Contracts may be classified according to the extent to which the contractual promises have been performed. On this basis, contracts are commonly classified as executed contracts and executory contracts.
- Executed Contract
- Characteristics of an Executed Contract
- Example of an Executed Contract
- Executory Contract
- Characteristics of an Executory Contract
- Example of an Executory Contract
- Partly Executed and Partly Executory Contract
- Executed and Executory Contracts Compared
- Executed Contract vs Executory Contract: Simple Example
- Executed Contract and Executed Consideration
- Executory Contract and Executory Consideration
- Relationship with Reciprocal Promises
- Performance of Executory Contracts
- Executed Contract and Discharge by Performance
- Executory Contract and Breach
- Anticipatory Breach and Executory Contracts
- Executed vs Executory vs Partly Executed
- Important Cases
- Executed and Executory Contracts in Commercial Transactions
- Why the Distinction Matters
- Key Points for Examination
- Conclusion
The distinction is based mainly on whether the obligations undertaken by the parties have already been performed or remain to be performed.
In simple terms:
Executed Contract → Performance is complete
Executory Contract → Performance remains due
A contract may also be partly executed and partly executory, where one party has performed its obligation while the other party’s obligation remains outstanding.
Executed Contract
An executed contract is a contract in which the parties have completely performed their respective contractual obligations.
Once the promised acts have been performed, there is no substantial contractual performance remaining to be carried out.
Example
A buys a book from B for ₹500.
- A pays ₹500.
- B delivers the book.
Both parties have performed their obligations. The transaction is therefore an executed contract.
Characteristics of an Executed Contract
Complete Performance
The principal contractual obligations of the parties have been performed.
No Outstanding Performance
Neither party has a remaining contractual obligation that is required to complete the transaction.
Performance Creates Discharge
When contractual obligations are completely performed, the parties are generally discharged from those obligations by performance.
Common in Immediate Transactions
Cash purchases and other transactions completed immediately are common examples.
Example of an Executed Contract
A purchases a laptop from B for ₹50,000.
A immediately pays the full amount and B immediately delivers the laptop.
Both parties have performed their respective obligations.
Therefore, the contract is executed.
Executory Contract
An executory contract is a contract in which one or more contractual obligations remain to be performed.
The parties have entered into the contract, but performance is still pending.
Example
A agrees to sell 100 bags of rice to B for ₹2 lakh.
The agreement is made today, but:
- A will deliver the rice next month; and
- B will pay the price on delivery.
Since the contractual obligations remain to be performed, the contract is executory.
Characteristics of an Executory Contract
Performance is Pending
One or more contractual obligations remain outstanding.
Future Obligations
The parties have undertaken obligations that are to be performed in the future.
Continuing Contractual Relationship
The parties remain bound by their contractual promises until the obligations are performed, discharged or otherwise brought to an end according to law.
Common in Commercial Transactions
Supply contracts, construction contracts, employment agreements and long-term service arrangements may involve executory obligations.
Example of an Executory Contract
A agrees to construct a house for B for ₹20 lakh.
The contract is entered into today, but:
- Construction will take six months.
- Payments will be made according to agreed stages.
The obligations have not yet been completely performed. The contract is therefore executory, at least until performance is completed.
Partly Executed and Partly Executory Contract
A contract may be partly executed and partly executory where one party has performed their obligation while the other party’s obligation remains outstanding.
Example
A sells goods to B for ₹1 lakh.
A delivers the goods immediately, but B has 30 days to make payment.
Here:
- A has performed the delivery obligation.
- B’s payment obligation remains outstanding.
Therefore, the contract is partly executed and partly executory.
Executed and Executory Contracts Compared
| Basis | Executed Contract | Executory Contract |
|---|---|---|
| Performance | Completely performed | One or more obligations remain |
| Outstanding obligations | Generally none | Present |
| Nature | Completed performance | Pending performance |
| Example | Goods delivered and price paid immediately | Goods to be delivered and paid for later |
| Discharge | Performance has generally discharged the contractual obligations | Parties remain bound to perform outstanding obligations |
Executed Contract vs Executory Contract: Simple Example
Suppose A agrees to sell a laptop to B for ₹40,000.
Situation 1: Executed
A delivers the laptop and B immediately pays ₹40,000.
Result: Executed contract.
Situation 2: Executory
A agrees to deliver the laptop next week and B agrees to pay on delivery.
Result: Executory contract.
Situation 3: Partly Executed and Partly Executory
A delivers the laptop today, but B has 15 days to make payment.
Result: One party has performed while the other still has an outstanding obligation.
Executed Contract and Executed Consideration
An important distinction should be made between an executed contract and executed consideration.
Consideration may be described as executed where the act constituting consideration has already been performed.
Example
A promises to pay B ₹10,000 if B finds and returns A’s lost phone.
B finds and returns the phone.
B’s act constitutes performed consideration.
This concept is particularly relevant to unilateral offers and should not be confused with the broader classification of a contract as executed or executory.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp ChannelExecutory Contract and Executory Consideration
Consideration is executory where the promised act or performance remains to be carried out.
Example
A promises to deliver goods to B next month, and B promises to pay upon delivery.
At the relevant stage, both sides have outstanding future obligations.
The consideration is executory.
Relationship with Reciprocal Promises
Executory contracts commonly involve reciprocal promises.
Section 2(f) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 provides that promises which form the consideration or part of the consideration for each other are called reciprocal promises.
Example
A promises to supply 500 units of goods to B.
B promises to pay ₹3 lakh for them.
If both obligations are still pending, the contract contains executory reciprocal promises.
The provisions relating to performance of reciprocal promises are found principally in Sections 51–54.
Performance of Executory Contracts
The Indian Contract Act contains several provisions dealing with performance.
Section 37
Section 37 provides the general rule that parties to a contract must either:
- Perform, or
- Offer to perform,
their respective promises, unless performance is dispensed with or excused under the Act or another law.
Section 38
Section 38 deals with refusal to accept a valid offer of performance, commonly referred to as tender of performance.
Sections 51–54
These provisions deal with the performance of reciprocal promises.
They address situations such as:
- Simultaneous performance;
- The order of performance;
- Prevention of performance; and
- Failure to perform the promise that should be performed first.
Executed Contract and Discharge by Performance
Performance is one of the principal ways in which contractual obligations are discharged.
When both parties have completely performed their promises, the contractual obligations are generally discharged by performance.
Example
A agrees to deliver 100 books to B for ₹50,000.
A delivers all 100 books and B pays ₹50,000.
Both parties have performed their promises.
The contractual obligations are discharged by performance.
Executory Contract and Breach
Because an executory contract contains outstanding obligations, failure to perform may result in breach of contract.
Example
A agrees to deliver goods to B on 1 December.
A refuses to deliver the goods without lawful justification.
A’s refusal may constitute breach, depending upon the terms of the contract and applicable law.
Section 39 deals with refusal to perform a promise wholly and the consequences of such refusal in appropriate circumstances.
Anticipatory Breach and Executory Contracts
Executory contracts are particularly relevant to anticipatory breach.
Under Section 39, where a party refuses to perform or disables themselves from performing their promise wholly, the promisee may, in appropriate circumstances, put an end to the contract unless they have signified their acquiescence in its continuance.
Example
A agrees to deliver goods to B on 1 December.
On 15 November, A clearly informs B that he will not deliver the goods.
Because performance is still due, the refusal may constitute an anticipatory breach.
Executed vs Executory vs Partly Executed
| Type | Position of Performance | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Executed | Both parties have completed performance | Goods delivered and price paid |
| Executory | Performance remains outstanding | Goods and payment both due next month |
| Partly executed and partly executory | One side has performed, the other has not | Goods delivered but payment due later |
Important Cases
Kanhaiya Lal Mukundlal Saraf v. Commissioner of Income Tax (1959)
The Supreme Court considered the effect of payment made under mistake and the restitutionary obligation under Section 72.
The case is useful when studying the consequences that may arise after performance or payment has already taken place.
State of West Bengal v. B.K. Mondal & Sons (1962)
The Supreme Court considered Section 70 and the obligation arising when a person lawfully does something for another without intending to act gratuitously and the other person enjoys the benefit.
The case is relevant to understanding obligations that may arise from completed acts even where a formal enforceable contract is absent.
Satyabrata Ghose v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co. (1954)
The Supreme Court considered Section 56 and the effect of subsequent impossibility on contractual obligations.
The case is relevant because an executory contractual obligation may be affected when circumstances make performance impossible in the legal sense recognised by the Act.
Executed and Executory Contracts in Commercial Transactions
The distinction is particularly useful in commercial contracts.
Sale of Goods
A contract where goods and payment are immediately exchanged may be executed.
A contract providing for delivery and payment at a future date is executory.
Construction Contract
A construction agreement is generally executory at the beginning because substantial obligations remain to be performed.
As construction progresses, some obligations are performed while others remain outstanding.
Employment Contract
An employment relationship involves continuing obligations.
The employee provides services over time, while the employer provides remuneration according to the contractual terms.
Thus, contractual obligations continue to be performed over the duration of the relationship.
Service Contract
A contract for a service to be provided over several months is generally executory until the agreed services have been performed.
Why the Distinction Matters
The classification helps determine the current position of the parties’ obligations.
It helps identify:
- Whether performance remains outstanding;
- Whether a party has already performed its obligation;
- Whether a breach has occurred;
- Whether reciprocal promises remain to be performed;
- Whether the contract has been discharged by performance; and
- What contractual remedies may become relevant.
Key Points for Examination
- An executed contract is one in which contractual obligations have been completely performed.
- An executory contract is one in which one or more obligations remain to be performed.
- A contract may be partly executed and partly executory.
- Section 37 deals with the general obligation to perform or offer to perform promises.
- Sections 51–54 deal with performance of reciprocal promises.
- Section 39 deals with refusal to perform a promise wholly and anticipatory breach.
- Executed contracts are commonly associated with discharge by performance.
- Executory contracts involve outstanding contractual obligations.
- Executed and executory consideration are related concepts but should not be confused with the classification of the contract itself.
- Most contracts may begin as executory and become executed as the parties complete their obligations.
- The classification depends upon the stage and extent of performance.
Conclusion
Executed and executory contracts are distinguished primarily by the status of performance.
An executed contract is one where the contractual obligations have been completed. An executory contract is one where performance remains outstanding on one or both sides. Where one party has performed while the other still has an obligation remaining, the contract may be described as partly executed and partly executory.
The simplest way to remember the distinction is:
Executed Contract = Performance completed
Executory Contract = Performance pending
Partly Executed and Partly Executory = One side performed, another obligation remains
This classification is particularly important when studying performance of contracts, reciprocal promises, breach, anticipatory breach and discharge by performance.