A counter offer arises when the person to whom an offer is made does not accept the original offer as it stands but proposes different or modified terms instead.
- Meaning of Counter Offer
- Essential Features of a Counter Offer
- Counter Offer and Section 7
- Hyde v. Wrench (1840)
- Counter Offer vs Mere Inquiry
- Counter Offer vs Acceptance
- Counter Offer vs Cross Offer
- Counter Offer vs Conditional Acceptance
- Effect of a Counter Offer
- Example of the Complete Process
- Counter Offer in Negotiations
- Counter Offer and Communication
- Counter Offer in Electronic Contracts
- Important Cases
- Key Points for Examination
- Conclusion
A counter offer is therefore not an acceptance of the original offer. It generally amounts to a rejection of the original offer and the making of a new offer.
The principle can be remembered as:
Original Offer → Modified Response = Counter Offer
Whereas:
Original Offer → Absolute Acceptance = Acceptance
Meaning of Counter Offer
The Indian Contract Act, 1872 does not separately define the expression “counter offer.” The concept follows from the rules relating to proposal and acceptance, particularly Sections 2(a), 2(b) and 7.
Under Section 7, acceptance must be absolute and unqualified.
Therefore, if the offeree changes, adds to, removes, or qualifies the terms of the original offer, the response will generally not constitute acceptance. Instead, it becomes a counter offer.
Example
A offers to sell his car to B for ₹5 lakh.
B replies:
“I will buy your car for ₹4.5 lakh.”
B has not accepted A’s offer. B has made a counter offer of ₹4.5 lakh.
If A accepts B’s counter offer, a contract may then be formed, provided all other requirements of a valid contract are satisfied.
Essential Features of a Counter Offer
1. There Must Be an Original Offer
A counter offer can arise only when there is an existing offer.
For example:
A offers to sell a house to B for ₹50 lakh.
This is the original offer.
2. The Offeree Changes the Terms
The response must introduce a change or qualification in the original terms.
For example:
A offers to sell a car for ₹6 lakh.
B says:
“I will buy it for ₹5.5 lakh.”
The price has been changed, so B has made a counter offer.
3. It Is Not Absolute Acceptance
Section 7 requires acceptance to be absolute and unqualified.
If the offeree says:
“I accept, provided you reduce the price.”
this is not an absolute acceptance. It is a counter offer.
4. The Original Offer Is Generally Terminated
A counter offer generally amounts to rejection of the original offer.
Once the original offer is rejected by a counter offer, the offeree cannot ordinarily later accept the original offer as though it were still open, unless the offeror renews it or otherwise indicates that it remains available.
5. A Counter Offer Becomes a New Offer
The person making the counter offer becomes the offeror in relation to the counter offer.
The original offeror becomes the offeree.
Example
A → offers ₹10 lakh to B
B → counter offers ₹9 lakh to A
Now:
- B is the offeror regarding ₹9 lakh.
- A is the offeree.
- If A accepts ₹9 lakh, a contract may arise.
Counter Offer and Section 7
Section 7 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 provides that acceptance must be:
- absolute, and
- unqualified.
Therefore, an acceptance that modifies the terms of the original offer is generally not valid acceptance.
Example
A:
“I will sell 1,000 units at ₹100 each.”
B:
“I accept, but at ₹90 each.”
B has not accepted A’s offer.
B has made a counter offer to purchase the goods at ₹90 each.
Hyde v. Wrench (1840)
Facts and Principle
In Hyde v. Wrench, the defendant offered to sell a property for £1,000.
The plaintiff offered to purchase it for £950. The defendant rejected that proposal. The plaintiff later attempted to accept the original offer of £1,000.
The court held that the counter offer had terminated the original offer, so the plaintiff could not subsequently accept the original offer.
Legal Principle
The case establishes the important rule:
A counter offer amounts to rejection of the original offer and creates a new offer.
This is the leading classic authority for the law relating to counter offers.
Counter Offer vs Mere Inquiry
Not every question or request made by the offeree is necessarily a counter offer.
A mere inquiry about the terms of an offer does not necessarily reject the offer.
Example
A offers to sell a property for ₹50 lakh.
B asks:
“Would you consider selling it for ₹47 lakh?”
Depending on the circumstances, this may merely be an inquiry rather than a definite counter offer.
But if B says:
“I will buy the property for ₹47 lakh.”
this is a definite counter offer.
The distinction depends on whether the communication demonstrates a definite intention to propose different terms or merely seeks information or clarification.
Counter Offer vs Acceptance
| Counter Offer | Acceptance |
|---|---|
| Changes or qualifies the original terms | Accepts the original terms |
| Not absolute acceptance | Must be absolute and unqualified |
| Generally rejects the original offer | Assents to the original offer |
| Creates a new offer | May create a binding contract |
| The original offeror becomes offeree | The original offeror becomes promisor if contract is formed |
| Governed by the principle in Section 7 | Section 7 directly requires absolute and unqualified acceptance |
Example
Original offer:
A offers to sell a laptop for ₹60,000.
Acceptance:
B: “I accept your offer for ₹60,000.”
Counter offer:
B: “I will buy it for ₹55,000.”
Counter Offer vs Cross Offer
These concepts are particularly important because both involve two offers.
| Counter Offer | Cross Offer |
|---|---|
| Made in response to an existing offer | Made independently |
| The party knows about the original offer | Party is unaware of the other offer |
| Changes or modifies the original terms | Offers may contain identical terms |
| Generally terminates the original offer | Neither offer constitutes acceptance of the other |
| Hyde v. Wrench | Tinn v. Hoffman & Co. |
Simple Illustration
Counter Offer:
A → “I will sell for ₹5 lakh.”
B → “I will buy for ₹4.5 lakh.”
B knows about A’s offer.
Cross Offer:
A → “I will sell for ₹5 lakh.”
B, independently and without knowing A’s offer → “I will buy for ₹5 lakh.”
The first is a counter offer; the second involves cross offers.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp ChannelCounter Offer vs Conditional Acceptance
A counter offer can often appear in the form of a conditional acceptance.
Example
A offers to sell a machine for ₹10 lakh.
B says:
“I accept your offer if you include transportation at no additional cost.”
B has not given an absolute and unqualified acceptance.
The response is generally treated as a counter offer because it introduces an additional condition.
Thus:
Conditional acceptance → generally counter offer
Effect of a Counter Offer
The principal legal effects are:
1. Original Offer Is Rejected
The counter offer generally indicates that the offeree does not accept the original terms.
2. New Offer Is Created
The counter offer itself becomes a new proposal.
3. Original Offer Cannot Normally Be Accepted Later
Once rejected by a counter offer, the original offer generally cannot subsequently be accepted unless it is renewed or otherwise remains available through the conduct or communication of the offeror.
4. Acceptance of Counter Offer May Create a Contract
If the original offeror accepts the counter offer absolutely and all other requirements of a valid contract are satisfied, a contract may arise.
Example of the Complete Process
A offers to sell land to B for ₹20 lakh.
B responds:
“I will purchase it for ₹18 lakh.”
This is a counter offer.
Now A can:
Accept:
“I agree to sell it for ₹18 lakh.”
A contract may be formed.
Reject:
“I will not sell it for ₹18 lakh.”
No contract is formed.
Make another counter offer:
“I will sell it for ₹19 lakh.”
A has now made another offer to B.
B may then accept or reject that new offer.
Counter Offer in Negotiations
Counter offers are common in commercial negotiations.
For example:
- Seller offers goods for ₹10 lakh.
- Buyer offers ₹8 lakh.
- Seller proposes ₹9 lakh.
- Buyer accepts ₹9 lakh.
The parties may therefore move through several offers and counter offers before reaching final agreement.
The contract arises only when there is acceptance of a particular outstanding offer and the other requirements of a valid contract are satisfied.
Counter Offer and Communication
A counter offer must itself be communicated to the other party.
A person cannot ordinarily create contractual obligations merely by privately deciding to make a counter offer.
For example, A offers to sell a car for ₹5 lakh.
B privately decides:
“I will buy it for ₹4.5 lakh.”
Until this proposal is communicated in the legally relevant manner, it does not operate as a communicated counter offer.
Counter Offer in Electronic Contracts
Counter offers can also arise through:
- Email;
- Online negotiations;
- Business messaging platforms;
- Electronic purchase negotiations;
- Digital correspondence.
Example
Seller emails:
“100 units at ₹1,000 each.”
Buyer replies:
“We will purchase 100 units at ₹900 each.”
The buyer’s response is not acceptance of the original offer. It is a counter offer.
If the seller accepts the revised price, a contract may arise subject to the other requirements of contract formation.
Important Cases
Hyde v. Wrench (1840)
The leading authority on counter offers.
Principle: A counter offer generally terminates the original offer and cannot ordinarily be followed by acceptance of the original offer unless it is renewed.
Tinn v. Hoffman & Co. (1873)
Important for distinguishing a cross offer from a counter offer.
Principle: Independent matching offers do not constitute acceptance of each other.
Stevenson, Jacques & Co. v. McLean (1880)
This case is useful for distinguishing a mere inquiry from a counter offer.
Principle: A request for information or clarification does not necessarily amount to rejection of an offer or creation of a counter offer.
Key Points for Examination
- A counter offer is a new offer made in response to an existing offer.
- It generally involves a change, addition, or qualification of the original terms.
- A counter offer is not acceptance.
- Section 7 requires acceptance to be absolute and unqualified.
- A counter offer generally terminates or rejects the original offer.
- The counter offer becomes a new proposal.
- Acceptance of the counter offer may result in a contract.
- A mere inquiry about an offer is not necessarily a counter offer.
- Hyde v. Wrench (1840) is the leading case.
- Stevenson, Jacques & Co. v. McLean (1880) helps distinguish inquiry from counter offer.
- A counter offer is different from a cross offer, because a counter offer is made in response to an existing offer, whereas cross offers are made independently.
Conclusion
A counter offer occurs when an offeree responds to an offer by proposing different or modified terms. Since acceptance under Section 7 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 must be absolute and unqualified, such a response is generally not acceptance. Instead, it becomes a new offer and ordinarily terminates the original offer.
The leading principle from Hyde v. Wrench (1840) is that a counter offer rejects the original offer, unless the original offer is subsequently renewed.
The easiest way to remember it is:
Offer → Change in terms → Counter Offer → Original offer generally terminated
Whereas:
Offer → Absolute and unqualified acceptance → Contract may arise