Nature of Quasi Contracts Under Contract Law

Published: 7 min read

Meaning of Quasi Contracts

A quasi-contract is an obligation imposed by law to prevent one person from being unjustly enriched at the expense of another. Unlike an ordinary contract, a quasi-contract does not arise from an agreement or mutual consent between the parties. Instead, the law creates an obligation because the circumstances make it unjust for one person to retain a benefit without making the legally required payment or restitution.

Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, quasi-contractual obligations are primarily covered by Sections 68–72, under the heading “Of Certain Relations Resembling Those Created by Contract.”

Example: A mistakenly delivers goods to B that were intended for C. If B knowingly accepts and uses the goods, B may be required to pay for them or restore their value under the applicable legal principles.

Nature and Characteristics of Quasi Contracts

1. Obligation Imposed by Law

The most important feature of a quasi-contract is that the obligation arises by operation of law rather than through an agreement between the parties.

In an ordinary contract, the parties voluntarily undertake obligations. In a quasi-contract, the law imposes an obligation because the circumstances justify restitution or compensation.

Example: A supplies essential goods to a person who is legally incapable of contracting. Under Section 68, A may recover reimbursement from that person’s property if the statutory requirements are satisfied.

2. No Actual Agreement Between the Parties

A quasi-contract does not require an offer, acceptance or consensus between the parties. The parties may never have intended to enter into a contractual relationship.

The expression “quasi-contract” is therefore used to describe a legal obligation resembling a contractual obligation, rather than a genuine agreement under Section 2(e) of the Indian Contract Act.

Example: A pays money to B by mistake, believing that B is legally entitled to receive it. If the payment was made by mistake, A may be entitled to recover it under Section 72.

3. Based on the Principle of Unjust Enrichment

Quasi-contracts are closely connected with the principle of unjust enrichment. A person should not ordinarily retain a benefit obtained at another person’s expense when the law requires the benefit to be returned or its value to be paid.

However, not every benefit received from another person creates a legal obligation. The relevant statutory requirements and circumstances must be established.

Example: A lawfully supplies goods to B in circumstances covered by Section 70, and B enjoys the benefit knowing that the goods were not intended to be supplied gratuitously. B may be required to compensate A.

4. The Remedy Is Generally Restitution or Reasonable Compensation

The purpose of quasi-contractual liability is generally to restore a benefit or compensate the person who provided it, rather than automatically award the full profit expected from a negotiated contract.

The exact remedy depends on the applicable provision.

For example:

  • Section 68 allows reimbursement from the property of a person incapable of contracting for necessaries supplied to that person or someone whom they are legally bound to support.
  • Section 69 provides for reimbursement in specified circumstances where a person pays money that another is legally bound to pay.
  • Section 70 requires compensation or restoration where its conditions are satisfied.
  • Section 72 provides for repayment or return of money or goods delivered by mistake or under coercion.

5. The Obligation Is Independent of Contractual Consent

A person cannot necessarily avoid a quasi-contractual obligation merely by arguing that they never agreed to enter into a contract.

If the legal conditions for the obligation are satisfied, liability may arise even without consent.

Example: A pays B’s legally recoverable liability to a third party under circumstances satisfying Section 69. A may claim reimbursement from B even though B did not enter into a separate reimbursement agreement with A.

6. The Obligation Must Be Legally Recognised

Quasi-contractual liability is not an unrestricted power to award compensation whenever a court considers a result unfair. The claim must fall within a recognised legal principle or statutory provision.

Sections 68–72 identify specific situations in which obligations resembling contractual obligations arise.

Types of Quasi-Contractual Obligations Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872

Sections 68–72 provide the principal statutory categories of quasi-contractual obligations.

SectionNature of obligationExample
Section 68Necessaries supplied to a person incapable of contractingNecessaries supplied to a minor
Section 69Reimbursement of a person paying money another is legally bound to payA person pays another’s legally payable debt to protect their own interest
Section 70Benefit of a non-gratuitous actGoods are lawfully supplied and knowingly enjoyed without an intention to provide them free of charge
Section 71Responsibility of a finder of goodsA person finds and takes possession of another’s lost property
Section 72Money or goods delivered by mistake or under coercionMoney is paid twice due to a payment error

These provisions create legal obligations in specified circumstances, even though the parties may not have entered into an ordinary contract.

Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.

Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.

Join WhatsApp Channel

Important Case Laws

State of West Bengal v. B.K. Mondal & Sons (1962)

The Supreme Court of India considered a claim under Section 70 concerning work performed for the government without a valid contract satisfying the constitutional requirements for government contracts.

Principle: Section 70 may require compensation where a person lawfully does something for another, does not intend to act gratuitously, and the other person enjoys the benefit. A valid formal contract is not always necessary for such a claim.

Mulamchand v. State of Madhya Pradesh (1968)

The Supreme Court considered the consequences of a government transaction that did not comply with the formal requirements of Article 299 of the Constitution.

Principle: Although an invalid government contract cannot be enforced as an ordinary contract, restitutionary relief may be available under Section 70 if its statutory requirements are satisfied.

Sales Tax Officer v. Kanhaiya Lal Mukundlal Saraf (1959)

The Supreme Court considered the recovery of money paid under a mistake of law.

Principle: Section 72 can apply to money paid under a mistake of law as well as a mistake of fact, subject to the applicable legal requirements.

Difference Between Quasi Contracts and Ordinary Contracts

BasisQuasi ContractOrdinary Contract
FormationObligation arises by lawArises from an agreement satisfying legal requirements
ConsentNo mutual contractual consent is necessaryConsent is generally essential
Legal basisSections 68–72 and related restitutionary principlesGeneral contract law
Main purposePrevent unjust enrichment or provide statutory reimbursementEnforce voluntarily undertaken obligations
Nature of remedyGenerally restitution or reasonable compensationContractual remedies, including damages where appropriate
ExampleRecovery of money paid by mistakePayment under an agreed sale contract

Difference Between Quasi Contracts and Implied Contracts

Quasi contracts should not be confused with implied contracts.

An implied contract arises from the conduct of the parties or circumstances demonstrating an agreement, even though the agreement was not expressed in words. Section 9 of the Indian Contract Act recognises implied promises.

A quasi-contractual obligation, by contrast, is imposed by law without requiring the parties to have agreed to the obligation.

For example, a customer who orders food and eats it may be required to pay under an implied contractual arrangement. A person who receives money by mistake may be required to return it under Section 72, even though no agreement to repay was made.

Key Points for Exams

  • Quasi contracts are obligations imposed by law, not agreements formed through mutual consent.
  • Their principal purpose is to prevent unjust enrichment and provide restitution where legally required.
  • Sections 68–72 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, govern the principal quasi-contractual obligations.
  • Quasi contracts are also described as obligations arising from certain relations resembling those created by contract.
  • Section 70 is important where a lawful, non-gratuitous act benefits another person.
  • Section 72 covers money or goods delivered by mistake or under coercion.
  • State of West Bengal v. B.K. Mondal & Sons (1962) is a leading authority on Section 70.
  • Sales Tax Officer v. Kanhaiya Lal Mukundlal Saraf (1959) is important for Section 72.
  • A quasi contract differs from an implied contract because the former does not depend on establishing an agreement between the parties.

Conclusion

The nature of quasi contracts lies in the creation of legal obligations without an actual contractual agreement. Under Sections 68–72 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the law provides for reimbursement, restitution or compensation in specified circumstances where allowing a person to retain a benefit without the legally required payment would be unjust.

Quasi contracts demonstrate that contractual-looking obligations may arise not only from consent but also from the law’s requirement to prevent unjust enrichment and ensure fairness in recognised situations.