Meaning of Agreements to Do Impossible Acts
An agreement to do an impossible act is an agreement in which a person promises to perform an act that cannot be performed in reality or is legally impossible. Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, such agreements are governed primarily by Section 56, which deals with agreements to do impossible acts and the subsequent impossibility or unlawfulness of contractual performance.
- Meaning of Agreements to Do Impossible Acts
- Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
- Types of Impossibility
- Important Case Laws on Agreements to Do Impossible Acts
- Difference Between Initial and Subsequent Impossibility
- Difference Between Impossibility and Frustration
- Legal Consequences of Agreements to Do Impossible Acts
- Key Points for Exams
- Conclusion
The law does not compel a person to perform an act that is inherently impossible. However, the legal consequences depend on whether the impossibility existed when the agreement was made or arose after the contract was formed.
Example: A promises to discover a hidden treasure through supernatural powers. If the promised act is inherently impossible, the agreement is void.
Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
Section 56 deals with three important situations:
- An agreement to do an act impossible in itself.
- A contract that becomes impossible or unlawful to perform after it is made.
- A promisor who knew, or could have known with reasonable diligence, that the promised act was impossible or unlawful, while the promisee did not know.
1. Initial Impossibility
The first paragraph of Section 56 provides that an agreement to do an act impossible in itself is void.
Initial impossibility exists when the promised act cannot be performed from the very beginning. The impossibility may be physical or legal.
Examples:
- A agrees to bring a dead person back to life.
- A promises to create a substance that cannot exist under the applicable laws of nature.
- A agrees to perform an act that is prohibited by law and cannot lawfully be performed.
In these situations, the agreement is void because the promised act cannot be carried out as legally required.
2. Subsequent Impossibility
The second paragraph of Section 56 deals with a contract that was valid when made but subsequently becomes impossible or unlawful to perform due to an event beyond the relevant party’s control.
This principle is commonly known as the doctrine of frustration.
A contract may become frustrated when an unforeseen event fundamentally prevents performance or makes it unlawful. However, mere inconvenience, increased expense or commercial difficulty does not ordinarily make a contract impossible.
Examples:
- A contracts to perform at a particular concert venue, but the venue is destroyed by an accidental fire before the event.
- A agrees to export goods to another country, but a subsequent legal prohibition makes the export unlawful.
- A contracts to provide a hall for a specific event, but the hall is destroyed before the event takes place.
Whether the contract becomes void depends on the facts, the contractual terms and the nature of the supervening event.
3. Knowledge of Impossibility
The third paragraph of Section 56 addresses a situation in which a person promises to perform an act that the promisor knew, or with reasonable diligence might have known, was impossible or unlawful, while the promisee did not know.
In such a situation, the promisor must compensate the promisee for the loss sustained because of the non-performance.
Example: A agrees to arrange a licence for B despite knowing that the licence cannot legally be issued. B, unaware of this fact, incurs expenses in reliance on A’s promise. Depending on the circumstances, Section 56 may require A to compensate B for the resulting loss.
The provision prevents a promisor from escaping responsibility by relying on an impossibility that the promisor knew or should have known about when making the promise.
Types of Impossibility
Physical Impossibility
Physical impossibility arises when an act cannot be performed because of the physical nature of the situation.
Example: A promises to deliver a specific painting, but the painting had already been destroyed before the agreement was made, and the agreement specifically concerns that painting.
The legal result depends on whether the destruction makes the promised performance genuinely impossible and on what the parties knew when contracting.
Legal Impossibility
Legal impossibility arises when the promised act cannot lawfully be performed.
Example: A agrees to supply goods whose sale is subsequently prohibited by a valid law applicable to the contract.
If a subsequent legal change makes performance unlawful, Section 56 may render the contract void from the point performance becomes unlawful.
An agreement whose object or consideration is unlawful from the outset may instead be void under Section 23.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp ChannelCommercial Impracticability and Increased Expense
A contract does not ordinarily become impossible merely because performance becomes more expensive or less profitable.
Example: A agrees to supply materials at a fixed price. Later, the market price of those materials rises sharply. A cannot ordinarily avoid the contract merely because fulfilling it has become less profitable.
The court considers whether the event fundamentally prevents performance or merely makes it more difficult or expensive.
Important Case Laws on Agreements to Do Impossible Acts
Satyabrata Ghose v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co. (1954)
The Supreme Court of India explained the doctrine of frustration under Section 56 and clarified that impossibility is not confined to literal or physical impossibility.
Principle: An event may frustrate a contract when it destroys the fundamental basis of the contractual obligation. The court must assess the nature of the contract and the effect of the intervening event.
Alopi Parshad & Sons Ltd. v. Union of India (1960)
The Supreme Court considered contractual obligations affected by changes in commercial circumstances.
Principle: A contract does not become impossible merely because performance becomes more onerous or expensive. Courts cannot ordinarily rewrite contractual obligations simply because circumstances have become commercially unfavourable.
Energy Watchdog v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (2017)
The Supreme Court considered force majeure and frustration in the context of power-purchase agreements affected by changes in the availability and cost of imported coal.
Principle: Increased cost or commercial hardship does not, by itself, frustrate a contract. The contractual force majeure provisions and the requirements of Section 56 must be examined.
Difference Between Initial and Subsequent Impossibility
| Basis | Initial Impossibility | Subsequent Impossibility |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | The act is impossible when the agreement is made | The act becomes impossible or unlawful after the contract is made |
| Relevant provision | First paragraph of Section 56 | Second paragraph of Section 56 |
| Legal effect | The agreement is void from the outset | The contract becomes void when performance becomes impossible or unlawful |
| Example | A promises to bring a dead person back to life | A contracts to use a hall that is later destroyed by fire |
| Main issue | Whether the promised act was impossible at formation | Whether a later event fundamentally prevents lawful performance |
Difference Between Impossibility and Frustration
Although the concepts are closely related, they describe different stages of contractual performance.
| Basis | Impossibility | Frustration |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Performance cannot be carried out | A valid contract becomes impossible or unlawful to perform because of a subsequent event |
| Timing | May exist from the beginning or arise later | Arises after the contract is formed |
| Legal basis | Section 56 | The doctrine under the second paragraph of Section 56 |
| Example | An agreement to perform an inherently impossible act | A contract frustrated by the destruction of its essential subject matter |
Legal Consequences of Agreements to Do Impossible Acts
The consequences depend on the circumstances:
- Agreement void from the beginning: An agreement to perform an act impossible in itself is void under the first paragraph of Section 56.
- Contract becomes void later: A valid contract may become void when subsequent impossibility or unlawfulness falls within Section 56.
- Compensation for known impossibility: A promisor who knew, or should have known with reasonable diligence, of the impossibility while the promisee did not may be liable to compensate the promisee.
- Restitution may arise separately: Where benefits or payments have already been exchanged, other provisions of the Contract Act may become relevant. Section 65, concerning agreements discovered to be void and contracts that become void, may apply where its requirements are satisfied.
- Contractual force majeure clauses: The parties’ agreed terms may determine how certain events affect performance. Such clauses must be interpreted alongside the applicable law.
Key Points for Exams
- Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, governs agreements to do impossible acts.
- An agreement to perform an act impossible in itself is void.
- Subsequent impossibility or unlawfulness may discharge a previously valid contract.
- The doctrine of frustration is associated with the second paragraph of Section 56.
- Increased expense or commercial hardship alone does not ordinarily frustrate a contract.
- A promisor who knew or should have known of initial impossibility may be liable to compensate an innocent promisee.
- Satyabrata Ghose v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co. (1954) is a leading Indian authority on frustration.
- Alopi Parshad (1960) and Energy Watchdog (2017) explain why commercial hardship alone is insufficient.
Conclusion
Agreements to do impossible acts are governed primarily by Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. The provision distinguishes between acts that are impossible from the beginning and contracts that become impossible or unlawful because of subsequent events.
While the law treats inherently impossible agreements as void, it also provides a framework for dealing with unforeseen events that prevent contractual performance. The central principle is that the law does not require performance of an impossible act, but impossibility must be legally established rather than inferred merely from inconvenience or increased expense.