Communication of Offer

Published: 9 min read

Communication of offer refers to bringing an offer to the knowledge of the person to whom it is made. An offer cannot ordinarily be accepted unless it has been communicated to the offeree.

Communication is therefore an essential part of the formation of a contract. A person cannot accept an offer of which they have no knowledge.

The basic principle is:

No communication of offer → No knowledge of offer → No valid acceptance

Meaning of Communication of Offer

Section 2(a) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 defines a proposal as a person’s willingness to do or abstain from doing something with a view to obtaining the assent of another.

For a proposal to operate as an offer capable of acceptance, it must be communicated to the intended offeree.

Communication may take place through:

  • Spoken words
  • Written communication
  • Letter
  • Email
  • Telephone
  • Electronic messages
  • Conduct, where the circumstances legally permit it

The important requirement is that the offeree must have knowledge of the offer before attempting to accept it.

Importance of Communication

Communication of an offer is important because acceptance requires knowledge of the proposal.

For example:

A secretly decides to sell his car to B for ₹5 lakh but does not communicate this to B.

B cannot accept A’s undisclosed intention because B has no knowledge of the offer.

Therefore, no contract can arise merely from A’s private intention.

Communication Must Reach the Offeree

The offer must be communicated to the person whose assent is sought.

Example

A sends a letter to B:

“I offer to sell my laptop to you for ₹50,000.”

Once the offer is communicated to B, B can accept it according to law.

If B has never received or otherwise learned of the offer, there can generally be no valid acceptance based on that offer.

Communication of Offer and Knowledge

Knowledge of the offer is particularly important where acceptance takes place through performance.

For example:

A announces a reward of ₹10,000 for finding his lost dog.

B finds the dog without knowing about the reward and returns it to A.

B generally cannot claim the reward merely on the basis of having performed the condition because B had no knowledge of the offer when performing it.

This principle is clearly illustrated by Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913).

Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)

Facts and Principle

A person’s nephew went missing. The plaintiff was sent to search for him. While the plaintiff was searching, the defendant announced a reward for finding the missing boy.

The plaintiff found the boy but had not known about the reward when he undertook the search.

The court held that the plaintiff was not entitled to the reward because he had performed the act without knowledge of the offer.

Legal Principle

Knowledge of an offer is necessary for valid acceptance.

A person cannot accept an offer of which they were unaware.

This is one of the most important cases for communication of offer.

Modes of Communication of Offer

1. Oral Communication

An offer may be communicated through spoken words.

Example:

A tells B:

“I will sell my motorcycle to you for ₹80,000.”

The offer is communicated orally.

2. Written Communication

An offer may be communicated through a written document, letter, notice or other written communication.

Example:

A sends B a letter offering to sell a plot for ₹20 lakh.

3. Electronic Communication

Modern offers may be communicated through:

  • Email
  • SMS
  • Online platforms
  • Electronic business correspondence
  • Other digital communications

For example:

A emails B:

“We offer to supply 500 units at ₹200 per unit.”

The offer is communicated electronically.

4. Communication Through Conduct

In certain circumstances, an offer may be communicated through conduct.

However, the circumstances must demonstrate a legally recognizable offer and the relevant person must have knowledge of it.

Communication of General Offer

A general offer is made to the public or an unspecified class of persons.

Communication of a general offer may take place through:

  • Newspaper advertisement
  • Public notice
  • Website
  • Public announcement
  • Other suitable means

Example

A publishes:

“₹10,000 reward to anyone who returns my lost dog.”

The offer is communicated to the public through the advertisement.

However, a person seeking to accept the offer by performance must generally have knowledge of the offer.

Communication of Offer vs Communication of Acceptance

These should be clearly distinguished.

Communication of OfferCommunication of Acceptance
Brings the proposal to the knowledge of the offereeCommunicates assent to the offeror
Necessary before acceptance can occurNecessary for formation of contract, subject to statutory rules
Initiates the offer-and-acceptance processCompletes the process when legally effective
Section 2(a) is relevantSections 3, 4 and 7 are particularly relevant
Offeree must know of the offerOfferor must receive legally effective acceptance

Communication Through Post

The Indian Contract Act contains specific rules concerning the communication of proposals and acceptances.

Under Section 4, communication of a proposal is complete when it comes to the knowledge of the person to whom it is made.

Example

A posts a letter offering to sell his house to B.

The communication of the proposal is complete when the letter reaches B and comes to B’s knowledge.

The important point is:

Communication of proposal is complete when it reaches the knowledge of the offeree.

Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.

Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.

Join WhatsApp Channel

Communication of Offer and Revocation

Communication is also relevant to revocation.

Under Section 5, a proposal may be revoked before communication of acceptance is complete against the proposer, subject to the statutory rules.

Section 6 specifies the modes through which a proposal may be revoked.

A revocation must itself be communicated according to law.

Communication of Offer Through an Agent

An offer may also be communicated through an authorized agent or intermediary.

For example:

A instructs his agent to offer B a property for ₹30 lakh.

The agent communicates the offer to B.

The offer has thereby been communicated to B through the agent.

Communication Must Be Clear and Certain

The communication should be sufficiently clear to enable the offeree to understand what is being proposed.

For example:

“I may sell my car sometime next month at a reasonable price.”

This is generally too uncertain to constitute a definite offer.

In contrast:

“I offer to sell my car to you for ₹4 lakh.”

is sufficiently definite in its basic terms.

Communication therefore involves not merely transmitting words but communicating a legally identifiable proposal.

Communication of Offer in Electronic Contracts

Electronic communication has become particularly important in modern commercial transactions.

An offer may be communicated through:

  • Email
  • E-commerce platforms
  • Electronic purchase orders
  • Business portals
  • Digital communications

The Information Technology Act, 2000 recognizes electronic transactions, while the Indian Contract Act continues to govern the basic principles of offer, acceptance and contract formation.

Example

A company sends an email:

“We offer to supply 1,000 units at ₹500 per unit.”

The email communicates the offer to the recipient.

If the recipient validly accepts the offer, a contract may arise subject to the other requirements of contract law.

Communication of Offer and Advertisement

Not every advertisement is an offer.

An ordinary advertisement may merely constitute an invitation to offer.

For example:

“iPhone available for ₹70,000.”

This generally invites customers to make offers.

However, an advertisement that clearly constitutes a general offer must be communicated to the relevant public in an appropriate manner.

Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893) is the classic illustration of an advertisement functioning as a general offer.

Communication of Offer vs Intention

A private intention is not the same as a communicated offer.

Example

A thinks:

“I should sell my car to B for ₹5 lakh.”

This is merely an intention.

A tells B:

“I offer to sell my car to you for ₹5 lakh.”

This is a communicated proposal, assuming the other requirements are satisfied.

Thus:

Intention ≠ Offer

Communicated intention satisfying Section 2(a) = Proposal/Offer

Communication of Offer in General and Specific Offers

Specific Offer

A specific offer is communicated directly to the identified offeree.

Example:

A sends B an email offering to sell a laptop for ₹40,000.

B is the intended offeree.

General Offer

A general offer is communicated to the public or an unspecified class.

Example:

A publicly announces a reward for returning lost property.

Anyone who has knowledge of the offer and fulfills its conditions may potentially accept it.

Important Sections

SectionRelevance
Section 2(a)Defines proposal
Section 2(b)Defines acceptance and promise
Section 3Communication of proposals, acceptances and revocations
Section 4When communication of proposal, acceptance and revocation is complete
Section 5Revocation of proposals and acceptances
Section 6Modes of revocation of proposal
Section 7Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified

Important Cases

Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)

Principle: Knowledge of the offer is necessary for valid acceptance.

Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893)

Principle: A sufficiently definite advertisement can constitute a general offer capable of acceptance by performance.

Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)

Principle: In instantaneous communications, such as telephone communications, the rules concerning when acceptance is communicated are different from those applicable to postal communication.

The case is important for understanding communication in modern forms of immediate communication.

Key Points for Examination

  • Communication is essential for an offer to become capable of acceptance.
  • Under Section 4, communication of a proposal is complete when it comes to the knowledge of the person to whom it is made.
  • A person cannot ordinarily accept an offer of which they have no knowledge.
  • Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt is the leading Indian case.
  • Offers may be communicated orally, in writing, electronically or through appropriate conduct.
  • A general offer must be appropriately communicated to the public.
  • An ordinary advertisement is generally an invitation to offer, not an offer.
  • Communication of offer must be distinguished from communication of acceptance.
  • A private intention to contract is not an offer until it is communicated.
  • Sections 2(a), 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 are particularly relevant.

Quick Revision

Communication of Offer

Proposal made → Communication to offeree → Knowledge of offer → Offer can be accepted

Example

A sends B an offer to sell a car for ₹5 lakh.

  • A merely thinks about selling → No offer
  • A sends the offer to B → Offer communicated
  • B receives/learns of the offer → B has knowledge
  • B validly accepts → Contract may arise

Golden Rule

An offer must be communicated before it can be accepted.

Conclusion

Communication of offer is a fundamental requirement of contract formation. The offeree must ordinarily have knowledge of the proposal before acceptance can take place. Section 4 expressly provides that communication of a proposal is complete when it comes to the knowledge of the person to whom it is made.

The principle is most clearly demonstrated by Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt, where performance without knowledge of the reward offer did not amount to valid acceptance.

Thus, the basic sequence is:

Offer → Communication → Knowledge → Acceptance → Contract