In Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India, the Supreme Court held that the Enforcement Directorate must furnish arrested persons with a copy of the written grounds of arrest under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002. Reading the grounds aloud or merely allowing the person to read them was inadequate. The Court also held that a remand order cannot cure an arrest that violates statutory safeguards. It set aside the appellants’ arrests and directed their release.
Case Details
| Detail | Particulars |
|---|---|
| Case name | Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India & Ors. |
| Court | Supreme Court of India |
| Case number | Criminal Appeal Nos. 3051–3052 of 2023, with Criminal Appeal Nos. 3053–3054 of 2023 |
| Judgment date | 3 October 2023 |
| Bench | A.S. Bopanna and Sanjay Kumar JJ. |
| Citation | 2023 INSC 866; (2024) 7 SCC 576 |
| Nature of decision | Final judgment allowing the appeals against the arrest and remand orders |
| Opinion | Unanimous; judgment authored by Sanjay Kumar J. |
Background and Material Facts
The appeals concerned Pankaj Bansal and his father, Basant Bansal, who were associated with the M3M real estate group.
The ED was investigating matters recorded in separate Enforcement Case Information Reports, or ECIRs. The Delhi High Court had granted the appellants interim anticipatory bail in connection with the first ECIR on 9 June 2023.
On 13 June 2023, the ED recorded a second ECIR based on an earlier corruption FIR. The appellants attended the ED’s office on 14 June pursuant to summons connected with the first matter. While there, they were proceeded against and arrested in connection with the second ECIR.
The ED maintained that the grounds of arrest had been read out or made available for reading. Copies were not furnished to the appellants.
Procedural History
Following their arrests, the appellants were produced before the competent court at Panchkula and remanded first to ED custody and subsequently to judicial custody.
Their challenges ultimately reached the Punjab and Haryana High Court, which dismissed their writ petitions through orders dated 20 and 26 July 2023.
They appealed to the Supreme Court, challenging the arrests and consequential remand orders.
Also Read: Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar: Arrest Guidelines, Police Duties and Magistrates’ Responsibilities
Issues Before the Court
The principal questions were:
- What does informing an arrested person of the grounds of arrest require under Section 19 PMLA and Article 22(1)?
- Can a remand order validate an otherwise unlawful arrest?
- Had the ED complied with the statutory safeguards in these cases?
- Could alleged non-cooperation, without more, justify arrest under Section 19?
Arguments of the Parties
The appellants argued that their arrests constituted an abuse of power and violated Section 19. They maintained that meaningful communication required furnishing the grounds in writing and that the remand court had acted mechanically.
The ED defended the arrests as based on incriminating material. It alleged evasive answers, non-cooperation and a risk of interference with the investigation.
It also maintained that reading or explaining the grounds satisfied the law and relied on decisions suggesting that judicial remand affected challenges to an arrest’s legality.
The Supreme Court expressly confined its examination to arrest and remand. It did not determine whether the appellants had committed money laundering.
Relevant Legal Provisions
Section 19 PMLA authorises specified officers to arrest a person when material in their possession provides reason to believe that the person is guilty of an offence under the Act. The reasons must be recorded in writing, and the person must be informed of the grounds of arrest.
Article 22(1) protects an arrested person’s right to be informed of the grounds and to consult a legal practitioner.
Section 45 PMLA imposes special conditions for bail. Knowledge of the arrest grounds is therefore important for preparing an effective application.
Section 50 PMLA concerns summons and examination during an inquiry.
The Court also considered Article 20(3) on self-incrimination and Section 167 CrPC, which governed the remand proceedings involved in the case.
Court’s Reasoning
Communication must make the right practically useful
The Court held that informing a person of the grounds must serve a meaningful constitutional purpose.
An arrested person needs to understand the basis of the arrest, obtain legal advice and prepare a response. This is particularly important under the PMLA because of Section 45’s stringent bail conditions.
Merely reading out detailed grounds assumes that a person, immediately after arrest, can remember everything necessary to pursue legal remedies. The Court considered that assumption unrealistic.
A written copy enables the arrested person and counsel to examine and respond to the stated basis for custody.
A written copy also prevents disputes about compliance
The ED’s practice was inconsistent: written copies were supplied in some places, while elsewhere the grounds were read aloud or shown to the arrested person.
This could produce a dispute between the officer’s account and the arrested person’s account.
The Court considered furnishing the written grounds under acknowledgement a straightforward way to establish compliance. It consequently directed that copies must be furnished as a matter of course.
Contrary approaches adopted by the Delhi and Bombay High Courts were held not to state the correct law.
The entire ECIR need not automatically be supplied
The Court distinguished the written grounds of arrest from disclosure of the entire investigative record.
In Vijay Madanlal Choudhary v. Union of India, the Supreme Court had held that supplying an ECIR was not mandatory in every case.
Pankaj Bansal clarified how arrest grounds must be communicated. It did not establish a general entitlement to every document held by the ED.
The Court also recognised that sensitive portions could be redacted where necessary to protect the investigation.
Remand requires independent judicial scrutiny
The remand court had a duty to examine whether Section 19’s requirements were satisfied.
The seriousness of allegations and an investigating agency’s request for custody could not substitute for that assessment. The Court found that the remand judge had failed to demonstrate the required scrutiny.
An order authorising custody therefore could not automatically validate an arrest that was unlawful at its inception.
Non-cooperation cannot be equated with failure to confess
Section 19 requires a material-based reason to believe that the person is guilty of a PMLA offence. Alleged non-cooperation alone does not satisfy that requirement.
The Court rejected an approach under which anything short of an admission of guilt could be labelled an evasive answer.
It also criticised the sequence in which the second ECIR was recorded and acted upon after the appellants obtained interim protection in the first matter. Those observations concerned the particular conduct established by the record.
Also Read: Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India: Supreme Court Quashes Remission Granted to 11 Convicts
Decision and Final Directions
The Supreme Court allowed the appeals and set aside:
- The impugned Punjab and Haryana High Court orders;
- The arrest orders and arrest memos;
- The challenged remand orders and consequential orders.
The appellants were directed to be released immediately unless their detention was validly required in another case.
This was a final determination of the arrest challenges. It was not an acquittal on the underlying money-laundering allegations.
There were no separate concurring or dissenting opinions.
Subsequent Clarification and Review
In Ram Kishor Arora v. Directorate of Enforcement, 2023 INSC 1082, the Court interpreted the written-copy direction, expressed as operating “henceforth”, as applying prospectively from 3 October 2023.
On 20 March 2024, the Supreme Court dismissed the Union’s review petitions against Pankaj Bansal, finding no apparent error warranting reconsideration.
The written-grounds principle was subsequently developed in Mihir Rajesh Shah v. State of Maharashtra, 2025 INSC 1288, which addressed its application across criminal statutes and the timing of communication.
Ratio Decidendi
Meaningful compliance with Section 19 PMLA and Article 22(1) requires furnishing written grounds of arrest. Merely reading or displaying them does not satisfy the direction laid down in this judgment.
The remand court must independently verify compliance with arrest safeguards. Judicial remand does not itself cure an unlawful arrest.
The decision clarified the operation of Section 19; it did not invalidate that provision or require automatic disclosure of the entire ECIR.
Significance for Law Students and Legal Practice
As an analytical matter, the judgment shows how a procedural safeguard enables substantive protection of liberty.
For examinations, it connects Article 22, statutory arrest powers, remand scrutiny and access to bail.
For practice, it makes the arrest record and remand order central documents. The inquiry concerns whether legal safeguards were actually observed, alongside the allegations relied upon by the investigating agency.
It also demonstrates why challenging the legality of arrest is distinct from contesting guilt at trial.
Also Read: Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh: Mandatory FIR Registration and Preliminary Inquiry
Key Takeaways
- The ED must furnish a copy of the written grounds of arrest.
- Communication must enable meaningful legal advice and access to remedies.
- A remand order does not automatically cure an unlawful arrest.
- Failure to confess cannot, by itself, establish non-cooperation justifying arrest.
- The appellants’ release did not amount to an acquittal.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp Channel