Acceptance is the assent given by the person to whom an offer is made. Under Section 2(b) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, when the person to whom a proposal is made signifies assent to it, the proposal is said to be accepted and becomes a promise.
- 1. Acceptance Must Be Absolute and Unqualified
- 2. Acceptance Must Be Communicated
- 3. Acceptance Must Be Made by the Proper Person
- 4. Acceptance Must Be Made Within the Prescribed Time
- 5. Acceptance Must Be Made Within a Reasonable Time
- 6. Acceptance Must Be Made Before Revocation or Lapse
- 7. Acceptance Must Be Made in the Prescribed Manner
- 8. Acceptance Must Correspond With the Offer
- 9. Acceptance Must Be Made With Knowledge of the Offer
- 10. Acceptance May Be Express or Implied
- 11. Acceptance May Be by Performance
- 12. Acceptance Must Be Unambiguous
- 13. Acceptance Must Be Made Before the Offer Is Withdrawn
- 14. Acceptance Cannot Normally Be Imposed Through Silence
- 15. Acceptance Must Be Made in Response to the Offer
- Communication of Acceptance Under Section 4
- Acceptance Through Instantaneous Communication
- Acceptance Through Electronic Communication
- Acceptance and Counter Offer
- Important Sections
- Important Cases
- Essentials of Valid Acceptance — Quick Table
- Key Points for Examination
- Easy Formula for Revision
- Conclusion
However, not every response to an offer constitutes valid acceptance. For acceptance to create a binding contractual relationship, it must satisfy certain legal requirements.
The basic rule is:
Valid Offer + Valid Acceptance + Other Essentials = Contract
1. Acceptance Must Be Absolute and Unqualified
Under Section 7(1), acceptance must be absolute and unqualified.
The offeree must accept the offer exactly as it is made. If the offeree changes or adds conditions to the offer, the response is generally a counter offer, not acceptance.
Example
A offers to sell his car to B for ₹6 lakh.
B says:
“I accept, provided you include insurance.”
This is not valid acceptance because B has introduced a new condition.
Hyde v. Wrench (1840)
Principle: A counter offer generally terminates the original offer and is not acceptance of it.
2. Acceptance Must Be Communicated
Acceptance must generally be communicated to the offeror.
A person cannot ordinarily create a contract merely by privately deciding to accept an offer.
Example
A offers to sell a laptop to B for ₹50,000.
B thinks:
“I accept.”
But B does not communicate this acceptance to A.
Ordinarily, there is no communicated acceptance.
However, where the offer itself permits or requires acceptance through performance, communication may occur through the required performance under Section 8.
3. Acceptance Must Be Made by the Proper Person
A specific offer must ordinarily be accepted by the person to whom it is made.
Example
A offers to sell a house specifically to B for ₹40 lakh.
C cannot ordinarily accept the offer merely because C knows about it.
In contrast, a general offer may be accepted by any person who has knowledge of it and fulfills its conditions.
4. Acceptance Must Be Made Within the Prescribed Time
Where the offer specifies a period for acceptance, acceptance must generally occur within that period.
Example
A says:
“I offer to sell this machine for ₹10 lakh. This offer will remain open until 10 October.”
B attempts to accept on 15 October.
If the offer had already lapsed, B cannot ordinarily accept it.
5. Acceptance Must Be Made Within a Reasonable Time
Where no specific period is mentioned, acceptance must be made within a reasonable time.
What constitutes a reasonable time depends on:
- Nature of the transaction
- Subject matter of the offer
- Market conditions
- Circumstances of the parties
- Method of communication
- Conduct of the parties
Example
An offer concerning goods whose value changes rapidly may require acceptance within a shorter period than an offer concerning a long-term transaction.
Ramsgate Victoria Hotel Co. v. Montefiore (1866)
Principle: An offer may lapse if it is not accepted within a reasonable time.
6. Acceptance Must Be Made Before Revocation or Lapse
Acceptance must take place while the offer is still open.
If the offer has already been:
- revoked;
- rejected;
- terminated by a counter offer;
- allowed to lapse; or
- otherwise brought to an end,
there is ordinarily nothing left to accept.
Example
A offers to sell a car to B.
Before B accepts, A validly revokes the offer.
B cannot ordinarily accept the revoked offer later.
7. Acceptance Must Be Made in the Prescribed Manner
Under Section 7(2), acceptance must be expressed in a usual and reasonable manner unless the proposal prescribes a particular manner of acceptance.
Example
A says:
“If you agree, communicate your acceptance by email.”
B sends an email accepting the offer.
The prescribed method has been followed.
If the offeree uses a different method, the legal consequences depend upon the circumstances and the offeror’s response.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp Channel8. Acceptance Must Correspond With the Offer
Acceptance must correspond with the terms of the original offer.
The offeree cannot change:
- price;
- quantity;
- subject matter;
- conditions; or
- other material terms
and still describe the response as acceptance.
Example
A offers:
“I will sell 100 chairs for ₹1 lakh.”
B replies:
“I accept the offer for 50 chairs for ₹50,000.”
B has not accepted the original offer. The response introduces different terms.
It is generally a counter offer.
9. Acceptance Must Be Made With Knowledge of the Offer
A person cannot ordinarily accept an offer of which they have no knowledge.
This is particularly important in cases involving general offers and rewards.
Example
A announces:
“₹10,000 reward to anyone who finds my lost dog.”
B finds the dog without knowing about the reward.
B cannot ordinarily claim that he accepted the offer because he was unaware of it when performing the act.
Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)
Principle: Knowledge of the offer is necessary for valid acceptance.
10. Acceptance May Be Express or Implied
Under Section 9, promises may be express or implied.
Express Acceptance
Acceptance is communicated through words, whether oral or written.
Example:
“I accept your offer.”
Implied Acceptance
Acceptance is inferred from conduct.
Example:
A offers a service under circumstances where acceptance is ordinarily indicated by taking the service, and B proceeds with the transaction in accordance with the terms.
The conduct must clearly indicate assent in the circumstances.
11. Acceptance May Be by Performance
Under Section 8, performance of the conditions of a proposal can constitute acceptance.
This is particularly important in general offers.
Example
A announces:
“₹5,000 will be paid to anyone who returns my lost dog.”
B knows about the offer and returns the dog.
B’s performance of the condition may constitute acceptance.
Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)
Principle: A general offer can be accepted by performing the conditions specified in the offer.
12. Acceptance Must Be Unambiguous
Acceptance should clearly indicate the offeree’s assent.
A vague or uncertain response may not constitute valid acceptance.
Example
A offers to sell a car to B for ₹5 lakh.
B replies:
“I think that should be fine.”
This may not clearly demonstrate final assent.
In contrast:
“I accept your offer to purchase the car for ₹5 lakh.”
clearly indicates acceptance.
13. Acceptance Must Be Made Before the Offer Is Withdrawn
This requirement follows from Sections 5 and 6.
If the offeror has validly revoked the offer and the revocation has become legally effective before acceptance, the offeree cannot subsequently accept the revoked offer.
Example
A offers to sell a property to B.
A validly communicates withdrawal of the offer before B accepts.
B’s later acceptance cannot ordinarily create a contract from the withdrawn offer.
14. Acceptance Cannot Normally Be Imposed Through Silence
The offeror cannot generally state that silence will automatically amount to acceptance.
Example
A tells B:
“If you do not reply within three days, I will consider the offer accepted.”
B remains silent.
Silence by itself does not ordinarily amount to acceptance.
Felthouse v. Bindley (1862)
Principle: Silence generally does not constitute acceptance.
However, acceptance by conduct or performance can be valid where the circumstances and terms of the offer establish such a mode of acceptance.
15. Acceptance Must Be Made in Response to the Offer
There must be a connection between the offer and the acceptance.
A person cannot accept an offer without knowing what proposal they are purportedly accepting.
Example
A makes several different offers to B.
B sends a message saying:
“I accept.”
If it is unclear which offer B is accepting, the communication may be insufficiently certain.
The acceptance must identify or sufficiently correspond to the relevant offer.
Communication of Acceptance Under Section 4
Section 4 determines when communication of acceptance is complete.
For traditional postal communication, communication of acceptance is complete:
As against the proposer
When the acceptance is put into a course of transmission to the proposer so as to be out of the power of the acceptor.
As against the acceptor
When the acceptance comes to the knowledge of the proposer.
This distinction is particularly important when considering revocation of acceptance and the formation of contracts through postal communication.
Acceptance Through Instantaneous Communication
Where acceptance is communicated through telephone or other instantaneous means, the rules differ from traditional postal communication.
Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)
Principle: The communication of acceptance through instantaneous communication must be considered according to the nature and circumstances of that communication.
This case is important for understanding acceptance through telephone and similar methods.
Acceptance Through Electronic Communication
Modern contracts may be accepted through:
- Online purchase systems
- Electronic orders
- Digital communications
- Online agreements
Example
A sends an email:
“We offer to supply 500 units at ₹200 each.”
B replies:
“We accept the offer on the stated terms.”
This may constitute valid acceptance if the communication satisfies the applicable legal requirements.
Section 10A of the Information Technology Act, 2000 recognizes the validity of contracts formed through electronic means, subject to other applicable legal requirements.
Acceptance and Counter Offer
This distinction is essential.
Valid Acceptance
A:
“I will sell my car for ₹6 lakh.”
B:
“I accept your offer for ₹6 lakh.”
Result: Acceptance.
Counter Offer
A:
“I will sell my car for ₹6 lakh.”
B:
“I will buy it for ₹5.5 lakh.”
Result: Counter offer, not acceptance.
Therefore:
Acceptance = Assent to existing terms
Counter Offer = New or modified terms
Important Sections
| Section | Relevance |
|---|---|
| Section 2(b) | Definition of acceptance |
| Section 3 | Communication of proposal, acceptance and revocation |
| Section 4 | Completion of communication |
| Section 5 | Revocation of proposal and acceptance |
| Section 7 | Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified |
| Section 8 | Acceptance by performance |
| Section 9 | Express and implied promises |
Important Cases
Hyde v. Wrench (1840)
Principle: A counter offer is not acceptance and generally terminates the original offer.
Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)
Principle: Knowledge of the offer is necessary for valid acceptance.
Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)
Principle: A general offer can be accepted by performing its specified conditions.
Felthouse v. Bindley (1862)
Principle: Silence generally does not constitute acceptance.
Ramsgate Victoria Hotel Co. v. Montefiore (1866)
Principle: An offer may lapse if not accepted within a reasonable time.
Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)
Principle: Communication of acceptance through instantaneous communication is governed differently from traditional postal communication.
Essentials of Valid Acceptance — Quick Table
| Essential | Rule |
|---|---|
| Absolute and unqualified | No modification of original terms |
| Communication | Acceptance must generally be communicated |
| Proper person | Must be accepted by the entitled offeree |
| Within time | Within prescribed or reasonable time |
| Before revocation/lapse | Offer must still be open |
| Prescribed manner | Follow specified mode where applicable |
| Correspondence | Must match the offer |
| Knowledge | Offeree must know of the offer |
| Clear and certain | Must demonstrate definite assent |
| Express or implied | May be through words or conduct |
| Performance | May constitute acceptance under Section 8 |
Key Points for Examination
- Section 2(b) defines acceptance.
- Acceptance converts a proposal into a promise.
- Under Section 7, acceptance must be absolute and unqualified.
- Acceptance must generally be communicated.
- It must be made by the proper person.
- It must occur within the prescribed or reasonable time.
- It must take place before revocation or lapse of the offer.
- Acceptance must correspond with the original offer.
- A counter offer is not valid acceptance.
- Knowledge of the offer is necessary.
- Acceptance may be express, implied, or by performance where permitted.
- Silence generally does not constitute acceptance.
- Sections 2(b), 3, 4, 5, 7, 8 and 9 are particularly important.
Easy Formula for Revision
Valid Acceptance =
Absolute + Unqualified + Communicated + Proper Person + Within Time + Before Revocation/Lapse + Corresponds with Offer
And remember:
Offer + Acceptance = Agreement
Agreement + Enforceability = Contract
Conclusion
A valid acceptance is the final, clear and unconditional assent to an existing offer. The Indian Contract Act, 1872 places particular importance on the requirement that acceptance must be absolute and unqualified under Section 7.
For examination purposes, the most important requirements are communication, absolute and unqualified assent, proper person, prescribed or reasonable time, conformity with the offer, knowledge of the offer, and acceptance before revocation or lapse.
The central rule is:
An acceptance must accept the offer as it stands; if it changes the terms, it generally becomes a counter offer.