inferred from conduct.
Example:
A taxi driver makes a taxi available for passengers for the applicable fare. The circumstances may indicate an implied offer to provide transportation.
Offer vs Invitation to Offer
An invitation to offer is not itself an offer.
It merely invites persons to make offers.
Common examples include:
- Display of goods in shops;
- Catalogues;
- Price lists;
- Advertisements that merely invite customers to negotiate;
- Auction notices.
Example
A shop displays a television with a price tag of ₹40,000.
The display is generally treated as an invitation to customers to make an offer to purchase, rather than as an offer that automatically creates a contract upon a customer’s response.
Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v. Boots Cash Chemists (1953)
The case is a classic authority on the distinction between an offer and an invitation to offer.
Goods displayed on shelves in a self-service store were treated as an invitation to customers to make an offer at the point of purchase, rather than as offers that were automatically accepted merely by taking the goods from the shelf.
Important Distinctions
General Offer vs Invitation to Offer
A general offer is capable of acceptance if its terms are fulfilled.
An invitation to offer merely invites others to submit offers.
Cross Offer vs Counter-Offer
A cross offer arises independently without knowledge of the other offer.
A counter-offer is made in response to an existing offer but proposes different terms.
Example
Cross Offer:
A → “I will sell for ₹5 lakh.”
B, without knowing this → “I will buy for ₹5 lakh.”
Counter-Offer:
A → “I will sell for ₹5 lakh.”
B → “I will buy for ₹4.5 lakh.”
Revocation of Different Types of Offers
An offer may come to an end according to the rules governing revocation and lapse.
Section 5 deals with revocation of proposals.
Section 6 recognises several modes of revocation, including:
- Communication of notice of revocation;
- Lapse of prescribed or reasonable time;
- Failure to fulfil a condition precedent to acceptance; and
- Death or insanity of the proposer, where the relevant fact becomes known to the acceptor before acceptance.
A counter-offer may also bring the original offer to an end.
Important Cases at a Glance
| Case | Principle |
|---|---|
| Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893) | General offer |
| Boulton v. Jones (1857) | Specific offer |
| Great Northern Railway Co. v. Witham (1873) | Standing/continuing offer |
| Tinn v. Hoffman & Co. (1873) | Cross offers |
| Hyde v. Wrench (1840) | Counter-offer |
| Pharmaceutical Society v. Boots (1953) | Invitation to offer |
| Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913) | Knowledge of offer |
Key Points for Examination
- Specific Offer → made to a particular person.
- General Offer → made to the public or an unspecified class.
- Express Offer → made through words.
- Implied Offer → inferred from conduct or circumstances.
- Standing Offer → remains open for acceptance over a period and is common in supply arrangements.
- Cross Offers → identical offers made independently without knowledge of each other; they do not constitute acceptance.
- Counter-Offer → response proposing different terms; it is not acceptance of the original offer.
- Conditional Offer → subject to specified conditions.
- Open Offer → remains open for acceptance until revoked, rejected, expires or otherwise terminates according to law.
- Section 2(a) defines a proposal.
- Section 5 deals with revocation of proposals.
- Section 6 provides modes of revocation.
- Section 7 requires acceptance to be absolute and unqualified.
- Section 9 recognises express and implied promises.
- Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. is the leading case on general offers.
- Great Northern Railway Co. v. Witham is important for standing offers.
- Tinn v. Hoffman & Co. is important for cross offers.
- Hyde v. Wrench is important for counter-offers.
Conclusion
Offers can take different forms depending upon to whom they are made, how they are communicated, how long they remain open and how they are intended to be accepted.
The most important classifications are specific and general offers, express and implied offers, standing offers, cross offers, counter-offers and conditional offers.
The easiest way to remember them is:
Specific → Particular person
General → Public
Express → Words
Implied → Conduct
Standing → Continues over time
Cross → Independent matching offers
Counter → Modified response to an offer
Conditional → Subject to conditions
Understanding these types is essential for determining whether a valid offer exists and whether a subsequent communication amounts to acceptance, a counter-offer or merely an invitation to offer.