An implied contract is a contract in which the agreement between the parties is inferred from their conduct, acts, circumstances or the nature of the transaction, rather than being expressly stated in words.
- Meaning of Implied Contract
- Statutory Basis
- How an Implied Contract Arises
- Essential Elements of an Implied Contract
- Common Examples of Implied Contracts
- Implied Contract vs Implied Terms
- Implied Contract vs Express Contract
- Implied Contract vs Quasi-Contract
- Implied Contract and Section 70
- Important Cases
- When Conduct Does Not Create an Implied Contract
- Advantages of Implied Contracts
- Limitations of Implied Contracts
- Difference Between Express and Implied Contracts
- Key Points for Examination
- Conclusion
Section 9 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 recognises implied promises. Where the proposal or acceptance of a promise is made otherwise than in words, the promise is said to be implied.
An implied contract is therefore based on what the parties do or the circumstances in which they act, rather than only on what they expressly say or write.
Meaning of Implied Contract
In an implied contract, the parties do not necessarily state their agreement in words. Their conduct indicates that they intend to enter into a contractual relationship.
Example
A enters a restaurant, orders food, eats the food and leaves after asking for the bill.
A may not have expressly said:
“I promise to pay for the food.”
However, from A’s conduct and the circumstances, an obligation to pay the price of the food can be inferred.
This is an example of an implied contractual relationship.
Statutory Basis
The primary statutory provision is Section 9 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
Section 9 distinguishes between express and implied promises:
- Where the proposal or acceptance is made in words, the promise is express.
- Where the proposal or acceptance is made otherwise than in words, the promise is implied.
Thus, the Act recognises that contractual obligations can arise not only from spoken or written words but also from conduct and circumstances.
How an Implied Contract Arises
An implied contract may arise from:
Conduct of the Parties
The actions of the parties may demonstrate their agreement.
Circumstances
The surrounding circumstances may indicate that the parties intended to create contractual obligations.
Course of Dealing
Repeated transactions between parties may establish an understanding regarding their contractual relationship.
Conduct in Commercial Transactions
Business practices and conduct may indicate acceptance of particular terms.
Essential Elements of an Implied Contract
Although the agreement is inferred rather than expressly stated, an implied contract must still satisfy the applicable requirements of a legally enforceable contract.
1. Offer or Proposal
There must be circumstances from which a proposal can be inferred.
Example
A taxi driver makes the taxi available for passengers at a recognised fare, and B enters the taxi and asks to be taken to a particular destination.
The conduct may indicate a proposal to provide transportation for the applicable fare.
2. Acceptance
Acceptance may be inferred from conduct.
B entering the taxi and taking the journey may indicate acceptance of the transportation service on the applicable terms.
3. Consideration
There must generally be consideration, subject to the exceptions recognised by law.
In the taxi example, the transportation service and payment of the fare represent the respective sides of the transaction.
4. Competency of Parties
The parties must generally satisfy Section 11.
They must:
- Have attained majority;
- Be of sound mind; and
- Not be disqualified from contracting by law.
5. Free Consent
Where consent is required, it must be free as contemplated by Section 14.
6. Lawful Object and Consideration
The object and consideration must satisfy Section 23.
The fact that an agreement is implied does not make an unlawful transaction enforceable.
7. Certainty
The terms inferred from the conduct and circumstances must be sufficiently certain to determine the parties’ rights and obligations.
Common Examples of Implied Contracts
Taxi or Auto-Rickshaw
A passenger enters a taxi and asks the driver to take them to a destination.
The passenger’s conduct indicates an intention to obtain transportation, while the driver’s conduct indicates an intention to provide it in return for the applicable fare.
Restaurant
A person enters a restaurant, orders food and consumes it.
The circumstances ordinarily indicate an obligation to pay the applicable price.
Public Transport
A passenger boards a bus and travels after paying or agreeing to pay the applicable fare.
The contractual relationship is largely inferred from the conduct of the passenger and transport provider.
Parking Facility
A person enters a paid parking facility and parks a vehicle under the facility’s stated conditions.
The conduct may give rise to contractual obligations concerning the parking service and payment.
Vending Machine
A person inserts money into a vending machine and selects a product.
The transaction may be understood through the conduct of the parties and the operation of the machine, rather than through an individually negotiated verbal agreement.
Implied Contract vs Implied Terms
An implied contract and an implied term in a contract are not necessarily the same thing.
An implied contract concerns the existence of contractual obligations inferred from conduct or circumstances.
An implied term, on the other hand, is a particular term that is inferred or incorporated into an otherwise existing contract.
Example
A and B expressly enter into a written service agreement. Certain obligations may be implied from the nature of the transaction or established legal principles.
The contract itself is express, even though some of its terms may be implied.
Implied Contract vs Express Contract
| Basis | Express Contract | Implied Contract |
|---|---|---|
| Communication | Terms are stated in words | Terms are inferred from conduct or circumstances |
| Section 9 | Express promise | Implied promise |
| Form | Oral or written | Usually inferred from conduct |
| Evidence | Words or written document | Conduct, circumstances and surrounding facts |
| Example | Written sale agreement | Taxi journey |
The key distinction is therefore:
Express contract → agreement communicated through words
Implied contract → agreement inferred from conduct or circumstances
Implied Contract vs Quasi-Contract
These concepts are often confused, but they are legally different.
| Implied Contract | Quasi-Contract |
|---|---|
| Based on an agreement inferred from conduct or circumstances | Not based on an actual agreement |
| Parties’ conduct indicates contractual intention | Obligation is imposed by law |
| Recognised through Section 9 principles | Sections 68–72 deal with certain relations resembling those created by contract |
| Example: taxi journey | Example: reimbursement under Section 70 |
A quasi-contract is therefore not simply another name for an implied contract.
Implied Contract and Section 70
Section 70 of the Indian Contract Act concerns a non-gratuitous act and creates an obligation to compensate in specified circumstances.
For example, if A lawfully does something for B, without intending to act gratuitously, and B enjoys the benefit of it, Section 70 may require B to compensate A or restore the thing done or delivered, depending upon the circumstances.
This is generally classified as a quasi-contractual obligation, not an ordinary implied contract.
This distinction is important because the obligation under Section 70 is imposed by law rather than being based on an inferred agreement between the parties.
Opportunities don’t wait. Neither should you.
Join 1 Lakh+ law students connected with Lexibal and stay updated with internships, opportunities, competitions and important updates.
Join WhatsApp ChannelImportant Cases
Upton Rural District Council v. Powell (1942)
This English case is commonly cited in discussions of implied contracts and emergency services.
A person called the fire brigade believing that he was entitled to its services under the applicable arrangement. The court recognised a contractual basis for payment in the circumstances.
The case illustrates how contractual obligations may sometimes be inferred from the conduct and circumstances of the parties.
Brogden v. Metropolitan Railway Co. (1877)
This English case is an important authority concerning acceptance by conduct.
The parties had been negotiating a written agreement, but continued to conduct their business according to its terms. Their conduct demonstrated acceptance of the contractual arrangement.
The case illustrates that contractual relationships may arise or become binding through conduct even where formal acceptance has not been separately communicated in words.
Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966)
The Supreme Court considered communication of acceptance in contracts formed through instantaneous communication.
The case is important for understanding how contractual obligations arise and when communication of acceptance becomes effective.
Although it primarily concerns communication of acceptance rather than implied contracts, it is useful when studying the formation of contractual relationships through forms of communication other than traditional written agreements.
When Conduct Does Not Create an Implied Contract
Conduct alone does not automatically establish a contract.
The circumstances must support the existence of a legally enforceable contractual relationship.
For example, merely receiving a benefit does not always mean that a person has entered into a contract. The court must examine:
- The intention and conduct of the parties;
- The surrounding circumstances;
- The nature of the transaction;
- Whether consideration exists;
- Whether the parties were competent;
- Whether consent was present; and
- Whether the object and terms are lawful and sufficiently certain.
Advantages of Implied Contracts
Practicality
They allow ordinary transactions to take place without requiring parties to negotiate every term verbally or in writing.
Convenience
Everyday transactions such as transportation, food services and parking can operate efficiently through conduct.
Recognition of Commercial Practice
Courts can consider established conduct and business practices when determining the contractual relationship between parties.
Flexibility
Contractual obligations can arise even when parties have not formally documented their agreement.
Limitations of Implied Contracts
The principal difficulty is determining the parties’ actual contractual intention and the terms of the relationship.
Disputes may arise regarding:
- Whether a contract existed;
- What terms were agreed;
- Whether conduct amounted to acceptance;
- What consideration was contemplated; and
- What obligations were actually undertaken.
Therefore, where a transaction is significant or complex, a written express contract generally provides greater certainty.
Difference Between Express and Implied Contracts
| Express Contract | Implied Contract |
|---|---|
| Agreement is expressed in words | Agreement is inferred from conduct or circumstances |
| May be oral or written | Generally arises from acts or circumstances |
| Terms are directly communicated | Terms are determined from surrounding circumstances |
| Easier to identify the agreed terms | Terms may require interpretation |
| Example: written employment agreement | Example: passenger using a taxi service |
Key Points for Examination
- An implied contract is one where contractual obligations are inferred from conduct or circumstances.
- Section 9 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 recognises implied promises.
- An implied contract is different from an express contract because its terms are not communicated entirely through words.
- An implied contract may arise from the conduct of both parties.
- Common examples include taxi journeys, restaurant transactions, public transport and parking services.
- An implied contract must still satisfy the applicable requirements of enforceability.
- An implied contract should not be confused with a quasi-contract.
- Quasi-contractual obligations under Sections 68–72 are imposed by law rather than arising from an actual agreement.
- An express contract may contain implied terms without becoming an implied contract.
- Conduct does not automatically create a contract; the surrounding circumstances must establish a legally enforceable relationship.
- Brogden v. Metropolitan Railway Co. is a classic authority on acceptance through conduct.
- Upton Rural District Council v. Powell is commonly discussed in relation to implied contractual obligations.
Conclusion
An implied contract is a contractual relationship in which the agreement is inferred from the conduct of the parties or the surrounding circumstances, rather than being expressly stated in words.
Section 9 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 provides the statutory basis for recognising implied promises. Such contracts are particularly important in everyday transactions where parties do not formally state their agreement but their conduct clearly indicates an intention to enter into a transaction.
The most important distinction to remember is:
Express Contract = Agreement communicated through words
Implied Contract = Agreement inferred from conduct or circumstances
Quasi-Contract = Obligation imposed by law without an actual agreement