Acceptance is the assent given by the person to whom an offer is made, indicating agreement to the terms of the offer. Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a proposal becomes a promise when it is accepted.
- Meaning of Acceptance
- Who Can Accept an Offer?
- Essentials of a Valid Acceptance
- 2. Acceptance Must Be Communicated
- 3. Acceptance Must Be Made in the Prescribed Manner
- 4. Acceptance Must Be Within the Prescribed or Reasonable Time
- 5. Acceptance Must Be Made Before Revocation or Lapse
- 6. Acceptance Must Be Made With Knowledge of the Offer
- 7. Acceptance Must Correspond With the Offer
- 8. Acceptance May Be Express or Implied
- 9. Acceptance May Be by Performance
- Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)
- 10. Acceptance Must Be Made by the Appropriate Person
- 11. Silence Generally Does Not Amount to Acceptance
- 12. Acceptance Must Be Within the Scope of the Offer
- Communication of Acceptance
- Postal Acceptance
- Acceptance Through Instantaneous Communication
- Acceptance Through Electronic Communication
- Acceptance of General Offer
- Acceptance of Specific Offer
- Acceptance and Counter Offer
- Acceptance and Invitation to Offer
- Important Sections
- Important Cases
- Acceptance vs Counter Offer
- Acceptance vs Mere Inquiry
- Acceptance vs Invitation to Offer
- Key Points for Examination
- Quick Revision
- Conclusion
Acceptance is one of the most important stages in the formation of a contract because an offer by itself does not create a contract.
The basic sequence is:
Offer → Acceptance → Promise → Agreement → Contract, if legally enforceable
Meaning of Acceptance
Section 2(b) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 provides that when the person to whom the proposal is made signifies his assent thereto, the proposal is said to be accepted. A proposal, when accepted, becomes a promise.
Thus:
Acceptance = Final and unconditional assent to an offer
Example
A offers to sell his laptop to B for ₹50,000.
B says:
“I accept your offer.”
B has accepted the offer.
If all other legal requirements are satisfied, the accepted proposal becomes a promise and may form part of a binding contract.
Who Can Accept an Offer?
The person to whom the offer is made is generally entitled to accept it.
In the case of a specific offer, acceptance must ordinarily come from the specified offeree.
In the case of a general offer, acceptance may be made by any person who has knowledge of the offer and fulfills its conditions.
Example
A offers ₹10,000 to anyone who finds and returns his lost dog.
B, knowing about the offer, finds and returns the dog.
B may accept the general offer by performing its conditions.
Essentials of a Valid Acceptance
1. Acceptance Must Be Absolute and Unqualified
Section 7(1) provides that to convert a proposal into a promise, acceptance must be absolute and unqualified.
The offeree must accept the offer as it stands.
Example
A offers to sell a car for ₹6 lakh.
B says:
“I accept, provided you reduce the price to ₹5.5 lakh.”
This is not acceptance. It is a counter offer.
The rule is:
Offer + Change in Terms = Counter Offer
Offer + Absolute Acceptance = Acceptance
Hyde v. Wrench (1840)
Principle: A counter offer generally terminates the original offer and cannot ordinarily be treated as acceptance of it.
2. Acceptance Must Be Communicated
Acceptance generally has to be communicated to the offeror in accordance with law.
A person cannot ordinarily accept an offer merely by privately deciding:
“I agree.”
The acceptance must be expressed or conveyed in a legally recognized manner.
Example
A offers to sell his car to B.
B privately decides to purchase the car but does not communicate his acceptance to A.
Ordinarily, there is no communicated acceptance.
However, where the offer invites acceptance through performance, communication through the prescribed performance may be sufficient.
3. Acceptance Must Be Made in the Prescribed Manner
Under Section 7(2), acceptance must be expressed in a usual and reasonable manner unless the proposal prescribes a particular manner of acceptance.
Example
A says:
“Send your acceptance by email.”
B sends an email accepting the offer.
The prescribed method has been followed.
If the offeree uses a different method, the legal consequences depend upon the circumstances and the offeror’s conduct. The deviation does not automatically produce the same result in every case.
4. Acceptance Must Be Within the Prescribed or Reasonable Time
Acceptance must take place within the time fixed by the offeror or, where no time is fixed, within a reasonable time.
Example
A offers to sell a machine to B and states that the offer remains open until 10 October.
B attempts to accept on 15 October.
If the offer has already lapsed, B cannot ordinarily accept the old offer.
5. Acceptance Must Be Made Before Revocation or Lapse
An offer must still be open when acceptance occurs.
If the offer has been:
- revoked;
- rejected;
- terminated by a counter offer;
- allowed to lapse; or
- otherwise brought to an end,
there is ordinarily no offer left to accept.
Example
A offers to sell a car to B.
Before B accepts, A validly revokes the offer.
B’s later attempt to accept the original offer will generally be ineffective.
6. Acceptance Must Be Made With Knowledge of the Offer
A person cannot ordinarily accept an offer of which they are unaware.
This is especially important in general offers.
Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)
Principle
The plaintiff performed the act for which a reward was later announced, but he did not know about the reward when performing the act.
The court held that he could not claim the reward.
Principle: Knowledge of the offer is necessary for valid acceptance.
7. Acceptance Must Correspond With the Offer
Acceptance must correspond with the terms of the offer.
If the offeree introduces a new condition, changes the price, alters the quantity, or otherwise modifies the offer, the response may become a counter offer rather than an acceptance.
Example
A:
“I offer to sell 100 books for ₹20,000.”
B:
“I accept your offer for 80 books at ₹16,000.”
B has not accepted the original offer. The terms have been changed.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp Channel8. Acceptance May Be Express or Implied
Section 9 recognizes express and implied promises.
Acceptance may therefore be expressed through words or inferred from conduct where the circumstances justify it.
Express Acceptance
Acceptance is made through spoken or written words.
Example:
“I accept your offer.”
Implied Acceptance
Acceptance is inferred from conduct.
Example:
A offers a service under circumstances where the service is normally accepted through performance, and B proceeds in accordance with the terms.
Conduct may therefore demonstrate assent where the legal requirements are satisfied.
9. Acceptance May Be by Performance
Section 8 provides that performance of the conditions of a proposal, or acceptance of consideration offered with a proposal, constitutes acceptance in certain circumstances.
Example
A announces:
“₹5,000 reward to anyone who finds and returns my lost dog.”
B, knowing about the offer, finds and returns the dog.
B’s performance of the condition can amount to acceptance.
This is particularly important in general offers.
Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)
Principle
The advertisement promised a reward to anyone who fulfilled specified conditions. The court treated the advertisement as a general offer, and performance of the specified conditions constituted acceptance.
The case demonstrates that:
General offer + knowledge + performance of conditions = acceptance
10. Acceptance Must Be Made by the Appropriate Person
A specific offer cannot ordinarily be accepted by a person to whom it was not addressed.
Example
A offers to sell a house specifically to B.
C cannot ordinarily accept A’s offer merely because C knows about it.
This principle is particularly important in distinguishing specific offers from general offers.
11. Silence Generally Does Not Amount to Acceptance
The offeror cannot ordinarily impose a contract merely by stating:
“If I do not hear from you, I will consider the offer accepted.”
Acceptance generally requires an indication of assent in accordance with law.
Felthouse v. Bindley (1862)
Principle: Silence generally does not constitute acceptance.
However, the actual conduct and circumstances of a transaction must be considered, particularly where acceptance by conduct or performance is contemplated.
12. Acceptance Must Be Within the Scope of the Offer
The offeree cannot accept only part of an offer in a manner that changes its terms and then claim that a contract has been formed.
Example
A offers to sell:
“100 chairs for ₹1 lakh.”
B replies:
“I accept 50 chairs for ₹50,000.”
This is not necessarily acceptance of A’s offer. It may constitute a new proposal.
Communication of Acceptance
Communication of acceptance is governed particularly by Sections 3 and 4.
Section 4 establishes when communication of acceptance becomes complete.
For postal communication, the law distinguishes between when acceptance becomes complete:
- as against the proposer, and
- as against the acceptor.
This distinction is important in determining when a contract is formed and whether revocation remains possible.
Postal Acceptance
The traditional postal rule under Section 4 provides that communication of acceptance is complete:
As against the proposer:
When the acceptance is put into a course of transmission to the proposer so as to be out of the power of the acceptor.
As against the acceptor:
When the acceptance comes to the knowledge of the proposer.
Example
A posts an offer to B.
B receives the offer and posts acceptance.
Once B properly posts the acceptance, communication is generally complete as against A.
The rules concerning revocation must then be considered separately.
Acceptance Through Instantaneous Communication
Modern forms of communication such as telephone and electronic communication raise different questions regarding when acceptance is communicated.
Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)
Principle
The Supreme Court considered communication of acceptance through instantaneous communication and emphasized the importance of the place and manner in which acceptance is communicated.
The case is important for understanding the difference between traditional postal communication and instantaneous modes of communication.
Acceptance Through Electronic Communication
Acceptance may occur through:
- Electronic purchase orders
- Online platforms
- Digital messages
- Other electronic communications
Example
A sends B an email offering 1,000 units at ₹500 each.
B replies:
“We accept the offer on the stated terms.”
This may constitute acceptance if the communication satisfies the requirements of contract law.
The Information Technology Act, 2000, particularly Section 10A, recognizes the validity of contracts formed through electronic means, subject to applicable legal requirements.
Acceptance of General Offer
A general offer can be accepted by performing the conditions of the offer, provided the person has knowledge of the offer.
Example
A offers ₹20,000 to anyone who returns his lost laptop.
B reads the announcement and returns the laptop.
B’s performance can amount to acceptance.
There is no requirement that B must first send a separate message saying:
“I accept your offer.”
Where the offer itself invites acceptance through performance, performance may constitute acceptance.
Acceptance of Specific Offer
A specific offer is ordinarily accepted by the person to whom it is made.
Example
A offers to sell a car to B for ₹5 lakh.
B accepts the offer.
C cannot ordinarily accept A’s specific offer.
Acceptance and Counter Offer
The distinction is extremely important.
Acceptance
A:
“I will sell my car for ₹6 lakh.”
B:
“I accept your offer for ₹6 lakh.”
This is acceptance.
Counter Offer
A:
“I will sell my car for ₹6 lakh.”
B:
“I will buy it for ₹5.5 lakh.”
This is a counter offer.
Therefore:
Acceptance = Agreement to original terms
Counter offer = Proposal of new terms
Acceptance and Invitation to Offer
An invitation to offer is not itself an offer.
For example:
A shop displays a phone for ₹50,000.
B says:
“I will buy this phone for ₹50,000.”
B’s statement may constitute the offer, which the seller may accept.
Thus, merely responding to an invitation to offer does not automatically mean that a contract has been formed.
Important Sections
| Section | Relevance |
|---|---|
| Section 2(b) | Defines acceptance and promise |
| Section 3 | Communication of proposals, acceptances and revocations |
| Section 4 | Completion of communication |
| Section 5 | Revocation of proposal and acceptance |
| Section 7 | Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified |
| Section 8 | Acceptance by performance |
| Section 9 | Express and implied promises |
Important Cases
Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)
Principle: Knowledge of the offer is necessary for valid acceptance.
Hyde v. Wrench (1840)
Principle: A counter offer is not acceptance and generally terminates the original offer.
Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)
Principle: A general offer may be accepted through performance of its conditions.
Felthouse v. Bindley (1862)
Principle: Silence generally does not constitute acceptance.
Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)
Principle: Communication of acceptance through instantaneous communication must be considered according to the nature of that communication.
Acceptance vs Counter Offer
| Acceptance | Counter Offer |
|---|---|
| Assents to the original offer | Changes or qualifies the original offer |
| Absolute and unqualified | Conditional or modified |
| May result in a contract | Creates a new offer |
| Section 7 | Principle derived from Section 7 |
| Example: “I accept ₹5 lakh” | “I accept ₹4.5 lakh” |
Acceptance vs Mere Inquiry
| Acceptance | Mere Inquiry |
|---|---|
| Shows final assent | Merely seeks information |
| Can result in contract | Does not ordinarily create a contract |
| “I accept your offer” | “Would you accept a lower price?” |
| Final decision | No final commitment |
Acceptance vs Invitation to Offer
| Acceptance | Invitation to Offer |
|---|---|
| Assent to an existing offer | Invites people to make offers |
| Comes after an offer | Usually precedes an offer |
| May create a contract | Does not itself create a contract |
| Governed by offer-and-acceptance rules | Preliminary stage of transaction |
Key Points for Examination
- Section 2(b) defines acceptance.
- A proposal becomes a promise when accepted.
- Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified under Section 7.
- Acceptance must ordinarily be communicated to the offeror.
- Acceptance must be made within the prescribed or reasonable time.
- Acceptance must occur before the offer is revoked or lapses.
- Acceptance must correspond with the terms of the offer.
- A counter offer is not acceptance.
- Silence generally does not amount to acceptance.
- Acceptance may be express or implied.
- Section 8 recognizes acceptance through performance.
- A general offer may be accepted by performing its conditions.
- Knowledge of the offer is necessary for valid acceptance.
- Sections 2(b), 3, 4, 5, 7, 8 and 9 are particularly important.
- Lalman Shukla, Hyde v. Wrench, Carlill, and Felthouse v. Bindley are important cases.
Quick Revision
Essentials of Valid Acceptance
1. Must be absolute and unqualified
2. Must be communicated
3. Must be made by the proper person
4. Must be within the prescribed or reasonable time
5. Must be made before revocation or lapse
6. Must correspond with the offer
7. Must be made with knowledge of the offer
8. May be express or implied
9. May occur through performance where permitted
Easy Formula
Offer + Absolute & Unqualified Assent = Acceptance
Acceptance + Other Legal Requirements = Contract
Conclusion
Acceptance is the final and unconditional assent to an offer. Under Section 2(b) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, an accepted proposal becomes a promise. For acceptance to be legally effective, it must generally be absolute and unqualified, properly communicated, made within the applicable time, and made before the offer has been revoked or has lapsed.
The most important rule to remember is:
An acceptance must correspond with the offer and must not introduce new terms.
Where the offeree changes the terms, the response is generally a counter offer, not acceptance.