Meaning of Unlawful Consideration
Under Indian contract law, consideration refers to something of value given, done, or promised in return for a promise. It may involve an act, abstinence or a promise made at the desire of the promisor.
- Meaning of Unlawful Consideration
- Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
- Grounds of Unlawful Consideration
- Difference Between Unlawful Consideration and Unlawful Object
- Unlawful Consideration vs Inadequate Consideration
- Legal Effects of Unlawful Consideration
- Important Case Laws
- Key Points for Exams
- Conclusion
Unlawful consideration refers to consideration that is prohibited by law or falls within the categories specified under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
Section 23 provides that the consideration or object of an agreement is unlawful if it is forbidden by law, would defeat the provisions of any law, is fraudulent, involves injury to another person or property, is immoral, or is opposed to public policy.
An agreement with unlawful consideration is void.
Example
A promises to pay B ₹50,000 to bribe a public official to secure a government contract.
The proposed payment is unlawful because it is intended to facilitate bribery. The agreement is void under Section 23.
Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
Section 23 governs the lawfulness of consideration and the object of an agreement.
The section identifies six grounds on which consideration or an object may be unlawful:
- It is forbidden by law.
- It would defeat the provisions of any law if permitted.
- It is fraudulent.
- It involves or implies injury to the person or property of another.
- The court regards it as immoral.
- The court regards it as opposed to public policy.
The provision applies to both consideration and the object of an agreement. Therefore, even where the promised exchange appears lawful on its face, the agreement may be void if its underlying purpose falls within one of these categories.
Grounds of Unlawful Consideration
1. Consideration Forbidden by Law
Consideration is unlawful when it involves something expressly prohibited by a law in force.
An agreement cannot be enforced when the promised exchange itself requires the parties to undertake an illegal act.
Example: A agrees to pay B to sell prohibited drugs in violation of applicable law.
The consideration is unlawful, and the agreement is void.
2. Consideration That Defeats the Provisions of Law
An agreement may be unlawful even when its terms do not expressly require an illegal act. If permitting the agreement would defeat the purpose or provisions of an applicable law, Section 23 may apply.
Example: A and B enter into an arrangement designed to circumvent a statutory restriction on the transfer of certain property.
If the arrangement defeats the relevant legal provision, the agreement may be void.
3. Fraudulent Consideration
Consideration is unlawful when it is connected with a fraudulent purpose.
The law does not permit parties to enforce agreements intended to facilitate deception or fraud against another person.
Example: A promises to pay B for preparing false documents to deceive a bank into approving a loan.
The consideration is unlawful because the arrangement is intended to facilitate fraud.
4. Consideration Involving Injury to a Person or Property
Under Section 23, consideration is unlawful when it involves or implies injury to the person or property of another.
The injury may relate to physical harm or unlawful interference with property.
Example: A promises to pay B to damage C’s vehicle.
The agreement is void because its consideration involves injury to another person’s property.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp Channel5. Consideration Regarded as Immoral by the Court
An agreement may be void where its consideration or purpose is regarded by the court as immoral within the meaning of Section 23.
Whether an agreement falls within this category depends on the relevant legal principles and circumstances.
Example: An agreement whose consideration involves an arrangement treated by law as immoral may be unenforceable under Section 23.
Not every transaction involving a personal or socially controversial matter automatically falls within this category; the applicable law must be examined.
6. Consideration Opposed to Public Policy
An agreement is unlawful when its consideration or object is opposed to public policy.
Public policy protects the public interest and the proper administration of justice. Courts apply this ground carefully because an excessively broad interpretation could create uncertainty in contractual dealings.
Example: A promises to pay B for improperly influencing a judicial officer to secure a favourable decision.
Such an agreement undermines the administration of justice and is opposed to public policy.
Difference Between Unlawful Consideration and Unlawful Object
Although Section 23 addresses both consideration and object, the two concepts are distinct.
| Basis | Unlawful Consideration | Unlawful Object |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | The act, abstinence or promise given in exchange is unlawful | The purpose sought to be achieved through the agreement is unlawful |
| Focus | The promised exchange | The objective or purpose of the agreement |
| Example | Paying someone to commit an illegal act | Entering into an agreement to achieve a prohibited purpose |
| Relevant provision | Section 23 | Section 23 |
| Legal effect | Agreement is void | Agreement is void |
In practice, unlawful consideration and unlawful object may overlap. An agreement may be void because its promised exchange is unlawful, its purpose is unlawful, or both.
Unlawful Consideration vs Inadequate Consideration
Unlawful consideration must also be distinguished from inadequate consideration.
Unlawful consideration violates Section 23, whereas inadequate consideration means that the value exchanged by the parties is unequal.
Section 25, Explanation 2, clarifies that an agreement is not void merely because its consideration is inadequate. However, inadequacy may be considered by the court when determining whether the consent of a party was freely given.
Example
A sells a watch worth ₹20,000 to B for ₹5,000.
The low price does not automatically make the consideration unlawful or render the agreement void. The circumstances may, however, raise questions about free consent if there is evidence of coercion, fraud or undue influence.
Legal Effects of Unlawful Consideration
1. The Agreement Is Void
Under Section 23, an agreement whose consideration or object is unlawful is void.
It cannot ordinarily be enforced by either party as a valid contractual obligation.
2. Contractual Remedies May Be Unavailable
A party generally cannot ask a court to enforce an agreement that is unlawful under Section 23.
The availability of restitution or recovery of property already transferred requires separate analysis and may depend on the applicable law and circumstances.
3. Related Agreements May Also Be Affected
Section 24 provides that where a single consideration or object is partly unlawful, the agreement is void if the unlawful part cannot be separated from the lawful part.
This provision prevents parties from enforcing an indivisible agreement when part of its consideration or object is unlawful.
Important Case Laws
Gherulal Parakh v. Mahadeodas Maiya (1959)
The Supreme Court of India examined wagering agreements and the relationship between wagering transactions and public policy.
Principle: An agreement being void under the Contract Act does not automatically mean that it is illegal in every sense. The legal effect depends on the relevant statutory provisions and applicable principles.
This case is useful when distinguishing void agreements from agreements that are illegal or opposed to public policy.
Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly (1986)
The Supreme Court considered an unconscionable contractual term imposed in circumstances involving unequal bargaining power.
Principle: Certain unfair and unconscionable contractual terms may be opposed to public policy and unenforceable in the relevant circumstances.
The case illustrates the importance of public policy in evaluating contractual arrangements, although it is not limited to unlawful consideration.
Key Points for Exams
- Unlawful consideration is governed primarily by Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
- Consideration is unlawful if it falls within any of the six statutory grounds.
- An agreement with unlawful consideration or an unlawful object is void.
- Section 24 deals with agreements involving partly unlawful consideration or objects.
- Unlawful consideration is different from inadequate consideration.
- Section 25, Explanation 2, provides that inadequacy alone does not make an agreement void.
- Gherulal Parakh v. Mahadeodas Maiya (1959) is important for understanding wagering agreements and public policy.
- Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly (1986) is relevant to unconscionable terms and public policy.
Conclusion
Unlawful consideration is an important principle under Indian contract law because contractual freedom cannot be used to enforce transactions that violate the law or undermine public interest.
Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, identifies the circumstances in which consideration or the object of an agreement becomes unlawful. Where these requirements are satisfied, the agreement is void and generally cannot be enforced.
The central principle is that consideration must be lawful for an agreement to be enforceable, and an unlawful purpose cannot be legitimised merely because the parties have agreed to it.