Undue Influence vs Fraud Under Contract Law

Published: 6 min read

Meaning of Undue Influence Under Contract Law

Undue influence is defined under Section 16 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. It occurs when the relationship between parties is such that one party is in a position to dominate the will of the other and uses that position to obtain an unfair advantage.

Undue influence generally involves the abuse of a position of authority, trust, dependence or influence. However, the existence of a special relationship alone does not automatically establish undue influence.

Example: An elderly person depends on a trusted adviser to manage their financial affairs. The adviser exploits this position to persuade the person to transfer valuable property on highly unfair terms.

If the requirements of Section 16 are established, the contract may be voidable under Section 19A.

Meaning of Fraud Under Contract Law

Fraud is defined under Section 17 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. It involves conduct intended to deceive another party or induce them to enter into a contract, including knowingly making a false statement, actively concealing a fact, or making a promise without intending to perform it.

Fraud focuses on deceptive conduct rather than the abuse of a position of dominance.

Example: A sells a car to B and knowingly conceals serious engine damage to induce B to purchase it.

If B’s consent was caused by the fraud, the contract is generally voidable under Section 19, subject to the statutory qualifications.

Difference Between Undue Influence and Fraud

The principal difference is that undue influence involves dominating another person’s will and using that position to obtain an unfair advantage, whereas fraud involves deception or other conduct covered by Section 17.

BasisUndue InfluenceFraud
Relevant provisionSection 16Section 17
MeaningAbuse of a position to dominate another’s will and obtain an unfair advantageDeceptive conduct specified under the Act
Main focusRelationship, dominance and unfair advantageDeception and fraudulent conduct
Special relationshipA position to dominate the other party’s will is essentialA special relationship is not necessary
Intention to deceiveNot essentialFraud involves the intention to deceive or conduct otherwise covered by Section 17
MethodMay involve exploiting trust, authority or dependenceMay involve false statements, active concealment or promises made without intention to perform
Burden of proofSection 16(3) may shift the burden in specified circumstances involving an unconscionable transactionThe party alleging fraud generally must establish the relevant fraudulent conduct
Effect on consentConsent is affected through undue influenceConsent is affected through fraud
Relevant remedy provisionSection 19ASection 19
Legal effectContract is voidable at the option of the affected partyContract is generally voidable at the option of the affected party, subject to statutory qualifications

Essentials of Undue Influence

To establish undue influence under Section 16, the following elements are important:

  1. Position to dominate the will: One party must be in a position to dominate the will of the other.
  2. Use of that position: The dominant position must be used to influence the transaction.
  3. Unfair advantage: The influence must be used to obtain an unfair advantage.

The Act identifies circumstances involving real or apparent authority, fiduciary relationships, and certain situations in which a person’s mental capacity is affected by age, illness or distress.

Case Law: Raghunath Prasad v. Sarju Prasad (1924)

This is an important Indian case on undue influence.

Principle: The court examines whether one party was in a position to dominate the will of the other, whether that position was used, and whether the transaction resulted in an unfair advantage.

The case demonstrates that undue influence must be established through the relevant legal requirements rather than inferred merely from the existence of a relationship.

Essentials of Fraud

Section 17 recognises several forms of fraudulent conduct:

  1. False assertion: Suggesting as a fact something that is not true when the person does not believe it to be true.
  2. Active concealment: Hiding a fact by a person who knows or believes it to exist.
  3. Promise without intention to perform: Making a promise without intending to fulfil it.
  4. Deceptive conduct: Performing another act fitted to deceive.
  5. Fraudulent acts or omissions: Conduct specifically declared fraudulent by law.

Fraud may occur between strangers, business partners, family members or parties in a fiduciary relationship. A special relationship is not a necessary element.

Case Law: Derry v. Peek (1889)

This English case is a leading authority on fraudulent misrepresentation.

Principle: Fraudulent misrepresentation involves a false statement made knowingly, without belief in its truth, or recklessly without caring whether it is true or false.

The case is useful for distinguishing deliberate deception from an honest but incorrect statement.

Undue Influence vs Fraud: Practical Examples

Example 1: Undue Influence

A dependent client trusts a financial adviser to manage their affairs. The adviser exploits this position to secure a transfer of the client’s property on highly unfair terms.

Legal position: The transaction may amount to undue influence if the requirements of Section 16 are established.

Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.

Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.

Join WhatsApp Channel

Example 2: Fraud

A sells a car to B and knowingly lies about serious accident damage to induce B to purchase it.

Legal position: The conduct may amount to fraud under Section 17 if the statutory requirements are satisfied.

Example 3: Both May Be Relevant

A trusted adviser uses their position of dominance over a client and deliberately lies about the legal consequences of transferring property to obtain that transfer.

Legal position: Depending on the evidence, the conduct may raise issues of both undue influence and fraud. The requirements of each provision must be assessed separately.

Remedy for Undue Influence: Section 19A

A contract induced by undue influence is voidable at the option of the affected party.

The court may set aside the contract absolutely or set it aside on terms and conditions it considers just.

Remedy for Fraud: Section 19

A contract induced by fraud is generally voidable at the option of the party whose consent was caused by the fraud.

Section 19 contains statutory qualifications, including a rule concerning the ability to discover the truth with ordinary diligence in cases involving misrepresentation or fraudulent silence. Its application depends on the precise circumstances.

The availability of rescission, restitution or damages must be assessed according to the applicable legal provisions and facts.

Key Points for Exams

  • Undue influence is defined under Section 16 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
  • Fraud is defined under Section 17.
  • Undue influence requires a position to dominate another’s will and the use of that position to obtain an unfair advantage.
  • Fraud involves deceptive conduct covered by Section 17.
  • A special relationship is not necessary to establish fraud.
  • Section 16(3) provides for a shift in the burden of proof in specified circumstances involving unconscionable transactions.
  • Section 19A deals with contracts induced by undue influence.
  • Section 19 deals with contracts induced by fraud.
  • Raghunath Prasad v. Sarju Prasad (1924) is important for undue influence.
  • Derry v. Peek (1889) is a leading case on fraudulent misrepresentation.

Conclusion

Undue influence and fraud are distinct grounds affecting free consent under Indian contract law. Undue influence focuses on the abuse of a position that enables one party to dominate another’s will, while fraud focuses on deception or other fraudulent conduct recognised by Section 17.

Although both may make a contract voidable, the legal requirements and applicable remedies differ.

The central distinction is that undue influence concerns the abuse of dominance to obtain an unfair advantage, whereas fraud concerns deceptive conduct that induces contractual consent.