Revocation of offer means the withdrawal or cancellation of an offer by the offeror before it has been validly accepted.
- Meaning of Revocation of Offer
- Section 5: Revocation of Proposal
- Section 6: Modes of Revocation
- 1. Revocation by Communication of Notice
- Byrne v. Van Tienhoven (1880)
- 2. Revocation by Lapse of Time
- 3. Revocation by Failure of Condition Precedent
- 4. Revocation by Death or Insanity of Offeror
- Revocation by Counter Offer
- Revocation by Rejection
- Revocation vs Lapse of Offer
- Revocation vs Rejection
- Revocation vs Counter Offer
- Revocation Through Indirect Information
- Revocation of General Offer
- Revocation and Acceptance
- Revocation in Postal Communication
- Revocation of Acceptance
- Important Sections
- Important Cases
- Key Points for Examination
- Quick Revision
- Conclusion
Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a proposal can generally be revoked before the communication of its acceptance is complete as against the proposer. The main provisions governing revocation are Sections 5 and 6.
The basic principle is:
Offer → Revocation before valid acceptance → Offer comes to an end
But:
Offer → Valid acceptance → Revocation is generally too late
Meaning of Revocation of Offer
When a person makes an offer, the offeror is generally free to withdraw it before the offer has been accepted in accordance with law.
Example
A offers to sell his car to B for ₹5 lakh.
Before B validly accepts the offer, A informs B:
“I withdraw my offer.”
The offer has been revoked and B can no longer accept that offer.
Section 5: Revocation of Proposal
Section 5 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 provides that a proposal may be revoked at any time before the communication of its acceptance is complete as against the proposer, but not afterwards.
Therefore, the crucial question is when acceptance becomes complete against the proposer.
Under Section 4, in the case of postal communication, communication of acceptance is complete as against the proposer when it is put into a course of transmission to him, so as to be out of the power of the acceptor.
Example
A posts an offer to B.
B receives the offer and posts his acceptance.
Once B has properly posted the acceptance, communication of acceptance is generally complete against A.
A cannot ordinarily revoke the offer after that point.
Section 6: Modes of Revocation
Section 6 specifically provides several ways in which a proposal may be revoked.
An offer is revoked:
- By communication of notice of revocation
- By lapse of the prescribed or reasonable time
- By failure of a condition precedent to acceptance
- By death or insanity of the proposer, if the fact comes to the knowledge of the acceptor before acceptance
These are important examination points.
1. Revocation by Communication of Notice
The offeror may expressly communicate to the offeree that the offer is withdrawn.
Example
A offers to sell his house to B for ₹50 lakh.
Before B accepts, A tells B:
“I withdraw my offer.”
The offer is revoked.
However, revocation must be communicated to the offeree.
A cannot effectively revoke an offer merely by privately deciding to withdraw it while B remains unaware of the revocation.
Byrne v. Van Tienhoven (1880)
Facts and Principle
The defendant sent an offer by post. Later, the defendant posted a letter revoking the offer. Before the revocation reached the plaintiff, the plaintiff accepted the original offer.
The court held that the revocation was ineffective until it was communicated to the offeree.
Legal Principle
Revocation of an offer must be communicated to the offeree before acceptance.
Posting a revocation is not necessarily sufficient; the revocation must reach the offeree in accordance with the applicable communication rules.
2. Revocation by Lapse of Time
An offer may be revoked by the expiry of the prescribed time.
If the offeror specifies a particular period during which the offer remains open, the offer normally expires when that period ends.
Example
A offers to sell a machine to B and states:
“This offer remains open until 10 October.”
If B does not accept within the specified period, the offer lapses.
Even where no specific period is prescribed, an offer may lapse after a reasonable period, depending on the circumstances.
What Is a Reasonable Time?
There is no universal period.
It depends on factors such as:
- Nature of the transaction
- Subject matter of the offer
- Market conditions
- Method of communication
- Conduct of the parties
An offer concerning rapidly changing goods may naturally have a shorter reasonable period than an offer concerning a long-term transaction.
3. Revocation by Failure of Condition Precedent
An offer may be revoked when the offeree fails to fulfill a condition that must be satisfied before acceptance can become effective.
Example
A offers to sell a property to B provided that B deposits ₹2 lakh as earnest money by a specified date.
B fails to make the required deposit.
If the deposit is a condition precedent to acceptance, the offer may cease to be capable of acceptance.
4. Revocation by Death or Insanity of Offeror
Under Section 6, an offer is revoked by the death or insanity of the proposer if the fact of the proposer’s death or insanity comes to the knowledge of the acceptor before acceptance.
The important point is that the acceptor must have knowledge of the death or insanity before acceptance.
Example
A offers to sell a property to B.
Before B accepts, A dies.
If B accepts without knowing about A’s death, the statutory rule concerning revocation by death operates differently from a situation where B has already learned of A’s death before attempting acceptance.
Therefore, the knowledge of the acceptor is important.
Revocation by Counter Offer
A proposal may also come to an end when the offeree makes a counter offer instead of accepting the original offer.
Example
A offers to sell his car to B for ₹6 lakh.
B replies:
“I will buy it for ₹5.5 lakh.”
B has made a counter offer rather than accepting A’s offer.
The original offer is generally treated as rejected.
Hyde v. Wrench (1840) is the leading case on this principle.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp ChannelRevocation by Rejection
An offer may also come to an end when the offeree clearly rejects it.
Example
A offers to sell land to B for ₹20 lakh.
B replies:
“I do not want to buy it.”
B has rejected the offer.
If B later attempts to accept the original offer, he ordinarily cannot do so unless the offer is renewed or otherwise remains available.
Revocation vs Lapse of Offer
Revocation and lapse are different concepts.
| Revocation | Lapse |
|---|---|
| Offer is withdrawn | Offer comes to an end due to expiry or another legal event |
| Usually initiated by offeror | May occur automatically |
| Notice of withdrawal may be given | May result from expiry of time |
| Section 5 and Section 6 | Section 6 and surrounding principles |
Revocation vs Rejection
| Revocation | Rejection |
|---|---|
| Usually done by the offeror | Done by the offeree |
| Withdraws the existing offer | Refuses the existing offer |
| Offeror communicates withdrawal | Offeree communicates refusal |
| Example: “I withdraw my offer” | Example: “I do not accept your offer” |
Revocation vs Counter Offer
| Revocation | Counter Offer |
|---|---|
| Offeror withdraws the offer | Offeree proposes different terms |
| Ends the offer | Generally rejects the original offer and creates a new offer |
| Governed primarily by Sections 5 and 6 | Follows from Section 7 |
| Example: “I withdraw my offer” | “I will buy it at a lower price” |
Revocation Through Indirect Information
An important principle is that revocation may, in appropriate circumstances, be communicated through a reliable third party.
Dickinson v. Dodds (1876)
Facts and Principle
The plaintiff received an offer that was stated to remain open until a particular time. Before the plaintiff accepted, he learned through a reliable third party that the property had been sold to someone else.
The court held that the offer had effectively been revoked because the plaintiff had reliable knowledge that the offeror had acted inconsistently with the continuation of the offer.
Legal Principle
An offer may be effectively revoked when the offeree receives reliable information that the offer has been withdrawn or the subject matter has been dealt with inconsistently with the offer.
Revocation of General Offer
Revocation of a general offer requires consideration of how the original offer was communicated.
If a general offer was made publicly, its revocation should generally be communicated through a method capable of bringing the revocation to the knowledge of the relevant public or persons who may accept it.
Example
A publicly announces:
“₹10,000 reward for returning my lost dog.”
A later publicly announces that the reward is withdrawn.
The revocation should be communicated appropriately before someone accepts the original offer in accordance with law.
Revocation and Acceptance
This is one of the most important distinctions in offer and acceptance.
Before Acceptance
An offer can generally be revoked, subject to Section 5.
After Valid Acceptance
Once acceptance has become legally effective against the proposer, the proposer cannot ordinarily revoke the offer because the contract formation process has already reached the relevant stage.
Example
A offers to sell goods to B.
B validly accepts the offer.
A then says:
“I revoke my offer.”
The revocation is too late because acceptance has already become legally effective.
Revocation in Postal Communication
The Indian Contract Act contains special rules concerning postal communication.
Consider:
- A posts an offer to B.
- B receives the offer.
- B posts his acceptance.
- B’s acceptance enters the postal transmission system.
- A attempts to revoke the offer.
Under Section 5 read with Section 4, the timing of the acceptance and revocation becomes important.
For the proposer, acceptance is generally complete when the acceptance is properly put into transmission and is beyond the acceptor’s control.
This is why the postal rule is important in understanding revocation.
Revocation of Acceptance
Section 5 also deals with revocation of acceptance.
Acceptance may be revoked at any time before the communication of acceptance is complete as against the acceptor, but not afterwards.
Example
B posts acceptance to A.
Before the acceptance reaches A, B sends a faster communication revoking his acceptance.
If the revocation reaches A before the acceptance does, the statutory requirements concerning revocation of acceptance may permit the revocation.
This is different from revocation of the original offer.
Important Sections
| Section | Relevance |
|---|---|
| Section 4 | Determines when communication of proposal, acceptance and revocation is complete |
| Section 5 | Revocation of proposal and acceptance |
| Section 6 | Modes of revocation of proposal |
| Section 7 | Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified |
| Section 8 | Acceptance by performance of conditions or receiving consideration |
Important Cases
Byrne v. Van Tienhoven (1880)
Principle: Revocation must be communicated to the offeree; merely sending a revocation is not necessarily enough.
Dickinson v. Dodds (1876)
Principle: Reliable knowledge of the offeror’s inconsistent action may amount to effective revocation.
Hyde v. Wrench (1840)
Principle: A counter offer generally terminates the original offer.
Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913)
Principle: Knowledge of the offer is necessary for acceptance, illustrating the importance of communication in offer and acceptance.
Key Points for Examination
- Revocation means withdrawal of an offer.
- Sections 5 and 6 are the principal provisions.
- An offer can generally be revoked before acceptance becomes complete against the proposer.
- Revocation must be communicated to the offeree.
- An offer may end through notice of revocation.
- It may lapse through expiry of time.
- Failure of a condition precedent may prevent acceptance.
- Death or insanity of the proposer may revoke the offer if the fact becomes known to the offeree before acceptance.
- A counter offer generally terminates the original offer.
- Rejection may also bring an offer to an end.
- Byrne v. Van Tienhoven is important for communication of revocation.
- Dickinson v. Dodds is important for indirect/reliable knowledge of revocation.
- Hyde v. Wrench is important for counter offers.
- Revocation after legally effective acceptance is generally too late.
Quick Revision
Section 6 — Four Main Modes
1. Notice of revocation
Offeror communicates withdrawal.
2. Lapse of time
Specified or reasonable time expires.
3. Failure of condition precedent
A required condition for acceptance is not fulfilled.
4. Death or insanity
The proposer dies or becomes insane and the fact becomes known to the acceptor before acceptance.
Easy Formula
Offer → Revocation communicated before valid acceptance → Offer ends
But:
Offer → Valid acceptance → Contract formation → Revocation of offer generally not possible
Conclusion
Revocation of offer is the legal withdrawal of a proposal before it has been validly accepted. Sections 5 and 6 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 establish the principal rules governing revocation.
The most important point is that an offeror generally has the right to withdraw an offer before acceptance becomes complete against the proposer, but the revocation must be legally communicated. An offer can also come to an end through lapse of time, failure of a condition precedent, or death or insanity of the proposer in the circumstances specified by Section 6.
The core rule can be remembered as:
An offer is revocable before legally effective acceptance, but not after.