Actual Performance of a Contract under the Indian Contract Act, 1872

Published: 8 min read

Introduction

Performance of a contract refers to the fulfilment of the obligations undertaken by the parties to an agreement. When the parties perform their respective promises in accordance with the terms of the contract, their contractual obligations are discharged.

Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, performance is one of the principal modes of discharge of a contract. It may take place through actual performance or, in appropriate circumstances, through an offer to perform known as attempted or tendered performance.

Actual performance occurs when a party fulfils the promise or obligation undertaken under the contract. Once the contractual obligations have been properly performed, the parties are generally discharged from those obligations, subject to any remaining obligations under the agreement.

For example, A agrees to sell a laptop to B for ₹40,000. A delivers the laptop to B, and B pays the agreed amount. Both parties have performed their respective promises, and the contract is discharged by actual performance.

Meaning of Actual Performance

Actual performance means the actual fulfilment of a contractual promise by the party responsible for performing it.

It occurs when the promisor does what they have agreed to do, in accordance with the terms and conditions of the contract. Depending on the nature of the agreement, performance may involve delivering goods, paying money, providing services, completing construction or carrying out another contractual obligation.

Actual performance may be complete or may occur in stages, depending on the terms of the contract. Where a contract requires several obligations to be performed at different times, the performance of one obligation does not necessarily discharge all the remaining obligations.

Example of Actual Performance

A agrees to paint B’s house for ₹25,000. A completes the painting work according to the agreed specifications, and B pays ₹25,000.

In this situation, A has actually performed the promise to provide painting services, while B has actually performed the promise to pay the agreed consideration.

The contract is discharged to the extent that the respective obligations have been properly fulfilled.

Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.

Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.

Join WhatsApp Channel

Relevant Statutory Provisions

The provisions of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, particularly Sections 37 to 50, deal with the performance of contracts and related matters.

Section 37: Obligation of Parties to Perform

Section 37 provides that the parties to a contract must either perform or offer to perform their respective promises, unless performance is dispensed with or excused under the provisions of the Act or any other applicable law.

The provision establishes the general rule that contractual promises must be fulfilled.

It also recognises that, in certain circumstances, a party may be excused from performance. For example, the parties may agree to dispense with performance, or a legal provision may excuse performance in the circumstances specified by law.

Section 37 further provides that promises bind the representatives of a promisor in the event of the promisor’s death, unless a contrary intention appears from the contract. This rule does not apply where the contract involves a personal undertaking that cannot appropriately be performed by the representatives.

Section 38: Effect of Refusal to Accept an Offer of Performance

Section 38 deals with a situation in which a promisor makes a valid offer to perform but the promisee refuses to accept it.

Where the offer satisfies the statutory requirements, the promisor is not responsible for non-performance merely because the promisee refuses to accept the offer. The promisor does not thereby lose the rights available under the contract.

This provision primarily concerns attempted or tendered performance rather than actual performance. Nevertheless, it is important for understanding the distinction between the two modes of fulfilling contractual obligations.

Section 40: Person by Whom Promise Is to Be Performed

Section 40 provides that, where the nature of the contract indicates that the promisor must personally perform the promise, the promisor must perform it personally.

Where personal performance is not essential, the promisor may employ a competent person to perform the promise unless the contract or the circumstances require otherwise.

For example, if A engages a particular artist to create an original painting, the artist’s personal skill may be central to the agreement. The artist cannot necessarily substitute another person to perform the obligation.

In contrast, an ordinary obligation to pay money may generally be performed through an authorised representative, subject to the applicable legal requirements.

Section 41: Acceptance of Performance from a Third Person

Section 41 provides that when a promisee accepts performance of a promise from a third person, the promisee cannot afterwards enforce the promise against the original promisor.

For example, A owes B ₹10,000. If C pays the amount on A’s behalf and B accepts the payment as performance of A’s obligation, B cannot subsequently demand the same amount from A.

The provision prevents a promisee from demanding the same performance twice after accepting it from another person.

Essential Elements of Actual Performance

1. Existence of a Valid Contractual Obligation

Actual performance presupposes an obligation that the party is required to fulfil. The obligation may arise from a valid contract and must be interpreted in accordance with its terms.

2. Fulfilment of the Promise

The promisor must carry out the obligation undertaken. Merely expressing an intention to perform does not amount to actual performance.

For example, agreeing to deliver goods is not the same as actually delivering them.

3. Performance in Accordance with Contractual Terms

The performance must comply with the relevant contractual requirements, including the agreed quantity, quality, time, place and manner of performance, wherever applicable.

A failure to comply with material contractual terms may amount to a breach rather than proper performance.

4. Performance by the Appropriate Person

The promise must be performed by the promisor personally where personal performance is required. Otherwise, performance may be undertaken by an authorised or competent person, subject to the contract and applicable law.

5. Completion of the Relevant Obligation

The particular promise must be fulfilled before it can be treated as discharged by actual performance. If the contract contains several independent or continuing obligations, completion of one does not necessarily discharge the others.

Types of Actual Performance

1. Complete Performance

Complete performance occurs when the party fully fulfils the relevant contractual obligation.

For example, A agrees to deliver 100 chairs to B. A delivers all 100 chairs in accordance with the contract, and the corresponding payment is made. The obligations are discharged to the extent of their proper fulfilment.

2. Performance in Stages

Some contracts require performance in instalments or stages.

For example, a contractor agrees to construct a building in three stages, with payments due after each stage. Completion of the first stage amounts to performance of that stage, but the remaining contractual obligations continue until they are fulfilled or otherwise discharged.

The consequences of incomplete or defective performance depend on the terms of the contract and the applicable law.

Actual Performance and Tendered Performance

Actual performance must be distinguished from tendered performance, which involves an offer to perform a contractual obligation.

Section 38 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, addresses the legal consequences of a valid offer of performance that the promisee refuses to accept.

BasisActual performanceTendered performance
MeaningThe contractual promise is actually fulfilledThe promisor offers to fulfil the promise
CompletionThe relevant obligation is performedPerformance is offered but may not be accepted
ExampleA delivers the agreed goods to BA brings the goods for delivery, but B refuses to accept them
Relevant provisionSection 37 and other applicable provisionsSection 38
Legal effectDischarges the obligation to the extent properly performedA valid offer may protect the promisor against liability arising merely from the promisee’s refusal

A valid tender must satisfy the requirements of Section 38. An incomplete or defective offer of performance does not automatically produce the same legal consequences.

The principal effect of actual performance is the discharge of the contractual obligation that has been fulfilled.

Once a party properly performs the promise, the other party generally cannot demand the same performance again. However, performance of one obligation does not necessarily terminate the entire contractual relationship if other obligations remain outstanding.

For example, in a contract involving the supply of goods in monthly instalments, delivery of one month’s supply discharges the obligation relating to that instalment but does not necessarily discharge the obligations for subsequent months.

Where performance is incomplete, delayed or defective, the consequences depend on the contractual terms and the applicable provisions governing breach, damages and other remedies.

Key Points for Exams

  • Actual performance means the actual fulfilment of a contractual promise.
  • Section 37 establishes the general obligation to perform or offer to perform contractual promises.
  • Section 38 addresses a valid offer of performance refused by the promisee.
  • Section 40 determines when the promisor must perform personally.
  • Section 41 deals with acceptance of performance from a third person.
  • Actual performance discharges the relevant obligation to the extent it has been properly fulfilled.
  • Completion of one obligation does not necessarily discharge all remaining obligations under a continuing or instalment-based contract.
  • Actual performance differs from tendered performance because actual performance fulfils the promise, whereas tendered performance involves an offer to fulfil it.

Conclusion

Actual performance is a fundamental mode of discharging contractual obligations under the Indian Contract Act, 1872. It occurs when a party fulfils the promise undertaken in accordance with the contract’s terms and applicable legal requirements.

Sections 37 to 50 establish the general framework governing the performance of contractual promises, including who must perform, the effect of accepting performance from a third person and the consequences of refusing a valid offer of performance.

The essential principle is that contractual obligations must ordinarily be fulfilled as agreed. Proper actual performance discharges the obligation performed, while any remaining obligations continue unless they are otherwise discharged under the contract or applicable law.