Lapse of Offer

Published: 8 min read

Lapse of offer means the termination of an offer due to the occurrence of a circumstance that causes the offer to cease to be open for acceptance. Once an offer has lapsed, the offeree can no longer validly accept it unless the offeror makes a fresh offer.

The Indian Contract Act, 1872 does not separately define the expression “lapse of offer,” but Section 6 specifically provides circumstances in which a proposal is revoked or comes to an end.

The basic principle is:

Offer → Lapse → No valid acceptance

Meaning of Lapse of Offer

An offer is not necessarily open indefinitely. It may come to an end because:

  • the specified time for acceptance expires;
  • a reasonable time expires;
  • the offeree fails to fulfill a condition precedent;
  • the offeror dies or becomes insane and the relevant fact becomes known before acceptance;
  • the offer is rejected or a counter offer is made;
  • the offer is revoked in accordance with law; or
  • the subject matter or circumstances make the offer incapable of acceptance.

Once the offer has lapsed, it cannot ordinarily be accepted without a fresh offer.

Lapse by Expiry of Specified Time

Under Section 6(2), a proposal is revoked by the lapse of the time prescribed in the proposal for its acceptance.

Example

A offers to sell his car to B for ₹5 lakh and states:

“This offer will remain open until 10 October.”

If B does not accept by 10 October within the prescribed period, the offer lapses.

B cannot ordinarily accept the old offer on 11 October.

If A still wishes to sell the car, A must make a fresh offer or otherwise renew the original offer.

Lapse by Expiry of Reasonable Time

Even where the offeror does not specify a particular period, an offer cannot remain open forever.

An offer may lapse after the expiry of a reasonable time.

What constitutes reasonable time depends upon the circumstances of the particular transaction.

Factors may include:

  • Nature of the subject matter
  • Nature of the transaction
  • Market conditions
  • Expected speed of communication
  • Conduct of the parties
  • Changes in circumstances

Example

A offers to sell B a commodity whose market price changes rapidly.

B waits for several months before attempting to accept the offer.

Depending on the circumstances, the offer may have already lapsed because an unreasonable period has passed.

Lapse Due to Failure of Condition Precedent

Under Section 6(3), a proposal is revoked by the failure of the acceptor to fulfill a condition precedent to acceptance.

A condition precedent is a condition that must be satisfied before acceptance can become effective.

Example

A offers to sell a machine to B, stating:

“The offer will remain open if you deposit ₹1 lakh by 10 October.”

B fails to make the required deposit.

If the deposit was expressly made a condition precedent to acceptance, the offer may lapse.

Lapse Due to Death or Insanity of Offeror

Under Section 6(4), a proposal is revoked by the death or insanity of the proposer if the fact of the proposer’s death or insanity comes to the knowledge of the acceptor before acceptance.

The knowledge requirement is important.

Example

A offers to sell property to B.

Before B accepts, A dies.

If B learns of A’s death before accepting, the offer is revoked under Section 6(4).

The mere fact of death is not sufficient under this provision unless the fact comes to the knowledge of the acceptor before acceptance.

Lapse by Rejection

An offer may come to an end when the offeree expressly rejects it.

Example

A offers to sell his house to B for ₹40 lakh.

B replies:

“I do not wish to purchase the house.”

The offer has been rejected.

B cannot ordinarily revive the old offer simply by changing his mind later.

If A still wishes to sell the house, A may make a fresh offer.

Lapse by Counter Offer

A counter offer generally terminates the original offer.

Example

A offers to sell a car for ₹6 lakh.

B replies:

“I will purchase it for ₹5.5 lakh.”

B has made a counter offer.

The original ₹6 lakh offer is generally treated as rejected.

If B later says:

“I accept your original offer of ₹6 lakh,”

he ordinarily cannot do so unless A has renewed or continued the original offer.

Hyde v. Wrench (1840)

Principle

A counter offer generally amounts to rejection of the original offer and prevents its subsequent acceptance unless it is renewed.

This case is a leading authority for the effect of a counter offer.

Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.

Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.

Join WhatsApp Channel

Lapse by Revocation

An offer can also come to an end through revocation under Sections 5 and 6.

Example

A offers to sell land to B for ₹20 lakh.

Before B accepts, A communicates:

“I withdraw my offer.”

The offer is revoked and B cannot subsequently accept it.

The distinction is that revocation is an active withdrawal by the offeror, whereas lapse may occur automatically because of expiry of time or another legal event.

Lapse Due to Failure of Acceptance in the Prescribed Manner

Where the offer specifies a particular mode or condition of acceptance, failure to comply with the requirements may prevent effective acceptance.

However, this should be distinguished from Section 7’s rules concerning the manner of acceptance. A deviation does not automatically mean that the offer has permanently lapsed in every situation.

The precise terms of the offer and the conduct of the parties must be considered.

Lapse of General Offer

A general offer may also lapse.

For example, A publicly offers:

“₹10,000 to anyone who returns my lost dog by 1 December.”

If the dog is not returned by the specified date, the offer may lapse according to its terms.

A person cannot ordinarily accept the offer after the specified period has expired.

Lapse of Offer vs Revocation

These concepts are closely related but should be distinguished.

Lapse of OfferRevocation of Offer
Offer comes to an end because of expiry or another legal circumstanceOffer is withdrawn by the offeror
May occur automaticallyNormally requires communication of withdrawal
Example: specified time expiresExample: offeror says “I withdraw my offer”
Section 6 is particularly relevantSections 5 and 6 are particularly relevant
No fresh acceptance is possible after lapseNo acceptance is possible after effective revocation

Lapse of Offer vs Rejection

LapseRejection
Offer ends due to expiry or another legal eventOfferee expressly or impliedly refuses the offer
May occur without an express refusalUsually involves conduct or communication by offeree
Example: acceptance period expiresExample: “I do not accept your offer”
Governed particularly by Section 6Follows from principles of offer and acceptance

Lapse of Offer vs Counter Offer

LapseCounter Offer
Existing offer comes to an endOfferee makes a new offer
May result from expiry of timeResults from proposing different terms
No new offer is necessarily createdNew offer is created
Example: offer expires on 10 October“I will buy it for ₹5 lakh instead of ₹6 lakh”

Effect of Lapse

Once an offer has lapsed:

  • it cannot ordinarily be accepted;
  • the offeree loses the power to accept that offer;
  • any purported acceptance is generally ineffective;
  • the offeror may make a fresh offer; and
  • a new offer must be accepted according to the ordinary rules of contract formation.

Example

A offers B a laptop for ₹50,000, with acceptance required by 5 October.

B attempts to accept on 8 October.

If the offer had already lapsed on 5 October, B’s communication does not create a contract by accepting the old offer.

Important Sections

SectionRelevance
Section 2(a)Definition of proposal
Section 4Communication of proposal, acceptance and revocation
Section 5Revocation of proposal
Section 6Modes by which a proposal may be revoked or come to an end
Section 7Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified

Important Cases

Ramsgate Victoria Hotel Co. v. Montefiore (1866)

Principle: An offer may lapse when it is not accepted within a reasonable time.

The case is particularly associated with the principle that an offer cannot remain open indefinitely where no specific period has been prescribed.

Hyde v. Wrench (1840)

Principle: A counter offer generally terminates the original offer.

Byrne v. Van Tienhoven (1880)

Principle: Revocation must be communicated to the offeree; an uncommunicated revocation does not ordinarily terminate the offer.

Key Points for Examination

  • Lapse of offer means the offer has come to an end and can no longer be accepted.
  • Section 6 is the principal statutory provision.
  • An offer lapses when the specified time expires.
  • An offer may lapse after a reasonable time where no period is specified.
  • Failure to fulfill a condition precedent can terminate the proposal.
  • Death or insanity of the proposer can revoke the offer if the fact becomes known to the acceptor before acceptance.
  • Rejection of an offer can bring it to an end.
  • A counter offer generally terminates the original offer.
  • Revocation can also terminate an offer.
  • Ramsgate Victoria Hotel Co. v. Montefiore is important for lapse by passage of reasonable time.
  • Hyde v. Wrench is important for lapse/termination through counter offer.
  • After lapse, the old offer cannot ordinarily be accepted; a fresh offer is required.

Quick Revision

Main Ways an Offer May Lapse

1. Expiry of specified time
The time fixed by the offeror expires.

2. Expiry of reasonable time
No period is fixed, but an unreasonable delay occurs.

3. Failure of condition precedent
A required condition for acceptance is not fulfilled.

4. Death or insanity of proposer
The fact becomes known to the acceptor before acceptance.

5. Rejection
The offeree rejects the offer.

6. Counter offer
The offeree proposes different terms.

7. Effective revocation
The offeror withdraws the offer before valid acceptance.

Easy Formula

Offer → Expiry / Rejection / Condition Failure / Other Legal Event → Lapse → No Acceptance

Conclusion

Lapse of offer refers to the termination of an offer by expiry of time or by another event recognized by law. Section 6 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 identifies important circumstances in which a proposal comes to an end, including expiry of the prescribed or reasonable time, failure of a condition precedent, and death or insanity of the proposer when known to the acceptor before acceptance.

The central rule is:

Once an offer has lapsed, it cannot ordinarily be accepted unless the offeror makes or renews a fresh offer.