Revocation of Acceptance

Published: 8 min read

Revocation of acceptance means withdrawing or cancelling an acceptance after it has been communicated or expressed, but before the law treats the communication of acceptance as complete against the acceptor.

The Indian Contract Act, 1872 expressly recognizes the possibility of revoking acceptance under Section 5. The rule is closely connected with Section 4, which determines when communication of acceptance becomes complete.

The basic rule is:

Acceptance → Revocation before communication is complete against acceptor → Revocation may be effective

But:

Acceptance → Communication complete against acceptor → Revocation is too late

Meaning of Revocation of Acceptance

Normally, once a person accepts an offer, the parties expect the contract to become binding. However, the Indian Contract Act provides a limited window during which the acceptor can revoke the acceptance.

Section 5 provides that an acceptance may be revoked at any time before the communication of acceptance is complete as against the acceptor, but not afterwards.

Therefore, revocation of acceptance depends primarily upon timing.

Example

A offers to sell a car to B for ₹5 lakh.

B accepts the offer by post and sends the acceptance to A.

Before A receives the acceptance, B sends a faster communication stating:

“I revoke my acceptance.”

If the revocation reaches A before the acceptance comes to A’s knowledge, Section 5 may permit B to revoke the acceptance.

Section 5: Statutory Rule

Section 5 contains two separate rules:

  1. Revocation of proposal
  2. Revocation of acceptance

For acceptance, the important part is:

Acceptance may be revoked before communication of acceptance is complete as against the acceptor.

This must be read with Section 4.

Section 4 and Revocation of Acceptance

Section 4 provides that communication of acceptance is complete:

As against the proposer

When the acceptance is put into a course of transmission to the proposer so as to be out of the power of the acceptor.

As against the acceptor

When the acceptance comes to the knowledge of the proposer.

This creates a limited period during which the acceptor may revoke the acceptance.

Example

B accepts A’s offer by post.

B posts the acceptance on Monday.

A receives it on Thursday.

Under the traditional postal rule:

  • As against A, acceptance is complete when B posts it.
  • As against B, acceptance is complete when A receives it.

Therefore, B may potentially revoke the acceptance before Thursday, provided the revocation reaches A before the acceptance comes to A’s knowledge.

How Can Acceptance Be Revoked?

The revocation must itself be communicated to the proposer.

It may be communicated through a faster or otherwise effective method, depending on the circumstances.

Example

B posts acceptance to A.

Before A receives it, B sends a telegram, telephone message, email, or other effective communication stating:

“I revoke my acceptance.”

If the revocation reaches A before the original acceptance does, the statutory requirement may be satisfied.

The important point is:

Revocation must reach the proposer before the acceptance comes to the proposer’s knowledge.

Example of the Complete Sequence

Suppose:

1 October: A makes an offer to B.

2 October: B receives the offer.

3 October: B posts acceptance.

4 October: B sends an urgent communication revoking the acceptance.

5 October: Revocation reaches A.

6 October: Original acceptance reaches A.

If the relevant statutory requirements are satisfied, B’s revocation may be effective because it reached A before the acceptance came to A’s knowledge.

When Revocation of Acceptance Is Not Possible

Once communication of acceptance is complete as against the acceptor, the acceptance can no longer be revoked under Section 5.

Example

B accepts A’s offer and sends the acceptance to A.

A receives and becomes aware of the acceptance.

B then says:

“I withdraw my acceptance.”

At this stage, revocation is too late under Section 5.

The contractual relationship has already reached the relevant stage of formation.

Revocation of Acceptance vs Revocation of Offer

These two concepts are often confused.

Revocation of OfferRevocation of Acceptance
Withdrawal of an offerWithdrawal of an acceptance
Generally initiated by offerorInitiated by acceptor
Governed by Sections 5 and 6Governed by Section 5
Must occur before acceptance becomes complete against proposerMust occur before acceptance becomes complete against acceptor
Example: A withdraws his offer to BExample: B withdraws his acceptance sent to A

Revocation of Acceptance vs Rejection of Offer

Rejection happens when the offeree refuses the offer before accepting it.

Revocation of acceptance happens when the offeree has already communicated acceptance but seeks to withdraw that acceptance within the limited period allowed by law.

Rejection

A offers to sell a car to B.

B says:

“I reject your offer.”

No acceptance has taken place.

Revocation of Acceptance

A offers to sell the car.

B accepts and communicates acceptance.

Before communication becomes complete as against B, B validly communicates:

“I revoke my acceptance.”

The legal situations are different.

Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.

Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.

Join WhatsApp Channel

Revocation of Acceptance in Postal Communication

The rule is particularly important where acceptance is sent by post.

Illustration

A makes an offer to B by post.

B receives the offer and posts his acceptance.

Before the acceptance reaches A, B sends a faster communication revoking his acceptance.

If the revocation reaches A before the acceptance comes to A’s knowledge, Section 5 may permit the revocation.

This creates an important difference between:

Completion of acceptance against proposer

and

Completion of acceptance against acceptor.

Revocation of Acceptance Through Electronic Communication

Modern transactions may involve acceptance through:

  • Email
  • Online platforms
  • Electronic purchase orders
  • Business messaging
  • Other digital communications

The traditional postal rule cannot simply be applied mechanically to electronic communications.

Where acceptance is communicated instantaneously or electronically, the relevant question is generally when the acceptance is legally communicated or comes to the knowledge of the proposer, considering the circumstances and applicable terms.

Example

A sends an offer to B by email.

B emails:

“I accept your offer.”

B then immediately sends another email:

“I revoke my acceptance.”

Whether the revocation is effective depends upon the timing and receipt of the respective communications and the applicable contractual and legal rules.

Instantaneous Communication

Telephone and similar instantaneous communications are treated differently from traditional postal communication.

Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)

Principle

The Supreme Court dealt with acceptance communicated through telephone and emphasized that the rules governing instantaneous communication differ from the traditional postal rule.

The case is important when considering when acceptance becomes legally effective through immediate forms of communication.

Postal Rule and Revocation of Acceptance

The interaction between Sections 4 and 5 can be summarized as follows:

StageLegal Effect
Acceptance prepared but not communicatedNo communicated acceptance
Acceptance properly postedComplete against proposer under the postal rule
Acceptance reaches proposerComplete against acceptor
Revocation reaches proposer before acceptanceRevocation may be effective
Revocation reaches proposer after acceptance is knownRevocation is too late

Can Acceptance Be Revoked After a Contract Is Formed?

Generally, no.

Once communication of acceptance is complete as against the acceptor, the statutory opportunity to revoke acceptance under Section 5 has passed.

Any subsequent termination or cancellation would have to be dealt with under the applicable rules concerning:

  • Rescission
  • Breach
  • Novation
  • Alteration
  • Termination clauses
  • Other contractual remedies

It should not be confused with revocation of acceptance under Section 5.

Important Sections

SectionRelevance
Section 2(b)Defines acceptance
Section 3Communication of proposals, acceptances and revocations
Section 4Determines when communication of acceptance is complete
Section 5Specifically permits revocation of acceptance before the specified stage
Section 7Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified

Important Cases

Byrne v. Van Tienhoven (1880)

Principle: Revocation of an offer must be communicated to the offeree. It is useful for understanding the broader principle that revocation is not effective merely because the offeror privately decides to revoke.

Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)

Principle: Communication through instantaneous methods such as telephone must be distinguished from postal communication when determining when acceptance becomes effective.

Adams v. Lindsell (1818)

Principle: The traditional postal rule recognizes acceptance as effective against the proposer when it is properly posted, subject to the applicable circumstances.

Key Points for Examination

  • Section 5 specifically deals with revocation of acceptance.
  • Acceptance can be revoked before communication of acceptance is complete as against the acceptor.
  • Section 4 determines when communication becomes complete.
  • In postal communication, acceptance is generally complete against the proposer when it is put into transmission and out of the acceptor’s control.
  • Acceptance is complete against the acceptor when it comes to the knowledge of the proposer.
  • Therefore, a faster revocation may potentially reach the proposer before the original acceptance.
  • Once acceptance has become complete against the acceptor, revocation under Section 5 is too late.
  • Electronic and instantaneous communications require consideration of their particular mode and timing.
  • Revocation of acceptance is different from revocation of the original offer.
  • Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas is important for instantaneous communication.

Quick Revision

Section 5 Rule

Acceptance → Revocation before communication is complete against acceptor → Possible

Acceptance → Communication complete against acceptor → Revocation not possible under Section 5

Postal Example

B posts acceptance → B sends faster revocation → Revocation reaches A first → Revocation may be effective

But:

B posts acceptance → A receives acceptance → B tries to revoke → Too late

Conclusion

Revocation of acceptance is the limited right of an acceptor to withdraw an acceptance before the communication of that acceptance becomes complete as against the acceptor. Section 5, read with Section 4, establishes the principal rule.

The most important point is the distinction between the two stages of communication:

Acceptance complete against proposer → when properly put into transmission

Acceptance complete against acceptor → when it comes to proposer’s knowledge

Therefore, an acceptor may be able to revoke an acceptance during the intervening period, provided the revocation reaches the proposer before the acceptance becomes known to the proposer.