Misrepresentation Under Contract Law

Published: 9 min read

Meaning of Misrepresentation

Misrepresentation is a false or misleading representation that induces another person to enter into a contract, generally without an intention to deceive.

Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, misrepresentation is defined under Section 18, while Section 19 explains its effect on the validity of a contract.

Misrepresentation affects free consent because a person may agree to a contract based on incorrect information about a material fact. Unlike fraud, misrepresentation generally involves an honest but incorrect assertion, a breach of duty without an intent to deceive, or another situation covered by Section 18.

Example

A sells a plot of land to B and honestly states that the plot measures 2,000 square feet, believing the information to be correct. The actual area is only 1,500 square feet, and B enters into the contract relying on A’s statement.

Depending on the circumstances, A’s statement may amount to misrepresentation under Section 18.

Section 18 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872

Section 18 recognises three principal forms of misrepresentation:

  1. A positive assertion that is not warranted by the information of the person making it, even though that person believes it to be true.
  2. A breach of duty that, without an intent to deceive, gives an advantage to the person committing it or someone claiming under them by misleading another person to their prejudice.
  3. Causing, however innocently, a party to an agreement to make a mistake about the substance of the thing that is the subject of the agreement.

These categories show that misrepresentation is not limited to a straightforward false statement. It may also arise through a breach of duty or innocent conduct that causes a legally relevant mistake.

Essentials of Misrepresentation

1. There Must Be a False or Misleading Representation

The representation must be incorrect or misleading in a legally relevant way.

It may concern matters such as:

  • the nature or condition of goods;
  • ownership or title to property;
  • the area or characteristics of land;
  • the financial position of a business; or
  • another material fact relevant to the transaction.

Example: A tells B that a machine has been used for only one year, genuinely believing this to be true. In fact, it has been used for five years. The statement may constitute misrepresentation if the other legal requirements are met.

2. The Representation Must Fall Within Section 18

Not every inaccurate statement amounts to misrepresentation under the Contract Act.

The conduct must fall within one of the categories specified in Section 18, such as an unwarranted positive assertion made honestly, a misleading breach of duty without an intent to deceive, or innocent conduct causing a mistake about the substance of the subject matter.

3. There Must Be No Fraudulent Intention in the Ordinary Case

Misrepresentation is generally distinguished from fraud by the absence of an intention to deceive.

The person making the representation may genuinely believe that it is true, even though it is incorrect or misleading.

However, the legal classification depends on the actual conduct. A person who knows that a statement is false, or makes it recklessly without caring whether it is true, may be committing fraud rather than innocent misrepresentation.

4. The Representation Must Induce Consent

The representation must have caused the other party to enter into the agreement.

If the other party did not rely on the representation or was not induced by it, the basis for avoiding the contract under Section 19 may be absent.

Example: A makes an incorrect statement about a property’s location, but B already knows the correct location and does not rely on A’s statement when purchasing it. The statement may not have induced B’s consent.

5. The Representation Must Be Legally Relevant

The statement or conduct must concern a matter relevant to the agreement and satisfy the statutory requirements.

A mere expression of opinion, sales exaggeration or statement about a future possibility does not automatically amount to misrepresentation. The context, wording and circumstances must be examined.

Types of Misrepresentation

1. Innocent Misrepresentation

Innocent misrepresentation occurs when a person makes an incorrect representation without intending to deceive the other party.

Example: A sells a painting to B and honestly believes it is an original work by a particular artist. The painting is later found to be a copy.

Whether the statement amounts to misrepresentation depends on the circumstances, including the basis on which A made the assertion and whether the requirements of Section 18 are satisfied.

2. Negligent Misrepresentation

The expression negligent misrepresentation is commonly used to describe a representation made without reasonable care to verify its accuracy.

Under Section 18, a positive assertion that is not warranted by the information of the person making it may qualify even where that person believes it to be true.

However, negligent misrepresentation is not a separate category expressly named in Section 18. Its legal treatment depends on the facts and the applicable principles.

Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.

Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.

Join WhatsApp Channel

3. Misrepresentation Through Breach of Duty

Section 18 also covers a breach of duty that, without an intention to deceive, gives an advantage to the person committing it by misleading another person to their prejudice.

Example: A person responsible for providing material information in a transaction breaches that duty, innocently misleads the other party and gains an advantage from the misunderstanding.

Whether the conduct qualifies as misrepresentation depends on the duty involved and the statutory requirements.

Effect of Misrepresentation on a Contract

Section 19: Voidability of Agreement

Section 19 provides that when consent to an agreement is caused by misrepresentation, the agreement is generally a contract voidable at the option of the party whose consent was so caused, subject to the statutory qualifications.

This means that the affected party may choose to avoid the contract rather than remain bound by it.

The contract is not automatically void merely because one party made an incorrect statement.

Exception: Ordinary Diligence

Section 19 provides an important qualification: where consent was caused by misrepresentation, or by silence that amounts to fraud under Section 17, the contract is not voidable if the affected party had the means of discovering the truth with ordinary diligence.

This qualification must be applied to the circumstances of the case and should not be treated as a universal defence for every type of misrepresentation.

Remedies for Misrepresentation

1. Rescission of Contract

The party whose consent was caused by misrepresentation may generally seek to avoid the contract under Section 19, subject to the statutory qualifications.

Rescission aims to undo the contractual relationship where the law permits it.

2. Restoration of Benefits

Where a voidable contract is rescinded, Section 64 may require the party rescinding it to restore benefits received under the contract, so far as possible.

The precise consequences depend on the transaction and the applicable legal rules.

3. Other Remedies

Depending on the facts, the contract’s terms and the applicable law, other remedies may be available. However, damages are not automatically recoverable in every case of innocent misrepresentation merely because the contract is voidable.

The legal basis for any additional remedy must be established separately.

Important Case Laws on Misrepresentation

Bisset v. Wilkinson (1927)

In this English case, a seller made a statement about the amount of land that could be used to carry sheep. The statement was treated as an opinion rather than a representation of an established fact in the circumstances.

Principle: A statement of opinion does not automatically amount to a false representation of fact. Its nature and context must be examined.

Derry v. Peek (1889)

This English case is principally an authority on fraudulent misrepresentation rather than innocent misrepresentation.

The House of Lords explained the requirements for establishing fraud in connection with a false statement.

Principle: A false statement made knowingly, without belief in its truth, or recklessly without caring whether it is true or false may constitute fraud.

The case is useful for distinguishing fraud from an honestly made but incorrect representation.

Misrepresentation vs Fraud

BasisMisrepresentationFraud
ProvisionSection 18Section 17
IntentionGenerally no intention to deceiveFraudulent intention or other conduct specified by Section 17
KnowledgeThe person may honestly believe the statement to be trueThe person may know the statement is false or act recklessly as to its truth
ConductMay include unwarranted assertions, breach of duty or innocent mistakeMay include false assertions, active concealment and promises made without an intention to perform
EffectContract generally voidable under Section 19Contract generally voidable under Section 19, subject to statutory qualifications

Misrepresentation vs Mistake

BasisMisrepresentationMistake
Main featureA representation or conduct induces consentA party or both parties operate under an incorrect belief
Relevant provisionsSections 18 and 19Sections 20–22, depending on the type of mistake
Source of errorMay arise from another party’s representation or conductMay arise independently or from a shared misunderstanding
Legal consequenceContract generally voidable if statutory requirements are metDepends on whether the mistake is bilateral, unilateral or a mistake of law

Section 14 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, provides that consent is free when it is not caused by coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation or mistake, subject to the Act’s provisions.

The relevant provisions work together as follows:

  • Section 14: Defines free consent.
  • Section 18: Defines misrepresentation.
  • Section 19: Explains the effect of consent caused by misrepresentation.
  • Section 64: Deals with restoration of benefits following rescission of a voidable contract.

Key Points for Exams

  • Misrepresentation is defined under Section 18 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
  • Section 19 governs the effect of consent caused by misrepresentation.
  • Misrepresentation generally involves an incorrect or misleading representation without an intention to deceive.
  • Section 18 covers unwarranted positive assertions, certain breaches of duty and innocent conduct causing a mistake about the substance of the subject matter.
  • The representation must induce the other party’s consent.
  • A contract induced by misrepresentation is generally voidable, not automatically void.
  • Section 19 contains a qualification concerning the means of discovering the truth through ordinary diligence.
  • A statement of opinion does not automatically amount to misrepresentation.
  • Bisset v. Wilkinson (1927) illustrates the distinction between opinion and fact.
  • Fraud and misrepresentation are distinguished primarily by the nature of the conduct and the presence of fraudulent intent.

Quick Revision

Section 18 → Definition of misrepresentation

↓

Incorrect or misleading representation

↓

Representation induces consent

↓

Section 19 → Contract generally becomes voidable

↓

Section 64 → Restoration of benefits may follow rescission

Conclusion

Misrepresentation is an important factor affecting free consent under Indian contract law. Section 18 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, covers certain false or misleading assertions, breaches of duty and innocent conduct that causes a mistake about the substance of the subject matter.

Where misrepresentation causes a party to enter into an agreement, Section 19 generally allows that party to avoid the contract, subject to the statutory qualifications. Unlike fraud, misrepresentation ordinarily does not involve an intention to deceive.

The central principle is that a party may be entitled to avoid a contract when their consent was induced by a legally recognised misrepresentation.