Specific Offer

Published: 9 min read

A specific offer is an offer made to a particular person or a specifically identified group of persons. Unlike a general offer, which is made to the public at large, a specific offer identifies the person or persons whose assent is sought.

Under Section 2(a) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a proposal is made when one person signifies to another their willingness to do or abstain from doing something with a view to obtaining the assent of that other person.

A specific offer is therefore an offer directed towards an identified offeree.

Meaning of Specific Offer

A specific offer is made to a particular individual or a definite and identifiable group.

Example

A tells B:

“I will sell my motorcycle to you for ₹80,000.”

The offer is specifically addressed to B. Therefore, it is a specific offer.

C cannot ordinarily accept A’s offer because A did not make the offer to C.

Essential Features of a Specific Offer

1. Made to an Identified Person

The most important characteristic is that the offeree is specifically identified.

Example

A sends an email to B stating:

“I offer to sell my laptop to you for ₹40,000.”

The offer is made specifically to B.

2. Only the Intended Offeree Can Ordinarily Accept

A specific offer can ordinarily be accepted only by the person to whom it is made.

A third person cannot generally accept an offer that was specifically addressed to someone else.

Example

A offers to sell a car to B for ₹5 lakh.

C learns about the offer and tells A:

“I accept your offer.”

C cannot ordinarily accept the offer because it was made to B.

3. The Offeree Must Have Knowledge of the Offer

The person accepting the offer must generally know about the offer.

This principle applies to specific offers as well as general offers.

Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)

The case is an important authority for the principle that a person cannot accept an offer without knowledge of its existence.

The case involved a reward and is commonly used to explain the requirement of knowledge before acceptance.

4. The Offer Must Be Clear and Certain

A specific offer must contain sufficiently clear terms so that the offeree can understand what is being offered and what is required for acceptance.

Example

A tells B:

“I will sell you my car for ₹6 lakh, delivery on 15 October.”

This is sufficiently specific regarding the subject matter, price and delivery date.

5. Acceptance Must Correspond With the Offer

Under Section 7, acceptance must be absolute and unqualified.

Example

A offers to sell his laptop to B for ₹40,000.

B says:

“I accept your offer for ₹40,000.”

This is acceptance.

But if B says:

“I accept it for ₹35,000,”

B has not accepted the original offer. The response may constitute a counter-offer.

6. Acceptance May Be Express or Implied

A specific offer may be accepted through words or, where the circumstances permit, through conduct.

Section 9 recognises express and implied promises.

Express Acceptance

B tells A:

“I accept your offer.”

Acceptance by Conduct

Where the terms of the offer permit acceptance through performance, the offeree may accept by performing the required act.

The exact legal effect depends upon the terms of the offer and the circumstances.

7. A Specific Offer May Be Conditional

The offeror may impose conditions that must be fulfilled for acceptance.

Example

A offers to sell B a house for ₹50 lakh subject to B obtaining a particular loan approval.

The offer is conditional upon the specified event or condition.

The offeree must comply with the condition according to its terms.

Specific Offer and General Offer

The most important distinction is the identity of the offeree.

Specific OfferGeneral Offer
Made to a particular person or identified groupMade to the public or unspecified class
Particular offeree is identifiedOfferee is not individually identified
Only the intended offeree can ordinarily acceptAnyone fulfilling the conditions may ordinarily accept
Example: A offers his car to BExample: reward offered to anyone who finds lost property
Boulton v. Jones is relevantCarlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. is the leading case

Specific Offer and Acceptance by a Third Person

A third person cannot ordinarily accept a specific offer merely because they have learned about it.

Example

A offers to sell his property to B for ₹20 lakh.

C hears about the offer and tells A that C accepts it.

There is no contract between A and C on the basis of that specific offer because C was not the intended offeree.

The principle is that an offer made to a particular person can ordinarily be accepted only by that person.

Boulton v. Jones (1857)

Facts and Principle

Jones had dealings with a particular person and placed an order with that person. Before the order was completed, the business was taken over by Boulton. Boulton supplied the goods, but Jones refused to pay him on the basis of the original arrangement.

The case is commonly cited for the principle that an offer made to a particular person cannot ordinarily be accepted by another person who was not the intended offeree.

Legal Principle

Specific offer → acceptance by the intended offeree.

The identity of the parties matters in the formation of a contract.

Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.

Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.

Join WhatsApp Channel

Specific Offer and Communication

The offer must be communicated to the identified offeree.

Example

A writes a letter to B:

“I offer to sell my car to you for ₹5 lakh.”

If B never receives the communication and has no knowledge of the offer, B cannot ordinarily accept an offer of which B is unaware.

This reflects the general principle that acceptance requires knowledge of the proposal.

Specific Offer and Counter-Offer

A specific offer can be rejected or modified through a counter-offer.

Example

A offers to sell his house to B for ₹50 lakh.

B replies:

“I will buy it for ₹45 lakh.”

B has not accepted A’s offer. B has made a counter-offer.

Hyde v. Wrench (1840)

This English case is a leading authority for the principle that a counter-offer is not acceptance of the original offer and may terminate the original offer.

Specific Offer and Invitation to Offer

A specific offer must also be distinguished from an invitation to offer.

Specific Offer

A tells B:

“I will sell you my car for ₹6 lakh.”

This is capable of being accepted by B.

Invitation to Offer

A shop displays a car with a price tag of ₹6 lakh.

The display is generally an invitation to customers to make an offer to purchase, subject to the circumstances.

The distinction depends on the intention and wording of the communication.

Specific Offer and General Offer: Examples

Specific Offer

A says to B:

“I will pay you ₹10,000 if you complete this research assignment by Friday.”

The offer is directed specifically to B.

General Offer

A announces:

“I will pay ₹10,000 to anyone who completes this research task by Friday.”

The offer is directed to the public or an unspecified class.

Can a Specific Offer Be Accepted by Performance?

Yes, depending on the terms of the offer.

An offer may specify that acceptance is to occur through performance of a particular act.

Example

A tells B:

“I will pay you ₹5,000 if you repair my computer by tomorrow.”

If B knows of the offer and performs the required act in accordance with its terms, the performance may constitute acceptance.

Therefore, the distinction between specific and general offers concerns who may accept, not necessarily whether acceptance must always be communicated through words.

Revocation of a Specific Offer

A specific offer may be revoked in accordance with Sections 5 and 6 of the Indian Contract Act.

An offer may come to an end through circumstances such as:

  • Communication of revocation;
  • Expiry of the prescribed or reasonable period;
  • Failure of a condition precedent;
  • Death or insanity of the proposer where the relevant fact becomes known before acceptance; or
  • Rejection or counter-offer by the offeree.

Example

A offers to sell his car to B for ₹5 lakh.

Before B accepts, A communicates that the offer is withdrawn.

Subject to the statutory rules, the offer may then be revoked.

Important Cases

Boulton v. Jones (1857)

A leading case on the rule that a specific offer must ordinarily be accepted by the person to whom it was made.

Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)

Important for the principle that the offeree must have knowledge of the offer before acceptance.

Hyde v. Wrench (1840)

Important for the principle that a counter-offer is not acceptance of the original offer.

Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)

The Supreme Court considered communication of acceptance in the context of instantaneous communications. It is useful for understanding when acceptance becomes effective in contractual communications.

Specific Offer vs General Offer vs Counter-Offer

TypeMeaningExample
Specific OfferOffer to an identified personA offers a car to B for ₹5 lakh
General OfferOffer to public or unspecified classReward to anyone finding a lost dog
Counter-OfferModified proposal made in response to an offerB responds to ₹5 lakh offer with ₹4.5 lakh proposal

Key Points for Examination

  • A specific offer is made to a particular person or specifically identified group.
  • It is governed by the general principles of proposal and acceptance under the Indian Contract Act.
  • Section 2(a) defines a proposal.
  • The intended offeree must ordinarily be the person who accepts the specific offer.
  • A third person cannot ordinarily accept a specific offer made to someone else.
  • The offeree must generally have knowledge of the offer.
  • The offer must be sufficiently clear and certain.
  • Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified under Section 7.
  • A specific offer may be accepted through words or conduct, depending upon its terms.
  • A specific offer may contain conditions.
  • Boulton v. Jones (1857) is an important case on specific offers.
  • Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913) is important for knowledge of the offer.
  • Hyde v. Wrench (1840) is important for counter-offers.
  • Sections 5 and 6 deal with revocation of proposals.
  • A specific offer differs from a general offer primarily in the identity of the person to whom the offer is made.

Conclusion

A specific offer is an offer made to a particular person or specifically identified group of persons. The central principle is that the offer is directed towards an identified offeree, who alone can ordinarily accept it.

The distinction from a general offer is straightforward:

Specific Offer → Made to a particular person

General Offer → Made to the public

The principle is particularly important because a person cannot ordinarily create a contract by accepting an offer that was never addressed to them.