Meaning of Agreements Opposed to Public Policy
An agreement opposed to public policy is an agreement whose object or consideration conflicts with the public interest, the administration of justice, or fundamental principles recognised by law.
- Meaning of Agreements Opposed to Public Policy
- Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
- Categories of Agreements Opposed to Public Policy
- Important Case Laws on Agreements Opposed to Public Policy
- Legal Effects of Agreements Opposed to Public Policy
- Difference Between Agreements Opposed to Public Policy and Agreements Forbidden by Law
- Difference Between Agreements Opposed to Public Policy and Wagering Agreements
- Key Points for Exams
- Conclusion
Under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the consideration or object of an agreement is unlawful if the court regards it as opposed to public policy. An agreement with an unlawful object or consideration is void.
The doctrine of public policy prevents parties from using contractual freedom to enter into arrangements that undermine justice, encourage corruption or harm the interests of society.
Example: A promises to pay B to bribe a public official to secure a government contract. The agreement is opposed to public policy and is void under Section 23.
Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
Section 23 governs the lawfulness of the consideration and object of an agreement. It identifies six grounds of unlawfulness:
- The consideration or object is forbidden by law.
- It would defeat the provisions of any law if permitted.
- It is fraudulent.
- It involves or implies injury to the person or property of another.
- The court regards it as immoral.
- The court regards it as opposed to public policy.
Public policy is one of the statutory grounds under Section 23. The doctrine must be applied carefully because an overly broad interpretation could create uncertainty in contractual dealings.
An agreement does not become opposed to public policy merely because it appears unfair or undesirable. The court must assess the agreement under the applicable legal principles and the circumstances of the case.
Categories of Agreements Opposed to Public Policy
1. Agreements Interfering with the Administration of Justice
Agreements that improperly obstruct the administration of justice or interfere with judicial proceedings may be opposed to public policy.
Example: A promises to pay B to influence a judge to decide a case in A’s favour.
Such an agreement undermines the independence of the judicial process and cannot ordinarily be enforced.
2. Agreements Involving Corruption or Improper Influence
An agreement intended to secure an official decision through bribery or improper influence may be unlawful under Section 23.
Example: A agrees to pay B for arranging an unlawful payment to a public official in exchange for a government licence.
The agreement is void because its purpose conflicts with the law and public interest.
3. Agreements Intended to Defeat the Law
An agreement designed to circumvent a statutory requirement may be void where permitting it would defeat the provisions of law.
Example: A and B enter into a sham arrangement to conceal the true nature of a transaction and evade a statutory prohibition.
The court examines the substance of the transaction rather than merely the form chosen by the parties.
4. Agreements Involving Fraud on Public Institutions
Agreements intended to deceive courts, public authorities or other institutions may be opposed to public policy and may also violate specific laws.
Example: A agrees to pay B to prepare false documents for submission to a public authority to obtain an unlawful benefit.
Such an arrangement cannot ordinarily be enforced because it is intended to facilitate deception.
5. Agreements Unfairly Exploiting Unequal Bargaining Power
Certain contracts contain oppressive or unconscionable terms imposed on a party who has little meaningful bargaining power.
Courts may examine such terms under public policy principles, particularly where one party has imposed an unfair condition on a substantially weaker party.
Example: An organisation imposes a highly oppressive contractual condition on an individual who has no realistic opportunity to negotiate the terms.
Whether the term is unenforceable depends on the circumstances, the nature of the relationship and the applicable legal principles. Not every unequal bargain is automatically void.
6. Agreements Undermining Public Duties
An agreement may be opposed to public policy where it improperly interferes with the performance of a public duty or seeks to obtain an official benefit through unlawful means.
Example: A promises to pay B for improperly influencing a public officer to disregard a statutory requirement.
The agreement may be void under Section 23 and may also attract other legal consequences depending on the conduct involved.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp ChannelImportant Case Laws on Agreements Opposed to Public Policy
Gherulal Parakh v. Mahadeodas Maiya (1959)
The Supreme Court of India considered the legal status of wagering agreements and their relationship with public policy.
Principle: An agreement that is void under the Indian Contract Act is not automatically illegal in every sense. Its legal consequences must be determined by examining the applicable statutory provisions and principles.
This case is important because it cautions against treating every void agreement as necessarily illegal or opposed to public policy.
Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly (1986)
The Supreme Court examined an unconscionable contractual term in the context of unequal bargaining power.
Principle: A contractual term may be unenforceable where it is unconscionable and opposed to public policy in the relevant circumstances.
The judgment is significant in understanding how public policy can protect parties from certain oppressive contractual terms.
Rattan Chand Hira Chand v. Askar Nawaz Jung (1991)
The Supreme Court considered the scope of Section 23 and the doctrine of public policy.
Principle: The lawfulness of an agreement must be assessed under Section 23 and the applicable legal principles. The doctrine of public policy must be applied judicially rather than on the basis of personal opinions about what is desirable.
Legal Effects of Agreements Opposed to Public Policy
1. The Agreement Is Void
Under Section 23, an agreement whose object or consideration is opposed to public policy is void.
Neither party can ordinarily compel the other to perform the unlawful agreement.
2. Contractual Remedies May Be Unavailable
A party generally cannot seek enforcement of an agreement that is void under Section 23.
Whether money or property already transferred can be recovered depends on the applicable legal rules and circumstances. Restitution is not automatic in every unlawful transaction.
3. Other Legal Consequences May Arise
If the agreement involves bribery, fraud, forgery or another prohibited act, the conduct may also attract consequences under the relevant criminal or statutory law.
The fact that an agreement is void under contract law does not, by itself, determine whether a separate offence has been committed.
Difference Between Agreements Opposed to Public Policy and Agreements Forbidden by Law
Both concepts fall within Section 23, but they are not identical.
| Basis | Forbidden by Law | Opposed to Public Policy |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | The agreement involves conduct expressly prohibited by applicable law | The agreement conflicts with public interests or legal principles recognised under public policy |
| Legal basis | An applicable statutory or legal prohibition | Section 23 and the relevant public policy principles |
| Scope | Depends on the prohibition in question | Requires judicial assessment of the agreement and applicable principles |
| Example | An agreement to perform an act expressly prohibited by statute | An agreement to improperly influence a judicial officer |
| Legal effect | Agreement is void where Section 23 applies | Agreement is void where Section 23 applies |
An agreement may fall within both categories. For example, an agreement to bribe a public official may violate specific laws and also be opposed to public policy.
Difference Between Agreements Opposed to Public Policy and Wagering Agreements
| Basis | Opposed to Public Policy | Wagering Agreement |
|---|---|---|
| Relevant provision | Section 23 | Section 30 |
| Nature | Agreement conflicts with public policy | Agreement involves a wager on an uncertain event |
| Legal effect | Void where Section 23 applies | Void under Section 30, subject to applicable statutory context |
| Scope | Broad legal doctrine within Section 23 | Specific category of agreement |
| Example | Agreement to bribe a public official | Agreement to pay money depending on the outcome of a wager |
A wagering agreement is not automatically opposed to public policy merely because it is void under Section 30. The two provisions must be analysed separately.
Key Points for Exams
- Agreements opposed to public policy are governed primarily by Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
- The object or consideration must conflict with public policy for this ground of invalidity to apply.
- Agreements involving corruption, improper interference with justice or unlawful circumvention of legislation may be void.
- Certain unconscionable contractual terms may be unenforceable in the relevant circumstances.
- Not every unfair agreement is automatically opposed to public policy.
- A void agreement is not necessarily illegal in every sense.
- Gherulal Parakh v. Mahadeodas Maiya (1959) is important for distinguishing void agreements from illegality.
- Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly (1986) is important for unconscionable terms and public policy.
- Rattan Chand Hira Chand v. Askar Nawaz Jung (1991) is relevant to Section 23 and public policy.
Conclusion
Agreements opposed to public policy are restricted under Indian contract law because contractual freedom cannot be used to undermine justice, facilitate corruption or defeat the public interest.
Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, provides the statutory foundation for treating such agreements as void. Courts apply the doctrine carefully, considering the purpose of the agreement, the applicable legal principles and the circumstances of the transaction.
The central principle is that an agreement cannot be enforced when its object or consideration is opposed to public policy within the meaning of Section 23.