The terms agreement and contract are closely related but are not identical under the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Every contract is an agreement, but every agreement does not become a contract.
- Meaning of Agreement
- Meaning of Contract
- Relationship Between Agreement and Contract
- Essential Elements of a Contract
- Essential Elements of an Agreement
- Agreement Is Wider Than Contract
- Contract Is a Legally Enforceable Agreement
- Intention to Create Legal Relations
- Offer and Acceptance
- Consideration
- Lawful Consideration
- Competency of Parties
- Free Consent
- Lawful Object
- Agreements Expressly Declared Void
- Void Agreement and Contract
- Voidable Contract
- Void Contract
- Agreement and Contract: Examples
- Important Cases
- Difference Between Agreement and Contract
- Agreement, Void Agreement and Contract
- Importance of the Distinction
- Agreement and Contract Under Section 10
- Key Points for Examination
- Conclusion
The distinction is fundamental to Contract Law because only those agreements that satisfy the legal requirements prescribed by the Indian Contract Act become legally enforceable contracts.
Meaning of Agreement
Section 2(e) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 defines an agreement as:
“Every promise and every set of promises, forming the consideration for each other, is an agreement.”
The definition can be understood through the relationship between proposal, acceptance, promise and agreement.
Under Section 2(a), a proposal is made when one person signifies to another their willingness to do or abstain from doing something with a view to obtaining the other’s assent.
Under Section 2(b), when the person to whom the proposal is made signifies their assent, the proposal is said to be accepted. A proposal, when accepted, becomes a promise.
Therefore:
Proposal + Acceptance = Promise
And:
Promise + Consideration = Agreement
Meaning of Contract
Section 2(h) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 provides:
“An agreement enforceable by law is a contract.”
Thus, the essential feature of a contract is legal enforceability.
An agreement may exist between two or more persons, but it becomes a contract only when the law recognises it as enforceable.
Therefore:
Agreement + Legal Enforceability = Contract
Relationship Between Agreement and Contract
The relationship can be represented as:
Proposal → Acceptance → Promise → Agreement → Legal Enforceability → Contract
For example, A agrees to sell a laptop to B for ₹40,000 and B agrees to purchase it for that price.
If the agreement satisfies the requirements of the Indian Contract Act, it becomes a contract.
However, if A and B merely agree to meet for dinner, there may be an agreement in the ordinary sense, but there is generally no intention to create legally enforceable obligations.
Essential Elements of a Contract
Section 10 of the Indian Contract Act provides the basic requirements for an agreement to become a contract.
An agreement becomes a contract if it is:
- Made by the free consent of parties competent to contract;
- For a lawful consideration;
- For a lawful object;
- Not expressly declared void; and
- Satisfies any other legal requirements applicable to the particular transaction.
The agreement must therefore satisfy both contractual requirements and applicable statutory requirements.
Essential Elements of an Agreement
For an agreement to arise in the contractual sense, there must generally be:
- Two or more parties;
- A proposal;
- Acceptance of the proposal;
- A promise; and
- Consideration forming the basis of the promises.
However, the existence of an agreement does not by itself establish legal enforceability.
Agreement Is Wider Than Contract
An agreement is a broader concept.
There may be agreements that the law does not enforce as contracts.
Examples include:
- Social agreements;
- Certain domestic arrangements;
- Agreements without consideration, subject to statutory exceptions;
- Agreements with unlawful objects;
- Agreements with persons incompetent to contract;
- Agreements expressly declared void; and
- Certain agreements where legal enforceability is excluded by law.
Thus:
Every contract is an agreement, but every agreement is not a contract.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp ChannelContract Is a Legally Enforceable Agreement
The defining characteristic of a contract is enforceability.
Suppose A promises to sell a bicycle to B for ₹10,000 and B accepts.
If all statutory requirements are satisfied, B may have legal remedies if A wrongfully refuses to perform.
The agreement has therefore become a contract.
If, however, the arrangement falls within a category that the law declares void, it cannot be enforced as a contract.
Intention to Create Legal Relations
The Indian Contract Act does not expressly use the phrase “intention to create legal relations” as a separate statutory requirement.
However, intention can be relevant when determining whether an arrangement is legally enforceable, particularly in cases involving social or domestic arrangements.
The courts generally distinguish between arrangements intended to create legal obligations and ordinary social or family arrangements.
Balfour v. Balfour (1919)
The English case established the principle that ordinary domestic arrangements are generally presumed not to create legally enforceable obligations unless circumstances indicate otherwise.
The case is frequently used to explain the distinction between social arrangements and legally enforceable agreements.
Offer and Acceptance
An agreement ordinarily arises from a proposal followed by acceptance.
Proposal
Under Section 2(a), a proposal is made when a person signifies willingness to do or abstain from doing something with a view to obtaining the assent of another person.
Acceptance
Under Section 2(b), when the person to whom the proposal is made signifies assent, the proposal is accepted.
Acceptance must generally correspond with the terms of the proposal and must satisfy the statutory requirements governing communication and acceptance.
Consideration
Consideration is an important element of an agreement.
Section 2(d) defines consideration as an act, abstinence or promise done or given at the desire of the promisor by the promisee or any other person.
The basic principle is:
“No consideration, no contract.”
However, Section 25 recognises certain exceptions where an agreement without consideration may nevertheless be valid.
Lawful Consideration
Under Section 10, consideration must be lawful.
Section 23 provides that consideration or object is unlawful if:
- It is forbidden by law;
- It defeats the provisions of law;
- It is fraudulent;
- It involves injury to the person or property of another;
- The court regards it as immoral; or
- It is opposed to public policy.
An agreement based on unlawful consideration cannot become an enforceable contract.
Competency of Parties
The parties must be competent to contract.
Section 11 provides that a person is competent to contract if they:
- Have attained the age of majority according to the law applicable to them;
- Are of sound mind; and
- Are not disqualified from contracting by any law to which they are subject.
Therefore, an agreement involving a person who lacks contractual capacity may not have the same legal consequences as an agreement between competent parties.
Free Consent
Section 14 provides that consent is free when it is not caused by:
- Coercion;
- Undue influence;
- Fraud;
- Misrepresentation; or
- Mistake, subject to the statutory provisions relating to mistake.
Free consent is important because contractual obligations should ordinarily arise from genuine agreement between the parties.
Lawful Object
The object of an agreement must be lawful.
An agreement cannot become a valid contract merely because the parties have consented if its object is unlawful under Section 23.
For example, an agreement to pay money for committing an offence cannot be enforced.
Agreements Expressly Declared Void
The Indian Contract Act expressly declares certain agreements void.
Important examples include:
- Agreements in restraint of marriage — Section 26;
- Agreements in restraint of trade — Section 27, subject to recognised exceptions;
- Agreements in restraint of legal proceedings — Section 28, subject to statutory exceptions;
- Agreements void for uncertainty — Section 29;
- Agreements by way of wager — Section 30, subject to applicable legal considerations.
A void agreement does not become an enforceable contract.
Void Agreement and Contract
Section 2(g) provides that an agreement not enforceable by law is said to be void.
Section 2(h), in contrast, defines a contract as an agreement enforceable by law.
Therefore:
Void Agreement → Not enforceable by law
Contract → Enforceable by law
Voidable Contract
A voidable contract is different from a void agreement.
Section 2(i) provides that an agreement which is enforceable by law at the option of one or more parties, but not at the option of the other or others, is a voidable contract.
For example, where consent has been obtained through coercion, fraud or misrepresentation, the affected party may have the statutory right to avoid the contract, subject to the provisions of the Act.
Void Contract
Section 2(j) provides that a contract which ceases to be enforceable by law becomes void when it ceases to be enforceable.
Thus, a contract may initially be valid but subsequently become void because of circumstances recognised by law.
Agreement and Contract: Examples
Example 1: Valid Contract
A offers to sell his car to B for ₹5 lakh.
B accepts the offer.
The parties are competent, consent is free, consideration and object are lawful, and there is no statutory bar.
This is a contract.
Example 2: Social Agreement
A promises to meet B for dinner at 8 p.m.
B agrees.
This may be an ordinary social arrangement rather than a legally enforceable contract.
Example 3: Unlawful Object
A agrees to pay B ₹50,000 to steal goods from C.
Although the parties have reached an agreement, the object is unlawful.
It cannot become an enforceable contract.
Example 4: Minor
A enters into an agreement with a person who is not competent to contract because of minority.
The legal consequences are governed by the rules concerning contractual capacity, and the agreement cannot simply be treated as an ordinary enforceable contract.
Important Cases
Mohori Bibee v. Dharmodas Ghose (1903)
The Privy Council held that a minor’s agreement is void ab initio.
The case is a leading authority on contractual capacity and the effect of an agreement entered into by a minor.
Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)
The English case illustrates the principles of offer and acceptance and demonstrates that an offer can, in appropriate circumstances, be made to the public generally.
It is frequently used to explain the formation of contractual agreements.
Balfour v. Balfour (1919)
The case illustrates the distinction between domestic arrangements and agreements intended to create legal obligations.
Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)
The case is commonly cited for the principle that acceptance requires knowledge of the proposal; a person cannot ordinarily accept an offer of which they were unaware.
It is an important Indian case for understanding offer and acceptance.
Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)
The Supreme Court considered communication of acceptance and the formation of contracts, particularly in the context of instantaneous communications.
The case is important for understanding when and where a contract may be formed through communication between parties.
Chinnaya v. Ramaya (1882)
The case is an important authority for the principle that consideration may move from the promisee or any other person under Section 2(d) of the Indian Contract Act.
Difference Between Agreement and Contract
| Basis | Agreement | Contract |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Every promise or set of promises forming consideration for each other | Agreement enforceable by law |
| Section | Section 2(e) | Section 2(h) |
| Legal enforceability | May or may not be enforceable | Legally enforceable |
| Scope | Wider | Narrower |
| Legal obligation | May not create legal obligation | Creates enforceable legal obligation |
| Requirements | Proposal, acceptance and consideration forming the agreement | Agreement plus requirements of enforceability |
| Example | Certain social arrangements | Valid sale or service agreement satisfying legal requirements |
Agreement, Void Agreement and Contract
| Category | Enforceable? |
|---|---|
| Agreement | Depends upon its nature and legal requirements |
| Void agreement | No |
| Voidable contract | Yes, until avoided by the entitled party |
| Contract | Yes |
| Void contract | No, after it ceases to be enforceable |
Importance of the Distinction
The distinction between agreement and contract is important because it determines whether the parties can seek legal remedies.
If an agreement is a valid contract, a party may, depending upon the circumstances, seek remedies such as:
- Damages;
- Specific performance;
- Injunction;
- Rescission; or
- Other remedies recognised by law.
If the arrangement is not legally enforceable, contractual remedies may not be available.
Agreement and Contract Under Section 10
Section 10 provides the central statutory test for determining when agreements become contracts.
It combines several requirements:
Agreement
↓
Competent Parties
↓
Free Consent
↓
Lawful Consideration
↓
Lawful Object
↓
Not Expressly Void
↓
Compliance with Other Applicable Legal Requirements
↓
Contract
This makes Section 10 one of the most important provisions for understanding the formation of contracts under Indian law.
Key Points for Examination
- Section 2(e) defines an agreement.
- Section 2(h) defines a contract.
- An agreement is broader than a contract.
- Every contract is an agreement, but every agreement is not a contract.
- A contract is an agreement enforceable by law.
- Section 10 provides the principal requirements for enforceability.
- Parties must generally be competent to contract under Section 11.
- Consent must be free under Section 14.
- Consideration and object must be lawful.
- Certain agreements are expressly declared void by the Indian Contract Act.
- Section 2(g) defines a void agreement.
- Section 2(i) defines a voidable contract.
- Section 2(j) defines a void contract.
- Intention to create legal relations is particularly relevant when distinguishing legally enforceable arrangements from ordinary social or domestic arrangements.
- Mohori Bibee v. Dharmodas Ghose is a leading case on minor’s agreements.
- Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt is important for offer and acceptance.
- Chinnaya v. Ramaya is important for consideration.
- Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas is important for communication of acceptance.
Conclusion
An agreement is a broader concept consisting of promises or sets of promises forming consideration for each other, whereas a contract is an agreement that the law recognises as enforceable.
The Indian Contract Act, 1872 establishes the conditions under which an agreement acquires legal enforceability. Competency of parties, free consent, lawful consideration, lawful object and the absence of statutory grounds of invalidity are central to this process.
The simplest formula to remember is:
Agreement + Enforceability = Contract
Therefore, while every contract necessarily begins with an agreement, only those agreements that satisfy the requirements of law become contracts capable of creating enforceable legal obligations.