Communication of Acceptance

Published: 10 min read

Communication of acceptance means conveying the offeree’s assent to the offeror in a legally recognized manner. Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, acceptance is not merely a mental decision to agree; the law provides specific rules regarding how and when acceptance is communicated.

The principal provisions are Sections 3 and 4, read with Sections 5 and 7.

The basic principle is:

Offer → Acceptance → Communication of Acceptance → Contract, subject to other requirements

Meaning of Communication of Acceptance

Under Section 2(b), when the person to whom a proposal is made signifies assent to it, the proposal is said to be accepted.

However, the legal effect of acceptance depends upon its communication.

Example

A offers to sell his car to B for ₹5 lakh.

B thinks:

“I accept the offer.”

But B does not communicate this decision to A.

Ordinarily, B’s private intention does not amount to communicated acceptance.

If B sends an acceptance to A through an appropriate method, the rules relating to communication of acceptance become applicable.

Section 3: Communication of Acceptance

Section 3 provides the general framework for communication of proposals, acceptances and revocations.

Communication may be made by:

  • Any act or omission intended to communicate the proposal, acceptance or revocation; or
  • Conduct having the effect of communicating it.

Thus, acceptance may be communicated through words, writing, electronic communication, or conduct where legally appropriate.

Section 4: When Communication of Acceptance Is Complete

Section 4 is the most important provision concerning communication of acceptance.

It provides different points at which communication becomes complete against the proposer and against the acceptor.

Communication of Acceptance Against the Proposer

Communication of acceptance is complete as against the proposer when the acceptance is:

put into a course of transmission to him, so as to be out of the power of the acceptor.

This is the traditional postal rule.

Example

A posts an offer to B.

B receives the offer and posts his acceptance.

Once B properly posts the acceptance, the communication of acceptance is generally complete as against A, because B has placed it into transmission and it is no longer within B’s control.

Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.

Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.

Join WhatsApp Channel

Communication of Acceptance Against the Acceptor

Communication is complete as against the acceptor when the acceptance comes to the knowledge of the proposer.

Therefore, in the traditional postal situation:

Against proposer: When acceptance is posted.

Against acceptor: When acceptance reaches the proposer and comes to his knowledge.

Postal Rule

The postal rule is one of the most important concepts in communication of acceptance.

Example

A makes an offer to B by post.

B receives the offer on 1 October.

B posts his acceptance on 2 October.

A receives the acceptance on 5 October.

Under Section 4:

  • As against A, acceptance is generally complete on 2 October.
  • As against B, acceptance is generally complete when it comes to A’s knowledge on 5 October.

This difference is important when determining whether either party can revoke the relevant communication.

Why Is the Distinction Important?

The distinction between completion of communication against the proposer and against the acceptor becomes important because Section 5 allows revocation of acceptance before communication of acceptance is complete as against the acceptor.

Thus, the Act creates different stages for the legal effectiveness of acceptance.

Revocation of Acceptance

Under Section 5, an acceptance may be revoked at any time before communication of the acceptance is complete as against the acceptor, but not afterwards.

Example

B posts an acceptance to A.

Before the acceptance reaches A, B sends a faster communication revoking the acceptance.

If the revocation reaches A before the acceptance itself comes to A’s knowledge, the statutory rule concerning revocation of acceptance may permit the revocation.

This is a special rule and should be distinguished from revocation of the original offer.

Communication Through Different Modes

1. Oral Communication

Acceptance may be communicated verbally.

Example

A says:

“I will sell the car for ₹5 lakh.”

B replies:

“I accept.”

The acceptance is communicated orally.

2. Written Communication

Acceptance may be communicated through:

  • Letter
  • Written notice
  • Signed document
  • Other written communication

Example

A sends B a written offer.

B signs an acceptance and sends it to A.

The rules governing the particular mode of communication then apply.

3. Telephone

Telephone communication is generally considered instantaneous communication.

Unlike traditional postal communication, the acceptance is not ordinarily treated as effective merely because the words have been sent into a postal-type transmission system.

Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)

Principle

The Supreme Court considered acceptance communicated through telephone and emphasized the importance of the place and circumstances of communication in determining when acceptance becomes effective.

The case is important for distinguishing instantaneous communication from postal communication.

Electronic Communication

Modern acceptance may be communicated through:

  • Email
  • Online platforms
  • Electronic purchase orders
  • Business messaging
  • Other electronic communications

Example

A emails B:

“We offer to supply 500 units at ₹200 per unit.”

B replies:

“We accept the offer on the stated terms.”

The acceptance is communicated electronically.

Section 10A of the Information Technology Act, 2000 recognizes the validity of contracts formed through electronic means, subject to other applicable legal requirements.

Email Acceptance

Email presents a practical question: when does the acceptance become legally effective?

Unlike traditional postal communication, email is generally treated as a form of electronic or instantaneous communication, and the precise point of communication depends upon the circumstances, the applicable contractual terms, and when the electronic communication is legally received and accessible.

Therefore, the traditional postal rule should not simply be applied mechanically to every email transaction.

Example

A sends an offer by email.

B replies by email accepting the offer.

The relevant question is when B’s acceptance is legally communicated through the electronic system and becomes available to A, having regard to the circumstances.

Acceptance by Conduct

Communication does not always require a separate written or oral statement.

Under Section 8, performance of the conditions of a proposal can constitute acceptance.

Example

A announces:

“₹10,000 will be paid to anyone who returns my lost dog.”

B knows about the offer and returns the dog.

B’s performance may constitute acceptance even though B does not separately communicate:

“I accept.”

The performance itself communicates assent in the manner contemplated by the offer.

Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)

Principle: A general offer can be accepted through performance of the conditions specified in the offer.

Communication Must Be Made in a Legally Recognized Manner

The acceptance should be communicated in the manner contemplated by the offer or in a usual and reasonable manner.

Section 7(2) provides that where the proposal prescribes a particular manner of acceptance, the acceptance should follow that mode, subject to the statutory rules.

Example

A states:

“Please communicate acceptance by email.”

B sends an email accepting the offer.

This follows the prescribed mode.

If B instead sends an unrelated message through another method, the legal consequences depend on the circumstances and conduct of the parties.

Silence and Communication of Acceptance

Silence generally does not amount to acceptance.

An offeror cannot ordinarily create a contract merely by declaring:

“If you do not reply, I will consider the offer accepted.”

Felthouse v. Bindley (1862)

Principle: Silence does not ordinarily constitute acceptance.

However, where acceptance is contemplated through performance or conduct, the relevant conduct may communicate assent.

Communication of Acceptance and Counter Offer

Communication must also clearly indicate what is being accepted.

Example

A offers:

“I will sell the car for ₹6 lakh.”

B replies:

“I will buy it for ₹5.5 lakh.”

This communication is not acceptance.

It is a counter offer because B has changed the price.

For valid acceptance:

Offer: ₹6 lakh

Acceptance: “I accept ₹6 lakh.”

Communication of Acceptance and General Offer

A general offer may be accepted through performance of its conditions.

Example

A publishes:

“₹20,000 reward for anyone who finds and returns my lost laptop.”

B, knowing about the offer, finds and returns the laptop.

B’s performance may constitute acceptance.

The communication takes place through the act contemplated by the offer.

Communication of Acceptance and Specific Offer

A specific offer is normally accepted by the person to whom it is made.

Example

A offers to sell a property to B for ₹30 lakh.

B sends A a message:

“I accept your offer.”

The acceptance has been communicated by B to A.

C cannot ordinarily communicate acceptance of A’s specific offer because C is not the intended offeree.

Important Cases

Adams v. Lindsell (1818)

Principle: The traditional postal rule provides that acceptance by post may become effective when the acceptance is properly posted, rather than only when it reaches the offeror.

The case is the classic foundation of the postal acceptance rule in common-law contract law.

Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)

Principle: Communication through instantaneous methods such as telephone is treated differently from postal communication, and the circumstances of communication determine when acceptance becomes effective.

Felthouse v. Bindley (1862)

Principle: Silence generally does not constitute acceptance.

Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)

Principle: Acceptance of a general offer may occur through performance of the specified conditions.

Communication of Acceptance vs Communication of Offer

Communication of OfferCommunication of Acceptance
Brings the proposal to the offeree’s knowledgeCommunicates assent to the offeror
Initiates the contractual processResponds to an existing offer
Section 2(a) is relevantSection 2(b) is relevant
Section 4 says proposal communication is complete when it comes to the offeree’s knowledgeSection 4 provides special rules for completion of acceptance
Must occur before valid acceptanceMay complete the formation process

Communication of Acceptance vs Revocation

Communication of AcceptanceRevocation
Communicates assentWithdraws an offer or acceptance
Usually made by offereeRevocation of offer is made by offeror
Section 4 determines completionSections 5 and 6 govern revocation
Can result in contract formationPrevents acceptance if effective in time

Important Sections

SectionRelevance
Section 2(b)Definition of acceptance
Section 3Communication of proposal, acceptance and revocation
Section 4When communication becomes complete
Section 5Revocation of proposal and acceptance
Section 6Modes of revocation of proposal
Section 7Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified
Section 8Acceptance by performance
Section 9Express and implied promises

Key Points for Examination

  • Section 3 deals with communication of proposals, acceptances and revocations.
  • Section 4 determines when communication of acceptance is complete.
  • Against the proposer, postal acceptance is generally complete when it is put into transmission and is beyond the acceptor’s control.
  • Against the acceptor, communication is complete when acceptance comes to the knowledge of the proposer.
  • Section 5 permits revocation of acceptance before communication is complete as against the acceptor.
  • The traditional postal rule should be distinguished from instantaneous communication.
  • Telephone and similar instantaneous communications follow different principles.
  • Electronic communications may validly form contracts.
  • Acceptance may sometimes be communicated through performance or conduct under Section 8.
  • Silence generally does not constitute acceptance.
  • Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas is important for instantaneous communication.
  • Adams v. Lindsell is the classic postal-rule case.
  • Felthouse v. Bindley is important regarding silence.
  • Carlill illustrates acceptance by performance of a general offer.

Quick Revision

Section 4 — Acceptance

Against proposer:
Acceptance is complete when it is put into a course of transmission so as to be out of the power of the acceptor.

Against acceptor:
Acceptance is complete when it comes to the knowledge of the proposer.

Simple Example

A → Offer by post → B

B → Accepts and posts acceptance → A

As against A: acceptance is generally complete when B posts it.

As against B: acceptance is complete when it comes to A’s knowledge.

Conclusion

Communication of acceptance is a crucial part of contract formation. Sections 3 and 4 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 establish the principal rules, while Section 5 deals with the revocation of acceptance.

The most important rule is that the law distinguishes between the point at which acceptance becomes complete against the proposer and the point at which it becomes complete against the acceptor.

The traditional postal rule is particularly important:

Against proposer → Acceptance put into transmission

Against acceptor → Acceptance comes to proposer’s knowledge

For telephone, electronic communication and acceptance by conduct, the rules must be applied according to the nature and circumstances of the communication.